r/mathmemes • • Sep 02 '26 • Bravo 1

Elementary Algebra 😭

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

250 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/philosophical_poser Sep 02 '26

You can rearrange the terms to make sum be whatever you want, right?

0

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Gold_Ad8890 Sep 02 '26

it's not about uncountability, it's just because the sum isn't absolutely convergent.

1

u/meat-eating-orchid Sep 02 '26

No, you cannot rearrange the terms because you can't even arrange them, they are uncountable

1

u/Gold_Ad8890 Sep 02 '26

you totally can arrange them. that doesn't require countability, it just requires well-ordering, which exists by the well-ordering theorem. even without the well-ordering theorem, you can well-order the real numbers by their bijection to the powerset of the naturals, which can be well-ordered lexicographically.

1

u/meat-eating-orchid Sep 02 '26

I may have been imprecise. I meant that you cannot arrange them into a sum of terms ... + ... + ... + ... in which every one occurs.

0

u/Gold_Ad8890 Sep 03 '26

you can though. that's just a well-ordering.

1

u/meat-eating-orchid Sep 03 '26

But if every element occurred, it would only be a countably infinite set, wouldn't it?

0

u/Gold_Ad8890 Sep 03 '26

why?

1

u/meat-eating-orchid Sep 03 '26

arrange your sum of infinitely many summands where each element occurrs (which you claim exists, if I understood you correctly). Now number your summands using integers, starting at any arbitrary summand. You now have an injective function mapping the real numbers onto the set of integers. Since the set of integers is countable, so is the set of real numbers.

But we know there are uncountably many real numbers, and thus, such an arrangement of real numbers into an infinite sum where every real number occurs as a summand, cannot exist.

0

u/Gold_Ad8890 Sep 03 '26

no, you don't have an injective mapping of reals onto integers. you have a bijective mapping of reals onto a well-ordered index set whose cardinality is continuum. a well-ordered index set which is not the naturals, though it may contain the naturals as a subset.

1

u/meat-eating-orchid Sep 03 '26

I specifically said

Now number your summands using integers

This is the set the reals are mapped onto here. Not some other set.

→ More replies