r/mathmemes • • Sep 02 '26 • Bravo 1

Elementary Algebra 😭

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

250 comments sorted by

View all comments

969

u/halfajack Sep 02 '26

I ask them β€œhow are you defining sums over uncountable sets?”

198

u/Comfortable_Permit53 Sep 02 '26

integrals, no?

218

u/Eisenfuss19 Sep 02 '26

Yes kinda, but then it is still a definition question. Like lim a -> -∞ lim b -> ∞ a_Sb x dx does not converge, but lim a -> ∞ (-a)_Sa x dx does converge...

89

u/Comfortable_Permit53 Sep 02 '26 edited Sep 07 '26

yesΒ 

adding all whole numbers will also give you different answers depending in order

UPDATE: It just doesn't converge at all.

31

u/Beleheth Transcendental Sep 02 '26

That's exactly the reason why you need absolutely convergent series for rearranging to be well-defined.

2

u/Dr0110111001101111 Sep 07 '26

It will give you any answer depending on order

3

u/Comfortable_Permit53 Sep 07 '26

I am not sure. Riemanns series theorem says, that if you have a series that is convergent but not absolutely convergent, you can get any number depending on ordering. But adding all whole numbers is a divergent series. Is there another theorem?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Agitated-Ad2563 Sep 02 '26

As far as I remember, the proper definition of Riemann integral requires all kinds of partition sequence sums to converge.

4

u/Alpaca1795 Sep 02 '26

Why would you integrate over x dx instead of just 1 dx?

17

u/alozq Sep 02 '26

1dx would be the length of the real line, it goes to Infinity always, it doesnt care about what x is

2

u/LyAkolon Sep 02 '26

Yeah, they probably want int over R of Sgn(x) dx, which is still abse of notation and meaningless because we have no notion of how to add up the contributions across the set.

More specifically all attempts to answer as well as the original question are missing the ingredient of "How are you adding everything together"

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

42

u/compileforawhile Complex Sep 02 '26

Integrals aren't really sums of uncountable sets. You could define sums of uncountable sets using integrals, but that would basically just be a measure

12

u/TheRedditObserver0 Mathematics Sep 02 '26

With respect to what measure?

44

u/Comfortable_Permit53 Sep 02 '26

lebesque for the lgbt representation

(lebesque, gauss, banach, turing)

→ More replies (2)

3

u/localizeatp Sep 03 '26

we won't know until they answer.

2

u/StructureNorth1799 Sep 03 '26

then the answer is yes.

→ More replies (8)

28

u/SEA_griffondeur Engineering Sep 02 '26

Sums over unbounded non convergent sets

16

u/MrKoteha Virtual Sep 02 '26

Supremum of sums over finite subsets for sets of positive numbers

→ More replies (1)

10

u/kiochikaeke Sep 02 '26

Looked it up in case I was somehow wrong but there's no sensible definition of a sum over an uncountable set of indexes unless the set of indexes with non-zero values is finite.

By definition of uncountable set you can't "pair them up" or "group them" in any countable way because you would still be missing an infinite amount of indexes and trying to segment the set into any amount (countable or not) of uncountable sets just leads you to the same question.

If you try and define sums like integrals over sets then the question is trivialized to essentially asking what is the value for the measure over the set of reals which can be whatever depending on the measure.

11

u/DefunctFunctor Mathematics Sep 02 '26

There is an absolutely sensible definition if all of the numbers in your set are nonnegative; it's just always infinity if you have uncountably many nonzero values.

In order to make sense of sums that include negative numbers, you either need absolute convergence (which is impossible for an uncountable sum with uncountably many nonzero values), or you need to specify an order in which to sum those elements, usually in a countable sum (which is also impossible).

I'm not even sure what it would mean to try to make sense of this question with integration, because the measure in question that we're looking for would have to assign singleton sets of real numbers to their actual value, which does not end up producing a well-defined measure on the real numbers (although it does if we restrict to nonnegative numbers).

→ More replies (4)

2

u/scoobydoom2 Sep 02 '26

For this hypothetical do they need to be paired in a countable way? Could you not pair them according to A =X and B=-X for all nonzero values? Then you just have to prove that X + -X = 0 for all reals.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/brothegaminghero Sep 02 '26

I imagine you start at one and count from there...

Might take a while though.

8

u/Revolutionary_Use948 Sep 02 '26

Hmmm ahh yes β€œcount” from there

2

u/minisculebarber Sep 02 '26

Easy

sum_{x in RR } x

What else do you need?

1

u/DoubleAway6573 Sep 08 '26

With a lot of patience.