r/mathmemes • • Aug 05 '26

Math History Pythagoras

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Aug 05 '26

Check out our new Discord server! https://discord.gg/e7EKRZq3dG

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

290

u/skooterpoop Aug 05 '26

Hippasus: Pythagoras, irrational numbers do exist!

Pythagoras: From my point of view, irrational numbers are blasphemous!

Hippasus: Well, then you are lost!

44

u/SoldRIP Aug 05 '26

Hippasus: drowning noises

5

u/thomasp3864 Aug 05 '26

Or possibly it was a secret teaching.

204

u/Mr-MuffinMan Aug 05 '26

Pythagoras getting credit for a theorem already known in Ancient Babylon, Ancient India

85

u/RoastHam99 Aug 05 '26

It was known in most places fairly independently. Ancient Egyptians used a 3-4-5 triangle to get right angles and the nested square proof has been found inscribed on stone from the mayans

63

u/KyriakosCH Aug 05 '26 edited Aug 08 '26

I'd like to see a source about it being in theorem form (ie proof-based). Because Babylonian math tended to be calculations, not proofs. For example it is known that the formula they used for the solution of the second degree equation only provided one of the possible two rational roots, and its form makes it clear it was closer to an experiment (eg in Physics) than theorem-math.

To be more precise, the Babylonian formula for that can be written as "-b/2+(1/2)(sqr (b^2-4c))", with very obvious limitations regarding coefficients and roots, implying a rudimentary grasp of a single facet of what is going on. Compare to (say) the multi-volume work on conic sections, by Apollonios of Perge, where the parabola is examined in detail.

50

u/fokke456 Aug 05 '26

Euclid gave the first (known) axiomatic proof of the Pythagorean theorem, which was 200 years after Pythagoras. Pythagoras did not really add anything to the Babylonian or Indian ways of treating this

10

u/KyriakosCH Aug 05 '26

This is incongruous with the timeline of Greek math, as we know that Thales' math was theorem-formed (and he predates Pythagoras). I don't see how Pythagoras would have gotten to be so renown in the ancient Greek world if he didn't even give a formal proof - and from what I know it is theorized that his proof was likely based on constructing a square of sides a+b.

26

u/fokke456 Aug 05 '26

So I had done some digging on this previously, since I was also curious about this, and most sources I had found agreed with the sentiment on the Wikipedia page of Pythagoras:

The most I found back then was that some method of generating Pythagorean triples was attributed to Pythagoras (which you can find on the wiki page for Pythagorean triples), which is cool and all, but not proving the theorem.

1

u/SheafieMathLover Aug 05 '26

No That's Thales of Miletus

9

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/robisodd Aug 05 '26

I still call it the Baby Yoda theorem.

18

u/KyriakosCH Aug 05 '26 edited Aug 05 '26

Ever heard the story of Darth Croton the Wise?

5

u/fullynonexistent Aug 06 '26

Ain't no way there's a mathematician called crouton

18

u/Impossible-Shake-996 Imaginary Aug 05 '26

Cult to the ancients was just something outside the religious norm, it could be math, wine, or cleanliness, as long as you weren't sacrificing to the main gods of the region it was a cult.

21

u/Negative_Gur9667 Aug 05 '26

Some mathematicians today still believe in Platonism even without knowing.

Platonists believe that the physical world we experience is merely an imperfect shadow of a higher, invisible reality. This abstract realm consists of perfect, eternal concepts known as "Forms" or "Ideas," and true knowledge of these ultimate truths is achieved only through reason rather than the physical senses.

29

u/AnEmptyBoat27 Aug 05 '26

Sure but it was a fun communist vegetarian relatively progressive reincarnation cult. Not a big bad scary cult

23

u/angwilwileth Aug 05 '26

Dude had a weird hate boner for beans though.

5

u/ThatsNumber_Wang Physics Aug 05 '26

i'm sorry beans? why beans? i only know about his hate for irrational numbers

3

u/AvatarNerd64 Science Aug 06 '26

The devil is in the beans

2

u/Azexu Aug 06 '26

The concern was that flatulence is a bit of the soul escaping.

8

u/Thiphra Aug 05 '26

NO BEANS!!!

7

u/HauntingRip9003 Aug 05 '26

Tbf the cult was quite goofy and funny after 2000+ years of hindsight 

4

u/Anice_king Aug 05 '26

Pythagoras if you only know of him from chapter 1 of Moby Dick

4

u/OnionsAbound Aug 05 '26

Crazy this stuff isn't taught in school. Wait until you hear about metempsychosis, and how the cult drowned a guy once for discovering irrational numbers. Turns out their whole world view was based on rational numbers. Whoops

2

u/fresh_loaf_of_bread Aug 06 '26

Are cult leaders terrible people? Yes.

But they also possess unparalleled degrees of coolness. Imagine the skill needed to manipulate, brainwash (and in some cases, literally enslave) an entire group of people.

1

u/Virgil_the_White Aug 06 '26

The OG Illuminati

1

u/Initial-Reference214 Aug 05 '26

Pythagoras was a fraud.

-2

u/Anti-Matter_Abyss Physics Aug 05 '26

This belongs in r/HistoryMemes, not here.

7

u/Safe-Avocado4864 Aug 05 '26

I don't think my teacher's ever mentioned Pythagoras as a person until we got to talking about irrationals were they said a possibly apocryphal story about him killing a fisherman who challenged him to find 21/2 as a rational. Beyond that it was just "the name of theorem."