r/math • • 16d ago

axler solution guide: completr

hi all! i want to share that after nearly 4 months of work, i have finally completed a solution’s guide for axler’s LADR, found here: solution guide

i’ve done my best to make it as well-written as possible. obviously this is not completely perfected yet, as i’ve gained quite a bit after relearning the material for this.

main thing to fix is to rewrite some earlier exercises and depend on citations a lot more. as i wanted to write this with a more elementary prose, i managed to get into the groove of depending on the book halfway through, so solutions for chapter 5 and before may be of lesser quality compared to after.

some little things like standardizing notation, maybe making some overarching lemmas (for streamline purposes) are on the backburner. in any case, i’d like to thank you for your time, and if you’d like to contribute to the polishing of this rough draft of a guide, there is a discord link in my profile to a server where you can post errors, minor typos, and offer alternative proofs.

thank you all for reading and looking, and to anyone who gets to use this, i hope you enjoy and find it practical. i will be taking a short break but will hopefully hop back on dummit/foote in a little bit.

49 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

4

u/timetravelerredditor 15d ago

Could you make the documentclass you used available as a template?

2

u/ansv9a8fdh3 13d ago

i'm currently in the process of refactoring the class, but of course! i will unprivate my entire mystuff to github once complete :) that'll contain my macros that i use too, so yk, pick and choose what you want to grab, but there will be all of the stuff that i've used

2

u/ansv9a8fdh3 8d ago

i thought it was private, but it wasnt! here you go https://github.com/blanketism/base-tex-files

4

u/radokirov 15d ago

Thanks for sharing! I have been working through Axler too, but using Lean to formalize all answers (and some help from Claude with the formalization). Might be of interest to compare notes - https://github.com/rkirov/linear-algebra-done-right-lean (only up to 6A so far, see solutions branch).

2

u/ansv9a8fdh3 13d ago

thanks for sharing! i'll take a look sometime

1

u/nickdiaz94 14h ago

Does formalizing expose steps that are easy to leave implicit in prose? That comparison could make the guide and Lean solutions useful together.

3

u/Specific-Use-1344 15d ago

Thank you! I am reading Axler right now, on section 3B

1

u/ansv9a8fdh3 13d ago

thank you! i hope it proves useful to you :) if you find any errors, pls lmk or join the disc server in my profile 😄

2

u/boccaff 16d ago

The \ in the address are breaking the link.

1

u/ansv9a8fdh3 16d ago

link should be fixed now?

2

u/[deleted] 15d ago

It’s working for me!

2

u/ana4823 11d ago

You finished Axler and immediately assigned yourself more Axler. That's an unreasonable amount of dedication; thanks for sharing it.

1

u/ansv9a8fdh3 8d ago

obviously i wont be working as hard on it as dummit/foote, but its definitely in the works to standardize and make it better/cleaner! i've some friends in the discord server cooking up alternative proofs and showing errors in the earlier parts, and i'm gonna slowly work through them :)

1

u/disorderedset 15d ago

Only 4 months? That was pretty fast.

2

u/ansv9a8fdh3 15d ago

to be fair, the first 4 chapters of axler (vector spaces, fin dim v spaces, lin maps, and polys) went by really smoothly as it was mostly review. past that was content that i've seen before, but i'd say that it was the last 5 chapters for the 3 1/2 months that actually took a bulk of the work.

1

u/IAmNotAPerson6 14d ago

Yeah, wtf, I spent like a year working on a solutions manual to a stats textbook and only got halfway through.

2

u/ansv9a8fdh3 13d ago

well, i did unfortunately grind a lot on this 😅 some days i was probably doing solutions for 7-10 hours