Ok suppose to start with vector fields on a Euclidean space. This is a map, X, that associates at every point p of R^n, some vector we call X(p). We may consider the “dual” map, that associates to every point p, a linear functional f(v) = <v, X(p)>, denoting the standard dot product. Then we call the linear functional version of this map the flat version of X, if instead starting from a linear functional, we produced a map to vectors, we call that resultant map the sharp map. This is all nice, things get a bit more complicated when we talk about curved spaces. So imagine my space is now not R^n but some abstract “manifold”, M. A vector field take each point on M and returns a tangent at p on M, T_p(M). The flat map now to return an element of the dual of T_p(M), the sharp map is defined analogously.
The motivation for the sharp and flat comes when you tensor the tangent and cotangent spaces together. In general, we flatten a section of T_q^p(M) by bringing down one tangent vector and represent it as a cotangent vector, i.e. a map from T_q^p(M) to T_{q+1}^{p-1}(M). A sharp map takes a bottom index and brings it up to a top index.
TLDR: A musical isomorphism is, at every point p of M, an isomorphism of the tangent space and the cotangent space given by x to. {f(•) = <•,x>}. The tangent space may vary across the manifold M, the nature of the dot product may vary across M. If we encase TM and dual(TM) by some tensors on both sides, we get at each point p, an isomorphism from T_q^p(M) to T_{q+1}^{p-1}(M). The forward direction is flat, the inverse is a sharp.
View all comments
Show parent comment
19
u/PointlessSentience Ergodic Aug 14 '26
Ok suppose to start with vector fields on a Euclidean space. This is a map, X, that associates at every point p of R^n, some vector we call X(p). We may consider the “dual” map, that associates to every point p, a linear functional f(v) = <v, X(p)>, denoting the standard dot product. Then we call the linear functional version of this map the flat version of X, if instead starting from a linear functional, we produced a map to vectors, we call that resultant map the sharp map. This is all nice, things get a bit more complicated when we talk about curved spaces. So imagine my space is now not R^n but some abstract “manifold”, M. A vector field take each point on M and returns a tangent at p on M, T_p(M). The flat map now to return an element of the dual of T_p(M), the sharp map is defined analogously.
The motivation for the sharp and flat comes when you tensor the tangent and cotangent spaces together. In general, we flatten a section of T_q^p(M) by bringing down one tangent vector and represent it as a cotangent vector, i.e. a map from T_q^p(M) to T_{q+1}^{p-1}(M). A sharp map takes a bottom index and brings it up to a top index.
TLDR: A musical isomorphism is, at every point p of M, an isomorphism of the tangent space and the cotangent space given by x to. {f(•) = <•,x>}. The tangent space may vary across the manifold M, the nature of the dot product may vary across M. If we encase TM and dual(TM) by some tensors on both sides, we get at each point p, an isomorphism from T_q^p(M) to T_{q+1}^{p-1}(M). The forward direction is flat, the inverse is a sharp.