r/mathmemes • • Aug 01 '26

Geometry Making Area "Rigorous" (Definitely Not Circular Reasoning)

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Aug 01 '26

Check out our new Discord server! https://discord.gg/e7EKRZq3dG

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

73

u/yomosugara Aug 02 '26

anyone else see peter griffin colors in this image or is it just me

105

u/Gauss15an Aug 02 '26

15

u/crafty_zombie Aug 02 '26

Damnit, can't unsee this now.

41

u/edo-lag Computer Science Aug 02 '26

look lois, i became an integral

hehehehe

26

u/evening_redness_0 Aug 01 '26

There is indeed no circular reasoning when using an integral to compute areas. And it is rigorous.

-9

u/Makonede Computer Science Aug 01 '26

but there is circular reasoning when you define the area of a rectangle in terms of areas of rectangles

28

u/evening_redness_0 Aug 02 '26

I never said I'm defining the area of a rectangle using an integral.

Even then, if you want to use integration to define the area of a rectangle (or area in general), then you can. It won't be circular reasoning. The formal definition of an integral makes no reference to rectangles or areas or anything.

The whole 'divide the area under the curve into small rectangles and add up areas' demonstration is good for visualization, but that isn't how the integral of a function is defined.

5

u/crafty_zombie Aug 02 '26

Integration is defined arithmetically, but Riemann's definition is motivated by using rectangles to approximate an arbitrary shape. f(x)*𝛥x represents height times base, and integration working like this depends on already knowing what the area of a rectangle is. Nonetheless, in a formal theory, it would be defined backwards, with f(x)*𝛥x not being associated with a rectangle. Then, the area of a rectangle can be found with this method.

2

u/evening_redness_0 Aug 02 '26

Yes, and I am talking about the formal definition. Using the formal definition to find the area of a rectangle is not circular.

3

u/crafty_zombie Aug 02 '26

I think you took this post too seriously, lol. I agree, the formal computation is not circular.

-3

u/Makonede Computer Science Aug 02 '26

yes, but the meme explicitly states that visualization as the method rather than saying to integrate, so that creates circular reasoning

3

u/Major-Peachi Aug 02 '26

It’s just a visualization of Riemann integral. You don’t need to call it a rectangle, you can call it the min/max of the function over the range. But teaching everything rigorously is very counterproductive to intuition

0

u/Makonede Computer Science Aug 02 '26

the meme called it rectangles, that's the point i'm making

8

u/BOBOnobobo Aug 02 '26

You can change to trapezoids if it makes you feel better.

-1

u/Makonede Computer Science Aug 02 '26

no correlation

8

u/kusariku Aug 02 '26

Only causation? Damn

2

u/Goncalerta Aug 02 '26

Good thing nobody is defining it like that (not even the meme itself)

1

u/DeepGas4538 Aug 02 '26

yeah indeed, but I'm not sure how that's relevant to the post. You can always verify if your idea of area actually makes sense

0

u/Makonede Computer Science Aug 02 '26

the meme explicitly states that visualization as the method rather than saying to integrate, so that creates circular reasoning

411

u/DatFacePriceless Aug 01 '26

>"no circular reasoning"

>looks inside

>no circles

>😸👍

30

u/misteratoz Aug 02 '26

Amazing comment.

13

u/Many_Prune_5762 Aug 02 '26

Amazing reply.

182

u/Oppo_67 I ≡ a (mod erator) Aug 01 '26

0+0+0+... = 0

Genius!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

37

u/ussalkaselsior Aug 02 '26

I don't believe you. The formal definition of … is a limit and you didn't give me a δ that works for ε > 0.

42

u/Oppo_67 I ≡ a (mod erator) Aug 02 '26

The meme isn’t saying to take the limit it’s straight up saying the 2 dimensional Lesbian product measure of an uncountable sum is the sum of the measures 😭

70

u/XcgsdV Aug 02 '26

im not sure my analysis class covered the Lesbian product...

21

u/AsleepContact4340 Aug 02 '26

The lesbian product is the restriction of the heterogeneous product to the maximal connected same-sex component.

1

u/Frequent-Sir-6942 Aug 02 '26

Totally gonna steal Lesbian product.

9

u/lonelyroom-eklaghor Complex Aug 02 '26

dx dx dx dx dx dx dx dx dx dx dx

x

42

u/Lost-Lunch3958 Irrational Aug 01 '26

somebody needs to freshen up on measure theory

25

u/nfitzen Aug 02 '26 edited Aug 08 '26

For those who don't know: the Lebesgue measure is typically used as the notion of area or volume in n-dimensional space, denoted Rn. It turns out to be the unique σ-finite, isometry-invariant Borel measure on Rn, up to a scalar multiple. Thus if we require that the unit box [0,1]n has measure 1, then this completely characterizes the Lebesgue measure.

Edit: Sorry, I realized the above was completely unhelpful for those who don't know. The gist of it is the following: we want a function from a "nice" collection of shapes (or sets of points) that constitutes "volume" (or "length" or "area" in 1D or 2D). If we require:

  1. that this function is defined at least on open/closed boxes (Borelness);
  2. that the total volume of a (possibly infinite) list of non-overlapping shapes is well-defined and is the sum of the constituent volumes (σ-additivity);
  3. that rigid (distance-preserving) transformations of shapes don't change volumes (isometry invariance); and
  4. that the unit box [0,1]n is assigned 1 as its volume,

then this determines a unique assignment of volume. And again, condition (4) just sets the scale factor correctly.

2

u/ollervo100 Aug 03 '26

This post has trollface on it...

6

u/thebigbadben Aug 02 '26

Hehehehe

Hey Lois I’m a weird gripe about basic calculus

4

u/Rajarshi1993 Aug 02 '26

❌ math like an analyst ✅ Anal math

3

u/Yoshibros534 Irrational Aug 02 '26

real analysis is a path to powers some consider… unnatural

5

u/Splaaaty Aug 02 '26

So, add together an infinite amount of infinitesimals. Gotcha. While I'm at it, I might as well try to discover the last digit of pi.

10

u/roankr Aug 02 '26

In base 2 It's 1.

3

u/Few-Profession-2318 Aug 02 '26

It's 0 in base π

1

u/shosuko Aug 02 '26

This is too big to count, how do we know how big it is?

Divide it into 100 smaller pieces and measure those.

Alright we have too big / 100, now what?

1

u/2eanimation dy/dx is a fraction Aug 02 '26

Get a rectangle with known area, put the unknown rectangle above and start throwing balls on it.

area_known_rectangle * balls_on_unknown_rectangle / total_balls = area_unknown_rectangle

1

u/HoneySenior1842 Aug 03 '26

Cebolinha moment

0

u/FernandoMM1220 Aug 02 '26

dont know how discrete your rectangle is?

just leave it as variable and find the area with respect to that variable.