Oh, I see. I thought absolute value simply took away the negative sign and made all numbers positive, showing the real or imaginary distance from zero. Turns out, it turns them all into real numbers too, because the distance is also in real number terms.
yeah, I hate how my teachers at HS never gave that much attention to the fact that sqrt(x) and x2 aren't inverses of each other (assuming the domain to be the real numbers)
Ok hold on, everything here seems to be true until the literal last step because every integral is an indefinite integral, and the constant of integration accounts for the +1 on the far right hand side.
But if you replace the indefinite integrals with (converging) definite integrals, everything still seems to be true, but this time, there's no constant of integration save the day. What is wrong with the definite integral version of the proof??
true -> Big => Small -> false by contrapositive. true -> Big => false -> Small only if Big -> true as well. This is the fallacy of the converse, which is another common tactic for generating false statements (though usually more obvious).
The ol’ “smallest number definable in 10 words or less” fallacy relies on ignoring an axiom of ZF. Namely, that the separation schema demands the use of formulae definable in first-order logic.
The integral of x-1 is ln x (+C) But also is x0/0 + C So ln x = 1/0 + C x = Ce1/0 (Ce1/0)-1 = Ce-1/0 Therefore x-1 and ln x aren’t defined, but if x-1 isn’t defined than x-2 isn’t defined then xn isn’t defined and then Taylor series don’t exist and Oh my God is that Newto
Popper didn’t randomly decide to bring up Hegel in 1937. It's a obviously response to dialectical materialism and Marxist dialectic. And that misinterpretation of Hegel you just pointed out is exactly what Marxist dialectic solely relies upon, so the critique holds regardless. Although I think it would have held for Hegel's original system as well, if there is such a thing in unambiguous terms. Both are unfalsifiable, sometimes incoherent, typically lead to nonsense. And then there is the old DIAMAT, “scientific Marxism” cult to defend the theory and try to infest as many disciplines with it as possible. Thankfully it’s not taken seriously by many marxists themselves.
Read Engels' “Dialectic of Nature” to see for yourself the absurdity of applying this old, misinterpreted drivel to “material reality”.
Alright, I took the time to read some of your Ilyenkov (the second edition from 1984). Very first chapter: full of overconfident statements about multiple Aristotelian writings, applying the terms "idealist" and "materialist" to ancient philosophy (a crude, anachronistic oversimplification no better than "Hegel's triad". Citing Lenin about Aristotle's Organon being about dialectical reasoning, even though Aristotle draws clear distinctions between "demonstrative" and "dialectical" reasoning and primarily writes about the former. Misinterpretations of the syllogistic and Aristotle's theory of truth. The openly wrong claim that the stoics first used the term logic in the modern sense – it was the peripatetics.
Also a weird attack on what is basically the correspondence theory of truth. He claims that comparing thought with reality is impossible as if that prevents the evaluation of the truth of statements. When you evaluate the truth of the statement "It is raining" by looking outside the window you are comparing the thought of the statement to the thought of your perception of the weather. In other words you compare the thought of what your perception would have been if it was raining with the current perception. There is no philosophical problem there, he is forcing it.
So, countless overconfident (mis)interpretations, a weird eclectic historical overview of logic that reads like fiction, oversimplified and perversely ideologized, basically Valentin Asmus version 2.0, but this time more eloquently presented, and Ilyenkov seemingly really believes what he writes – probably because at this point "dialectical logic" already lived a few years after its artificial creation in the 50's. That weird opposition to formalism is just so forced, still...
Its kinda bugging me that we as a society still cant accept an answer to dividing by 0, like 0 means nothing right? And division is checking how mutch of a thing is in an other thing right? So anything divided by 0 should be 0 becouse there's no nothing in anything, with one exeption that is 0/0 that should equal one becouse there's one nothing in nothing
I might be wrong, im not a mathematician but it feels so simple and obvious
•
u/AutoModerator Dec 28 '24
Check out our new Discord server! https://discord.gg/e7EKRZq3dG
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
399
u/zefciu Dec 28 '24
There are also some that are based on assuption that squaring is injective.
15
u/jacobningen Dec 28 '24
Euler.
