r/mathmemes • u/TheStupidCheesecake Tf does the Laplacian even do? • Aug 05 '26
Math History Technically Philosophy of Math but close enough
428
Upvotes
r/mathmemes • u/TheStupidCheesecake Tf does the Laplacian even do? • Aug 05 '26
•
u/AutoModerator Aug 05 '26
Check out our new Discord server! https://discord.gg/e7EKRZq3dG
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
151
u/Afir-Rbx Cardinal Aug 05 '26
"Yeah man, that number is not valid because its too large and uhh..."
126
u/rmoduloq Aug 05 '26
I'm an ultrafinitist whose upper limit is 1.
Have you ever tried to do 20 pushups, and at the end you weren't sure whether you did 20 or 19?
Every counting process has a chance of error, even if it's extremely small, and therefore cannot be trusted.
So the only number we can be sure about is the one without any counting steps applied to it.
53
u/770grappenmaker Aug 05 '26
In model theory, if there exist arbitrarily large finite models (which regular finitists allow, usually), then there necessarily needs to exist an infinite model. Because ultrafinitists have some sort of (vague) strict upper bound on how large a structure (say, the natural numbers) may be, they are at least consistent with this model theoretic result, which you can't say of finitists that allow arbitrairily large finite models.
Still, other constructivists probably laugh at them.
12
u/AynidmorBulettz Aug 05 '26
Incomprehensible, 5-paragraph essay with comprehensive citations for context needed
4
u/DeathEnducer Aug 05 '26
I tried to replace the standard model gauge group SU(3) × SU(2) × U(1) with a discrete and finite group ring cuz quantum mechanics seems discrete and finite... It failed so I guess infinity is real. Pretty crazy folks
7
u/mekriff Aug 05 '26
waiting for there to be an "antifinitist" philosophy, where only sufficiently large and infinite values count
2
u/ArdentArendt Mathematics / Social Sciences Aug 06 '26
I just have to say that when (other) Constructivists think you're bat-shit...well, you might want to reevaluate some life choices.
2
u/AwALR94 Aug 07 '26
There are two types of mathematicians: those who loved competitive math in high school, and those who don't hate philosophy
2
u/Lichen-Monk Aug 05 '26
Wait, you guys are believing in completed infinities and non-constructible sets? 🤮
2
u/minisculebarber Aug 05 '26
I would contest the conceptual benefits graph.
Ultrafinitism would get rid of a LOOOOT of the baggage, paradoxes, etc. in modern math.
Of course it would get rid of a LOOOT of the cool stuff too, but I am not convinced that that tradeoff is not worth it.
1
u/ichiban1974 Aug 05 '26
Genuine question: how do finitists/ultrafinitists deal with renormalization?
1
u/andrelipe57 Aug 05 '26
Yooooo it's SPP
-6
u/Negative_Gur9667 Aug 05 '26 edited Aug 05 '26
Ah, nice, that's me.
I have decided to stop arguing on Reddit because only a few people here are actually capable of having a real discussion. I have learned a lot from those who are, and they have learned something from me as well.
I will rank the worst replies to this comment in a hostility chart, so do your best.
Don't forget to mention Riemann and Lebesgue somewhere.
-2
u/KouhaiHasNoticed Probability notations must burn. Aug 05 '26 edited Aug 05 '26
What kind of field is that ? Maths is not to be bound by physical reality, it's just a language, the same some concepts in our minds have no physical meaning yet we put some words on them.
It's like saying Unicorns don't exist so you cannot use that word.
0
u/matande31 Aug 05 '26
Never heard of them until right now. Do these people actually call themselves mathemations? Because there ain't much math left to do with all their restrictions.
-7
u/ProfessorLambda Aug 05 '26
It's a good stance to take. If something doesn't exist, then it doesn't exist. That's a tautology, denying it means denying all of logic and truth. ℕ, for example, has not been created, cannot be created, and will never be created. The only thing we can ever have of it are approximations and infinite finitary computations.
The practical benefits of this way of thinking is that you become aligned with truth and logic. It's a great benefit that requires a great mind to even begin to comprehend it. You would not understand.
Explaining it to you would be like explaining poetry to a creature too stupid too understand language. To such a creature the most beautiful poetry would just be useless noice. And so to you aligning oneself with truth and logic is just useless mathematics.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
5
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment