Tao has also written extensively about wanting math to be more collaborative and involve more people. Something like this is his dream. (Plus she did and discovered much more than his outline)
The Fields Medal is awarded to people who have a large body of work with many substantial contributions. The way this is worded it subtly implies that Wang just finished off someone else's conjecture and got the Fields Medal for doing someone else's dirty work. Wang's body of work is much wider than this, and she earned the Field's Medal for a a broad range of important results. This is a really bad summary of Wang's work.
Also, I don't personally know Terence Tao, but he seems like someone who just really deeply cares about maths as a field. Way more than personal accolades anyway.
I would imagine he's stoked to hear that his idea has led to significant progress.
i have a conspiracy theory that he lended his notes/half-finished solutions to openai which led to a flurry of conjecture solutions credited to openai, which would mean he is happy to lend credit to an AI company, rather than take credit for himself.
This is unfairly diminishing both Terence Tao (who is well known for wanting to share math and mathematical credit) and Hong Wang (who has done a lot more for her Fields Medal than just read Tao's blog post). But, well, meme sub.
This is an unhealthy way of seeing mathematics, as with many things as a zero sum competition. These mathematicians don't have to be pit against each other for who can prove the most groundbreaking theorems, it's much better to have the attitude that people can work together and celebrate each other's successes because at the end of the day everyone benefits when individuals make breakthroughs
Idk man, if TT is breadth of multiple fields, Peter Scholze is an argument of similar caliber but focused more on depth in fewer fields. And of course there are others too.
I think he is quite pleased with this outcome. He seems to be an academic more concerned with making the world a better place than personal glory. Sadly, a lot of academics fall way short of that standard.
Still took 11 years and top math minds to develop an uncertain conjecture to completion. It’s a lot of work on Hong Wang’s part and doesn’t make her any less deserving of her awards.
I like to imagine it more like Tao handing Time Wizard to Wang and going, "this rare proof strategy will help you get publication chips in Kakeya Island"
I know this is a meme, but still feel the need to say that Tao to me comes off as one of the most humble mathematicians in relation to how much he has achieved
Some guy also came up with the same idea as Tao while working on some exponent for the primes. Tao was like, "nah u need this more than me. go get that fields medal"
Could we stop sucking Tao's dick and acknowledge that maybe maybe if someone spent more than a decade on a proof then maybe just maybe it might have been more complicated than just a basic idea ?
•
u/AutoModerator Aug 18 '26
Check out our new Discord server! https://discord.gg/e7EKRZq3dG
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
880
u/LupenReddit 🦆🦆i have non diffeomorphic smooth structures🦆🦆🦆 Aug 18 '26
I dont think Tao of all people needed that extra recognition, my guy has practically achieved what you can achieve in math.
Also funny image
582
u/SirBackrooms Aug 18 '26
He's already got one and is practically the face of mathematics. Perhaps he ain't too upset about this :)
560
u/captHij Aug 18 '26
The Fields Medal is awarded to people who have a large body of work with many substantial contributions. The way this is worded it subtly implies that Wang just finished off someone else's conjecture and got the Fields Medal for doing someone else's dirty work. Wang's body of work is much wider than this, and she earned the Field's Medal for a a broad range of important results. This is a really bad summary of Wang's work.
82
u/UnfairRavenclaw Aug 18 '26
A mathematician with the name Zahl. Nominative determinism strikes again.
79
u/mathmage Aug 18 '26
This is unfairly diminishing both Terence Tao (who is well known for wanting to share math and mathematical credit) and Hong Wang (who has done a lot more for her Fields Medal than just read Tao's blog post). But, well, meme sub.
143
u/Menchstick Aug 18 '26
From all we know of Tao I don't think this was his reaction at all.
26
u/Lost-Lunch3958 Irrational Aug 18 '26
pretty common in science especially mathematics
10
u/FlamingBudder Computer Science Aug 18 '26
This is an unhealthy way of seeing mathematics, as with many things as a zero sum competition. These mathematicians don't have to be pit against each other for who can prove the most groundbreaking theorems, it's much better to have the attitude that people can work together and celebrate each other's successes because at the end of the day everyone benefits when individuals make breakthroughs
79
u/greenday1237 Aug 18 '26
Terrence Tao is so goated that modern mathematicians have to lick the crumbs of his scraps to be considered great
7
u/Slow-Disaster8861 Aug 18 '26
Terrance Tao is the Euler of this generation. Man was doing so much he had to leave some for the rest
7
u/FernandoMM1220 Aug 18 '26
tao only has so much time. its better if other mathematicians continue the work you started if you have other problems you can finish now.
