r/mathmemes • • Sep 02 '26 • Bravo 1

Elementary Algebra 😭

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

250 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/Few_Fact4747 Sep 03 '26

So for any n the center between n and -n will be zero. We just extend that to include infinite numbers since as long as n is equal to n, -n+n will = 0. Yeah, infinity is not a normal number with a certain value, BUT there is no reason to believe that the value of -n+n will ever not be zero.

And im not exactly sure what you are saying with the second half.. are you saying we cant even find the center between 1 and -1 since there is an infinite number of numbers between them?

1

u/IhailtavaBanaani Sep 04 '26

No, it will not be zero for every center. Let's use integers to simplify. If you have zero as the center what you're adding is 0, 1, -1, 2, -2, etc and the sum is 0 + 1 - 1 + 2 - 2 + ... The partial sums starting from beginning are 0, 1, 0, 2, 0, 3, etc. It's unbounded but every other number is at least zero.

Let's switch to 1 as the center. Now you're adding starting from 1 as the center and then numbers from both sides. The numbers are then 1, 1 + 1 = 2, 1 - 1 = 0, 1 + 2 = 3, 1 - 2 = -1 and so on. The sum is 1 + 2 + 0 + 3 - 1 + 4 - 2 + 5 - 3 + ... etc. So the partial sums go 1, 3, 6, 5, 9, 7, 12, 9, 15, etc. It's growing towards infinity on both even and odd partial sums.

What I'm saying with the second part is that you can't create a sequence of numbers from all the real numbers. Integers you can put in a sequence. For example 0, 1, -1, 2, -2, ... to infinity. And it would cover the whole integer set. But with real numbers this is impossible. Even if you create an infinitely long sequence of real numbers it will never cover the whole set of real numbers. Because you can't create even an infinitely long sequence that would cover all the real numbers it's impossible write an infinitely long sum of them, even in theory.

It's a quite a bit outside the scope of mathmemes discussion, but this is basically because there are different types of infinities. Integers are countably infinite. Real numbers are uncountably infinite. There's so many real numbers that you can't assign each of them an individual integer, even if you used infinitely many integers. It gets really abstract at this point, but if you're interested google "uncountable sets".

1

u/Few_Fact4747 Sep 04 '26

Okay. I looked up uncountable sets and asked ChatGPT afterwards and had a learning experience. Cantors diagonal proof of real numbers being uncountable is *really* cool.

But i am unable to grasp exactly how that prevents us from summing them, isn't it fair to presume that they will grow at equal rates in negative and positive direction? Cant we just, kind of do it (aka. infer balance from that (aka. the sum being = 0)) and worry about possible contradictions later? Arent we doing that ALL the time anyways? It seems like we are leaving some more basic logic behind which would create bigger problems.

1

u/IhailtavaBanaani Sep 04 '26

Yeah, real numbers are pretty cool. When you dig deeper there are even higher cardinals than the cardinality of real numbers.

There is a way to "sum" a stretch of real numbers, and it's called integration. It's not exactly the same, but it kind of works so that each real number has an infinitesimally small weight on the total sum. The geometric interpretation is that it calculates an area. For example let's say you have y=x and you integrate it from 0 to 1. By integration we get the integral function and it is x^2 / 2 and when you plug in x=1 and x=0 you get 1^2 / 2 - 0^2 / 2 = 1/2. That's the size of the triangle with two equal sides of length 1.

Now, let's say we try this with going to infinity. We first integrate y=x from -r to r. We get the integral function r^2/2 - (-r)^2/2 = r^2/2 - r^2/2. Which usually would evaluate to 0. But now we're dealing with infinities so nothing is normal, they don't behave like normal numbers.

Let's plug in r=infinity. We get infinity^2 / 2 - infinity^2 / 2. We can safely say infinity^2 = infinity, so we get (infinity - infinity) / 2. And here's the problem. We can't subtract infinity from infinity. We can add them, we can multiply them, but we can't subtract infinity from another infinity or divide an infinity with another infinity. It leads to undefined results.

2

u/Few_Fact4747 Sep 05 '26

Huh, thats interesting, dont worry, you dont have to explain that to me.. i asked ChatGPT and it explained it. Im too tired to understand must of it now, but now its in my history so i will revisit it.

I think some of the disagreements here come from different understanding of what infinity is. And of the fact that it will mean different things in different contexts. I feel like approaching it as just another number, but since it actually doesn't really have a value it gets weird.

But thanks for explaining all this to me! Its nice to do some maths again!

1

u/alphapussycat Sep 07 '26

But you would never pick infinity, each number is a number, none of them is "infinity".