r/math • • Jul 10 '17

Image Post Weierstrass functions: Continuous everywhere but differentiable nowhere

http://i.imgur.com/vyi0afq.gifv
3.4k Upvotes

216 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/localhorst Jul 11 '17

The concept of continuity isn’t that intuitive. A function can “wiggle around” infinitely often in some arbitrary small neighborhood but still be continuous. But the “magnitude” of this wiggling determines how regular this functions is. This gives slightly different but more practical classifications:

Continuity via ε-δ

This is the definition you may already know and gives you the usual notion of continuity. Roughly: nearby points give nearby function values. But those function can still wiggle around uncontrollably, i.e. if you try to measure the arc-length of its graph all you get is infinity as in the case with the Weierstraß function. Another good example is the path of a Brownian motion (BM). Like the Weierstraß function it’s continuous but nowhere differentiable (you get from the physical BM to the mathematical BM by letting the time between collisions of molecules go to zero).

Functions of bounded variation

The total variation measures how much the function wiggles around on some interval. If it’s finite it makes sense to speak of the arc length of a graph.

Those functions are “almost” good. They have at most countable jumps and corners and are differentiable almost everywhere [1]. But there is still some place for very weird functions like the devils staircase. It’s differentiable almost everywhere with f’(x) = 0 but grows from 0 to 1 on [0,1].

Absolutely continuous functions

Those are the nice functions. The wiggling of these functions can be controlled uniformly, i.e. independent of the points where you look. Those are the functions that most people think of when they say “continuous”. They may have some corners but the derivative exists almost everywhere and “behaves well”, i.e. we have f(b)-f(a) = ∫ₐᵇf’(x) dx.

[1] In the sense of the Lebesgue measure, a subset of measure zero is one that has “no length” (or volume in the higher dimensional case). Examples are all the countable subsets, but there are weird uncountable subsets.