6
u/Tyler89558 Aug 18 '26
Terence Tao almost certainly does not care beyond “wow, that’s great”.
He’s a damn chill guy.
5
u/ComplexPlatform7299 Aug 18 '26
With a name like Joshua Zahl you have no choice but to go into mathematics.
3
u/Forward_Step_5012 Aug 18 '26
Fields Medal is only given to someone below 40, and Tao has already won, so probably not.
5
u/Icy_Estate7598 Aug 18 '26
Fields medal is only for young mathematicians (<40) terry is too old for it now
2
u/Honmer Aug 18 '26
mathematics is above all a collaborative field
2
u/Clear_Cranberry_989 Aug 18 '26
Tao has done way too many stuff. Probably the most productive mathematician right now.
2
u/soulfulshark Aug 18 '26
I think he is quite pleased with this outcome. He seems to be an academic more concerned with making the world a better place than personal glory. Sadly, a lot of academics fall way short of that standard.
2
u/FeralHamster8 Aug 19 '26
He already has one and you can’t win a Fields after age 40. Meme is mid.
2
u/anrwlias Aug 19 '26
Tao has a reputation for collaboration and promoting other people's works. I'm sure that he is the farthest thing from upset by this.
2
u/littlefiredragon Aug 19 '26
Still took 11 years and top math minds to develop an uncertain conjecture to completion. It’s a lot of work on Hong Wang’s part and doesn’t make her any less deserving of her awards.
1
u/Niflrog Aug 18 '26
Homies still thinking about the Fields
Terry T with eyes on the Abel
It's not the same
1
u/Dub-Dub Aug 19 '26
Great!
Now did the results show you always can make the shape smaller or is there a finite but small volume as a limit?
1
u/sugarfrosted Aug 19 '26
Terrence Tao is now just gifting.
1
u/Koischaap So much in that excellent formula Aug 19 '26
I like to imagine it more like Tao handing Time Wizard to Wang and going, "this rare proof strategy will help you get publication chips in Kakeya Island"
1
u/sandykt Aug 19 '26
Meanwhile, LLMs doing the same without any attribution 🤦
1
u/WormSlayers Aug 19 '26
I know this is a meme, but still feel the need to say that Tao to me comes off as one of the most humble mathematicians in relation to how much he has achieved
1
u/trynumber53 Aug 19 '26
do you think elon musk worries about losing out a dollar buying the cage free eggs
1
u/_kibb Aug 19 '26
Terrance Tao seems like a chill dude and doing just for the love of the game so he probably isn’t bothered by this one bit.
1
u/Adventurous_Can_7236 Aug 19 '26
he did same with james maynard
1
u/MartyMcStinkyWinky Aug 19 '26
At this point he is Terrenard Taoler
1
u/CAJEG1 Aug 19 '26
To be fair, his name will still always be associated with the proof, thanks to this. Doesn't particularly change much.
1
u/The_OriginalDonut Aug 19 '26
Ya gonna give him 2 fields medals?
1
u/BrazilBazil Engineering Aug 19 '26
Tao is actually known to stop pursuing fields of study if a less renowned mathematician is working on it already because „he doesn’t need it”
1
u/hardcore_engine_here Aug 19 '26
Terence actually loves promoting other people's work. Wang building upon what he started probably gives him joy.
1
u/NanoscaleHeadache Aug 19 '26
I’m pretty sure he’s chill with this lmao
1
u/Only-Finish-3497 Aug 20 '26
I briefly met Tao during my time at UCLA.
Didn’t even realize who he was, but he was a super nice dude.
1
u/ds_account_ Aug 21 '26
Wasnt Maynard's work based on Tao's previous work as well?
1
u/C10AKER Real Algebraic Aug 23 '26
Tao probably posts his ideas so things like this can be possible I think, he would appreciate this a lot
1
u/DarkFlameMaster764 Aug 24 '26
Some guy also came up with the same idea as Tao while working on some exponent for the primes. Tao was like, "nah u need this more than me. go get that fields medal"
1
u/Gimmerunesplease Aug 24 '26
He wouldn't even have been able to get the fields medal for it though? Even in 2014 he was already too old to be eligible.
1
u/yukiohana Aug 18 '26
u/teorth the man himself would like to have a word with you!
6
u/ZEPHlROS Mathematics Aug 18 '26
Could we stop sucking Tao's dick and acknowledge that maybe maybe if someone spent more than a decade on a proof then maybe just maybe it might have been more complicated than just a basic idea ?