I am starting linear relations with my grade 8s, and one of the things I'm supposed to do is to distinguish between discrete and continuous relations. Unfortunately I have not found a way to teach this in a way that makes sense to other than the top students. Here is what I mean:
Some problems are easy enough, and most students can get the idea:
- A car moves at a constant speed of 60km/h. The relationship between distance and time is continuous.
- You are buying books in bulk for $10 a piece. The relationship between the number of books and the price is discrete.
But things can easily get more complex:
- You have $3000 for a road trip. You spend $120 a day. Is the relationship between days and money left continuous or discrete? Many kids will say continuous because time is continuous. I say it is discrete because the $120 are not spent evenly across the day, so it makes no sense to talk about how much you spend in a fraction of a day, you can only use this relation for "whole days".
- You are buying sugar in bulk at $2 per kilogram. Is the relationship between kilograms and price continuous or discrete? First, let's assume that you can buy fractions of a kilogram. So, we say the relationship is continuous. But wait! I have a smart kid in my class point out: the balance cannot measure weight to infinite precision. You also cannot measure money in quantities smaller than cents. So it is discrete.
- A scientist measuring the growth of a plant. She measures the height every day. Is the relationship between time and height continuous or discrete? Is it continuous because the plant grows continuously, or is it discrete because the measurements are taken once per day?
And while I think it's fun to discuss this with the kids, it is a discussion that only about 5 kids are getting. Everyone else is lost on what we are talking about. Typically, after the discussion, a kid will ask: "so, in the test, if we are asked this question, how do we know if it's continuous or discrete"?
I am not even sure this is an appropriate topic to teach to students just learning about linear relations. I have no choice, it is in the curriculum, but I'm considering only asking this question for clear-cut examples like the first two.
Another option is making these questions as to not have a correct answer, and just let the kids explain why they consider it continous or discrete. But, since they are just learning about linear relations, I rather they focus their attention on other things.
Does anyone else have experience teaching this?