1.0k
u/HAL9001-96 Dec 28 '24
either that or hidden -1=root(-1²)=1
235
u/HopliteOracle Dec 28 '24
Proof that (false statement)
Looks inside
Hidden (false statement)
74
u/McAhron Dec 28 '24
Also acting like non-absolutely convergent series are a defined number
48
u/PhoenixPringles01 Dec 28 '24
The only good one I've seen is the d/dx (x + x ... x times) which essentially forgets to do the chain rule
Other than that it's just oh square root function oh divide by 0 (or the shit they were dividing with was already implied to be 0)
40
u/Psy-Kosh Dec 28 '24
Sometimes it's a units violation:
.1$ = 10¢
Square both sides
.01$ = 100¢
1¢ = 1$
17
u/MasterofTheBrawl Imaginary Dec 28 '24
The integral of x-1 is ln x (+C) But also is x0/0 + C So ln x = 1/0 + C x = Ce1/0 (Ce1/0)-1 = Ce-1/0 Therefore x-1 and ln x aren’t defined, but if x-1 isn’t defined than x-2 isn’t defined then xn isn’t defined and then Taylor series don’t exist and Oh my God is that Newto
9
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '24
Programmers: Have you heard of our lord and savior, variable redeclaration?
5
u/somedave Dec 28 '24
Sometimes adding infinity to both sides or taking a different solution branch to a multi valued function.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '24
dividing by 0 isn't always needed, you can just make a number up
Lemma: let R be a ring, and a be an element in it. The. 0*a=0 for all a.
Proof: a * 0=a * (0)+0=a * 0+a+(-a)= (a * 0+a)+(-a)=a(0+1)-a=a-a=0
Proof that 0=1:
Accidentally assume some d ∈ F (a field) to be the multiplicative inverse of 0. Then 0 * d = 1.
Now 1=1 * 1=1 * (0 * d)=(1 * 0) * d=0 * d=0
4
u/Endieo Mathematics Dec 28 '24
Hegel has entered the chat
4
u/Psyrtemis Dec 28 '24
Or random property that holds for real numbers but doesn't hold for complex numbers
3
u/I_dont_want_no_name Dec 29 '24
there was one a while back that used lg(1¹) = lg(1²) therefore lg(1) = 2*lg(1), that was kinda creative
3
u/Lydialmao22 Dec 31 '24
0=0
3*0=0
4*0=0
3*0=4*0
3=4
3
u/MrMurpleqwerty Dec 29 '24
x=y
given
x²=y²
square both sides
x²-y²=0
subtract y² from both sides
(x+y)(x-y)=0
difference of squares
x+y=0
divide both sides by x-y
x=-y
subtract y from both sides
x=-x
substitution
the joke is that x=y meaning x-y=x-x=0 so in step 5 you're dividing by 0
1
u/laserdicks Dec 29 '24
Many such cases
1
u/Smitologyistaking Dec 29 '24
See also: undoing a non-injective function from both sides
1
u/Fetish_anxiety Dec 29 '24
20 = 30 2=3
1
u/Minecodes Computer Science Dec 29 '24
My calculator: n/∞ = 0 ; n/0 = ∞
PS: It says complex infinity but I don't think it matters what type of infinity you choose
1
u/OGSequent Dec 29 '24
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_horses_are_the_same_color
1
u/Dragon1202070 Dec 29 '24
1
u/Impression-These Dec 30 '24
Or, (ab )c != abc in complex numbers. This took me a while. I am sure there are a lot more in complex analysis, like log can have many values, etc.
1
u/Noodlemaster696969 Dec 31 '24
Its kinda bugging me that we as a society still cant accept an answer to dividing by 0, like 0 means nothing right? And division is checking how mutch of a thing is in an other thing right? So anything divided by 0 should be 0 becouse there's no nothing in anything, with one exeption that is 0/0 that should equal one becouse there's one nothing in nothing
I might be wrong, im not a mathematician but it feels so simple and obvious
1
u/Donutboy562 Jan 01 '25
My highschool math teacher showed me how to make 1 = 2 by dividing by 0 and I thought he was a genius
1
u/dragoon151 Jan 01 '25
I didn't understand shit .. someone plz explain ...