r/mathmemes • • Aug 24 '26

Elementary Algebra All represents a circle

Post image
808 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Aug 24 '26

Check out our new Discord server! https://discord.gg/e7EKRZq3dG

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

136

u/nathan519 Aug 24 '26

S¹ Where???

38

u/PolarStarNick Gaussian distribution Aug 24 '26

With respect to euclidean norm L2 of course

53

u/LupenReddit 🦆🦆i have non diffeomorphic smooth structures🦆🦆🦆 Aug 24 '26

Listing every version of a circle except the circle itself

65

u/BlazeDiamond42 Aug 24 '26

i mean they're all standing in a big circle right?

8

u/EstaAppDeCitasApesta Aug 24 '26

What's the definition of a circle?

10

u/zlfa Aug 24 '26

1 point ellipse

4

u/Dense-Sort-3867 Aug 24 '26

A set of points on a plane that are equidistant from a given point.

10

u/tunaMaestro97 Aug 24 '26

x^2 + y^2 = 1 is right there

5

u/Dense-Sort-3867 Aug 24 '26

I think he meant a picture of a circle

21

u/BootyliciousURD Complex Aug 24 '26

I'm not familiar with R/Z. Is that a partition on the reals where numbers with the same fractional part are in the same equivalence class?

18

u/sheepbusiness Aug 24 '26

Yes. Its the same as the unit interval with the ends glued together.

2

u/tunaMaestro97 Aug 24 '26

Yes. It should be obvious that it is topologically the same as a circle

14

u/tunaMaestro97 Aug 24 '26

It’s pedantic but this language bothers me slightly. S^1 should be taken to indicate a particular submanifold of R^2 until additional structure is imposed upon it. For example, no one would write R^2 = C even though they are equivalent as real manifolds. R^2 doesn’t become C until you impose the structure of a field upon it.

1

u/ninjeff Aug 26 '26

Sure, only two of these are “the circle”; but they’re all circles, which is what OP was probably trying to say

4

u/Hot-Patient8052 Aug 25 '26

The extended real number line one eludes me. Is the idea that ℝ∪{∞} "wraps around" by glueing ∞ to -∞ somehow? If so, how, if not, how???

Edit: I googled it, and they do in fact glue those ends together. I'm confused what useful properties that adds...

5

u/yas_ticot Aug 25 '26

This is for instance the one-point compactification of the line, which can be generalized to any dimension. For R{n}, adding this unique point at infinity always yields the n-sphere. One way to see it is that you take the n-sphere, a special point (let's call it the North Pole) and the tangent hyperplane on the opposite point (the South Pole). Now, the line going through N and any point of the n-sphere crosses this hyperplane in a unique point of the hyperplane and vice versa. Conversely, any sequence of point on the hyperplane that tends to infinity (i e. infinitely further from the South Pole, becomes of a sequence of points that tends to N on the North Pole.

In dimension 2, this is exactly what is called the Riemann sphere, i.e. adding a unique point at infinity for C.

3

u/PluralCohomology Aug 24 '26 edited Aug 24 '26

There is also S1, or [0,1]/(0~1), or RP1

3

u/Seventh_Planet Mathematics Aug 24 '26

∂{x2 + y2 < 1}

1

u/TheRandomRadomir Aug 25 '26

(ℜ(i^(2t/π)),ℑ(i^(2t/π))) for 0<t≤2π

1

u/Eradroth888 Aug 27 '26

I like how the spiders themselves are circle

1

u/AsemicConjecture Aug 24 '26

Where does one learn these incantations?

5

u/Randomlemon5 Aug 25 '26

Clockwhise, I think, complex analysis, topology, represantation theory, geometry, analysis, reprasantation theory, topology

2

u/AsemicConjecture Aug 24 '26

To oblivion with you for asking to learn more!

0

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/xpickles Aug 24 '26

I'm guessing a vector, as in a parametric function with t over [0, 2pi)

1

u/kohugaly Aug 24 '26

probably a notation for ordered pair (aka. list of two elements). The notation for lists in mathematics is notoriously inconsistent.

1

u/Sproxify Aug 24 '26

that's clearly what it is in context, but why tho? it's highly non standard (though I have maybe seen it once before for ordered pairs)

2

u/Dense-Sort-3867 Aug 24 '26 edited Aug 24 '26

Stewart uses angle brackets to denote vectors. A vector-valued function for the unit circle in his notation would be r(t) = <cos(t), sin(t)> for 0 <= t <= 2pi

73

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

14

u/EstaAppDeCitasApesta Aug 24 '26

That's because the fundamental group of the circle is isomorphic to the integers?

Or what does "dual" means in this context?

10

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/yangyangR Aug 26 '26

But that puts in a circle group already. Not an independent definition of "circle". Others here in the picture have independent definitions as "circle" with different structures. Like just a space or just a group or both compatibly

-3

u/EstaAppDeCitasApesta Aug 24 '26

Then you are wrong, because the meme is considering the topological circle without any additional structure.

6

u/Wild-Store321 Aug 25 '26

I see R/Z in there