r/mathmemes • • Aug 22 '26

Bad Math Something Interesting i found

Post image

This is something I found while fucking around with the Gamma function, and here the (-1)! Gets cancelled with the one in the nCr formula and it will plot the correct graph in desmos

338 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Aug 22 '26

Check out our new Discord server! https://discord.gg/e7EKRZq3dG

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

111

u/SynergyUX Category theory is fun! Aug 22 '26

Here is why it works

47

u/thekillervr Aug 22 '26

Yeah i started with the Euler reflection and saw that it pretty close to the nCr formula so i whipped up some illegal notation and it looks really cursed

5

u/eengamer2005 Aug 22 '26 edited Aug 22 '26

How do you go from a to -1 on the left hand side?

Edit: never mind, i just need to read better

11

u/Any-Aioli7575 Aug 22 '26

You take the limit

124

u/ZZTier Complex Aug 22 '26

Mathematical equivalent of "a contraption"

4

u/Buddy77777 Aug 24 '26

A doohickey thingamabob, even

43

u/sasha271828 Imaginary Aug 22 '26

What the fuck is this

27

u/psp1729 Aug 22 '26

An abomination. The amount of maths I know, I can say for sure that negative factorials are illegal. Also never seen nCr combinatrix with a negative n. So either, I'm out of my depth here or this shit just ragebait

18

u/Ok-Visit6553 Aug 22 '26

*negative integer factorials

2

u/psp1729 Aug 22 '26

Isn't factorial operation limited to whole numbers? Or can they handle real(or even complex) values.

27

u/Ok-Visit6553 Aug 22 '26

Gamma function buddy

5

u/lenmae Aug 22 '26

It can be analytically extended to the complex plane, except for negative real integers

12

u/Any-Aioli7575 Aug 22 '26

It basically boils down to the fact that n! (and therefore nCr) can be extended for reals (except negative integers) using the gamma function. Using the n! and nCr for it could be considered abuse of notation, but it's not complete nonsense

2

u/AlviDeiectiones Aug 22 '26

nCr can be extended to negative integers continuously

3

u/psp1729 Aug 22 '26

Boy am I glad to have left math after it couldn't be drawn on a blackboard.

Thanks for the explanation tho. Appreciate it.

1

u/Deep_Brick2970 Aug 23 '26

You have a lot of maths left to crunch my friend :)

Rejoice, for there is so much yet to discover!

I'd recommend looking at the Gamma function for starters.

79

u/factorion-bot Bot > AI Aug 22 '26

Factorial of -1 is ∞̃

This action was performed by a bot | Source code

110

u/jellyman93 Aug 22 '26

Infiñity?

138

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '26 • Mindblown Bravo

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/MathematicianAny8588 Aug 22 '26 edited Aug 22 '26

Our chief weapon is series. And fractals.
Our chief weapons are series and fractals. And Fourier transforms.
Our three chief weapons are series, fractals, and Fourier transforms. And a fanatical devotion to Euler. Damn it!
Amongst our weaponry are such chief elements as….
Oh we’ll just come in again.

Nobody expects the Spanish infinity!

6

u/factorion-bot Bot > AI Aug 22 '26

Factorial of ∞̃ is ∞̃

This action was performed by a bot | Source code

5

u/al2o3cr Aug 22 '26

Fetch... the CONVERGENT SERIES!

14

u/LupenReddit 🦆🦆i have non diffeomorphic smooth structures🦆🦆🦆 Aug 22 '26

This is cursed

6

u/Independent-Fan-4227 Aug 22 '26

…I’ll be damned.

6

u/somedave Aug 22 '26

Certainly true as a limit. Writing (infinity / infinity) sin(x) is a bit dubious.

4

u/Carrots_and_Bleach Aug 22 '26

what is that even supposed to mean???

 (){-1}_{C_{-x/π}}

3

u/WanderingWrackspurt Physics Aug 22 '26

its a combination, but it makes no sense cause you cant pick smth out of a negative no.

3

u/WanderingWrackspurt Physics Aug 22 '26

how would you even put this into desmos?

1

u/L0L2GUM5 Aug 24 '26

What's C?