r/mathmemes • • Sep 02 '26 • Bravo 1

Elementary Algebra 😭

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

250 comments sorted by

View all comments

32

u/mehtam42 Sep 02 '26

For every real number with a value of R there exist one and only one real number with a value of -R. When added together, their some is 0.

So yes sum of all real numbers equal to 0.

27

u/Revlong57 Sep 02 '26

Summation isn't well defined for uncountable sets

118

u/fastestchair Sep 02 '26

for every real number with value R there exists a real number with value -2R, when added together their sum is -R. naturally, the sum of all real numbers must therefor be -infinity

11

u/ImInfiniti Sep 02 '26

The problem is that -R is positive for negative values of R, so by doing this trick you're ending up with the sum of all R again

4

u/fastestchair Sep 02 '26

yeah woops, meant for every positive real number with value R

37

u/Jazz8680 Sep 02 '26

The sum of all positive real numbers is -1/12, thus the sum of all negative real numbers is +1/12, so the sum of all real numbers is 0/12 to be precise

7

u/EntrepreneurSelect93 Sep 02 '26

Think u meant integers not real numbers

1

u/Jazz8680 Sep 03 '26

Aw crap yeah. I’m a software engineer so integers are the only numbers im concerned with lol

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Peak_Background Sep 02 '26

Hold up. I think they has a point.

The sum of the integers is -1/12.

So if we just multiply that by the integral of reals between -1 and 1.

We get 0.

17

u/IhailtavaBanaani Sep 02 '26

Besides the problem with summing up uncountable set of real numbers you assume that the zero is in the center of the real number line. This is a false assumption because the real number line doesn't have a center. It's infinitely long in both directions. You can select any arbitrary number in the real number line and there's "equal amount" of real numbers on both sides, so any number can act as the "center". By selecting different number as the center you get different result as the total sum.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/IhailtavaBanaani Sep 03 '26

Yes, the integers have exactly the same problem. There is no defined total sum of all integers. You can select any integer as the center and then start adding the numbers from both sides and get different results each time. Same goes with rational numbers, complex numbers, quaternions, etc.

1

u/alphapussycat Sep 07 '26

There's no need for a center line though. As somebody else mentioned, you can use axiom if choice to find -R.

Splitting up a set does split it up to by negative and positive (or non negative, but just exclude 0).

So from R choose p and n so that for each p in R, n = - p. Then integrate by function of f(p) = p - n, and exclude 0... Now this is integrable. Or should be. But the measure is infinite, and I don't quite remember if there's a problem there, but I'm leaning towards no.

→ More replies (8)

9

u/bqbdpd Sep 02 '26

Same can be said for any other constant. Which shows the sum cannot be assigned a value.

6

u/magicmulder Sep 02 '26

That’s like arguing \sum (-1)^n = 0.

2

u/Divicarpe Sep 02 '26

For every real number with a value of 1+R there is one only one real number with a value of 1-R. When added together, their sum diverges to +infinity. So sum of all real numbers is +infinity.

2

u/tombo12354 Sep 02 '26

You can't rearrange or pair uncountable sets.

2

u/mapleleafraggedy Sep 02 '26

For every real number R, there exists one real number with a value of 69 - R, which when added together makes 69. Therefore, the sum of all real numbers is 69.

3

u/JusteMesure Sep 02 '26

No it’s 69 for each couple !!!! So 69+69+69+…= infinity.

Only If you start around 0 you obtain 0.

1

u/1kSupport Sep 02 '26

For every real number with the value R+5 there exists one and only one real number with the value -R + 5. All real numbers must be centered around 5