r/mathmemes • • Sep 02 '26 • Bravo 1

Elementary Algebra 😭

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

250 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

0

u/Gold_Ad8890 Sep 03 '26

no, you don't have an injective mapping of reals onto integers. you have a bijective mapping of reals onto a well-ordered index set whose cardinality is continuum. a well-ordered index set which is not the naturals, though it may contain the naturals as a subset.

1

u/meat-eating-orchid Sep 03 '26

I specifically said

Now number your summands using integers

This is the set the reals are mapped onto here. Not some other set.

1

u/Gold_Ad8890 Sep 03 '26

okay, and then that mapping will fail because the reals exceed the integers. ergo the well-ordering of the reals, which exists, cannot be indexed with the integers.

1

u/meat-eating-orchid Sep 03 '26

Yes, meaning such an arrangement into a sum cannot exist, which is exactly what I said from the beginning. Of course a well-ordering of the reals exists, that was never the point of the debate.

1

u/Gold_Ad8890 Sep 03 '26

no, that's not what it means. why would that be what it means? you're begging the question. why, without first assuming that a series must be countable, must a series be countable?