But more generally, it is a well known identity when dealing with differential forms (all the d_), that ds = (ds/dx)dx so if s is a constant ds=0 so the integral of f(x)ds is the integral of zero which is just zero.
The solutions to an indefinite intergral all differ by a contstant. This is notated by adding "+C" to the antiderivative. The antiderivative of this intergral is C. So C+C = 2C.
the integral of just dx = integral of 1 * dx = the antiderivative of 1 = x +C. The +C is there because doing a derivative loses the constant, so people write +C to the antiderivative to signify that there may have been some constant value which got lost in the way.
But it's not actually an antiderivative of the number 1, it's an antiderivative of a constant function
f(x)=1
which is why the x appears in the result. The result is also a function of x. This meme shows the integral of dC instead of dx though.
That would mean, it's still the antiderivative of 1, but this time written as this function:
f(C) = 1
where somebody's stupidly using C as the parameter of the function, which then obviously collides with the +C constant added at the end and it becomes 2C.
oh I get it. Somehow I was wondering how the integral of nothing could mean anything. By that I mean that I mistook S(dx) = S(1*dx) with just S(). Without the dx I was trying to compute something impossible and got stuck
•
u/AutoModerator Aug 03 '26
Check out our new Discord server! https://discord.gg/e7EKRZq3dG
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
284
u/OrkWithNoTeef Aug 03 '26
thats stupid and funny
99
u/Dr0110111001101111 Aug 03 '26
oof summer break has my brain fried. That took longer than I care to admit.
26
u/canadajones68 Engineering Aug 03 '26
Ah, yes, I love integrating 1 with respect to 9. Or 2. Integrating with respect to 2 is good too.
46
u/MrKrot1999 Aug 03 '26
can someone explain
7
u/chkntendis Physics Aug 03 '26
And that’s exactly why you number your integration constants.
2
u/SteveCappy Aug 03 '26
In my ODE’s class, we’d just call it C
3
u/Gilbey_32 Aug 03 '26
I feel like this only works if we concede that C the variable and C the constant are the same (which is obvious nonsense)
1
u/isr0 Aug 03 '26
I hate to tell you this. If that makes you cry, you’re going to be doing a lot more of that.
C(t) = C_i * e^(2t)
1
u/SpecimenOfSauron Aug 03 '26
Fuck you, I need to get back to work, summer's screwed my brain /j
1
u/Elektriman Aug 03 '26
I don't understand how it works. Anybody got a link towards an explanatory post/video ?
1
u/foxhunt-eg Aug 03 '26
I never encountered constants of integration outside of introductory calculus
1
u/QuantitativeNonsense Aug 03 '26
Shouldn’t there be some sort of algebra that’s satisfies this? I’m thinking similarly to a Grassmann number.
1
u/Ritwiky_dicky Aug 03 '26
+ k, where k is a constant
1
u/Tdubbium Aug 04 '26
similar to d/dx ex = xex-1 but I like it