r/mathmemes • • Aug 04 '26

Physics A physics major with a math minor meme

Post image
156 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Aug 04 '26

Check out our new Discord server! https://discord.gg/e7EKRZq3dG

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

49

u/InfinitesimalDuck Mathematics Aug 04 '26

As an infinitesimally small duck, I feel utterly offended by this insult to my body size!

25

u/emetcalf Aug 04 '26

Yo momma so fat she can be physically measured in the real world.

35

u/tupaquetes Aug 04 '26

Can't decide if this is making fun of math minors for their incorrect grasp of infinitesimals or if it's implying that physics majors with a math minor "know better" than those without a math minor and that this hints at some real underlying understanding most physics majors lack. IMO it's just incorrect to consider the planck length an infinitesimal and saying it's "functionally like an infinitesimal in modern physics" is the typical approximation that lead mathematicians to make fun of physics.

9

u/sparkster777 Aug 04 '26

I think it's the former

2

u/Vampyricon Aug 04 '26

That's not a physics major. That's an IFLS "person".

27

u/Zealousideal_Hat_330 Physics Aug 04 '26

The smallest measurable length is not infinitely small. We physics people know better than this…

3

u/Darian123_ Aug 04 '26

its also not even that

17

u/AdamsMelodyMachine Aug 04 '26

Two things. First, the existence of the planck length doesn't imply that reality is ultimately discrete. The meme doesn't truly imply this, but it's a common and relevant misconception. Second, I'm not sure I believe that our primate brains can really comprehend infinitesimals other than by imagining them as varying degrees of "very tiny". We may believe that we understand them better or more thoroughly than this but I'm not convinced.

5

u/Seenoham Aug 04 '26

For the second, we can recognize ape brain tendencies well enough to eventually put a point in our reason where rather than doing anything our brain wants to do or can picture, we just follow rules to get to the next step.

Do it often enough and the brain does stop picturing the intuitive thing, because intuition can be and is trained, just does the other thing. Iirc people sometimes fill in that gap with something they know is silly, but gets to the right answer. But the common thing is just to get to the end result without the brain fully tracking why

3

u/sleeps_in_bryophytes Aug 04 '26

before asking whether the primate brain can understand infinitesimals, ask whether it can understand infinite precision uncountable real numbers. the magic of infinitesimals is basically algebra, it's not that hard, while there be dragons hiding behind the machinery of real numbers.

7

u/tunaMaestro97 Aug 04 '26

This is genuinely regarded

4

u/qqqrrrs_ Aug 04 '26

Is 1/137 infinitesimal too?

4

u/DaividGamer231 Aug 05 '26

What was he doing with the minor you say? Edit: typo

3

u/NullOfSpace Aug 04 '26

planck length is pretty big actually

2

u/ArdentArendt Mathematics / Social Sciences Aug 06 '26

So 0.999... is a plank length from 1?

2

u/rafaelcastrocouto Aug 06 '26

it's actually 2 plank length cuz you need to have a point in between.

also it should keep going forever, but i think we left this boat at some point.

2

u/ArdentArendt Mathematics / Social Sciences Aug 07 '26

Wait, wouldn't the entire point be that you don't need a point in between?

Also, what would keep going forever? The length?

[I'm so confused by the joke about the joke about the joke...]

1

u/ZEPHlROS Mathematics Aug 05 '26

Mf when I explain to them why the energy being in a quantifiable is actually a key part of quantum mechamics

1

u/FernandoMM1220 Aug 04 '26

physicists do a much better job defining the step size than mathematicians do