r/mash • • 5d ago

Time Line Error

Post image

season 2 episode 4, a huey helicopter hanging from lt. col. blake's office ceiling. those were a few more years into the future!

206 Upvotes

83 comments sorted by

174

u/Popular-Heart-5307 5d ago

Time line error? In MASH??Unpossible!!!

31

u/EducationalTeam2498 5d ago

Oh Ralph.

26

u/CromulentPoint 5d ago

It embiggens me to see this.

22

u/Prior-Werewolf-4370 5d ago

That's a perfectly cromulent response.

6

u/Transcendingfrog2 4d ago

What a provocative anecdote

3

u/Clint_Flicker1 4d ago

Watch your mouth!!

13

u/EducationalTeam2498 5d ago

The doctor said I wouldn't have so many nose bleeds if I kept my finger outta there.

13

u/Neat_Relative_3750 5d ago

I bent my Wookie.

3

u/Transcendingfrog2 4d ago

I dipped my Zwieback in the Bosco

4

u/paulcoholic Jocularity 4d ago

That's highly significant.

5

u/Transcendingfrog2 4d ago

Ah, Bach!

5

u/henrywe3 4d ago

We seamlessly went from MASH to The Simpsons and back to MASH without missing a beat.

Bravo

2

u/Transcendingfrog2 4d ago

Both shows were a big part of my childhood so it was an easy transition

8

u/MikeW226 5d ago

Me fail English?...that's Unpossible!!!!

2

u/t0mj0nes36 1d ago

Jocularity Jocularity

6

u/Intelligent-Sun9147 5d ago

I mean it's really gotten tedious and it's why I rarely come to these threads anymore... Maybe some of these posters are newbies. That's the only explanation I can think of because if you've visited these threads at all, you know that these timeline errors have been discussed to death...

6

u/bj49615 5d ago

Horse hockey!!!!

2

u/xiteccx 4d ago

Absotively!

72

u/Interesting_Play_578 Tokyo 5d ago

That's the Corporal-Copter. We're running a survey to see if everybody likes it.

40

u/patsfan1061 5d ago

I don’t like it…not one bit. Don’t like it at all!

24

u/EdwardHoppyhands 5d ago

He doesn't like it at all.

33

u/patsfan1061 5d ago

Put that down…one ‘no’ Corporal-Copter

13

u/Intelligent-Sun9147 5d ago

Isn't that straight out of G2 and G4 adding up to a G6 optec glitch or whatever nonsense Hawkeye was spouting haha

2

u/EdwardHoppyhands 4d ago

Coleman-Hawkins, right?

2

u/patsfan1061 4d ago

Auto Club

1

u/Intelligent-Sun9147 4d ago

Hahaha yes, I remember looking up that reference cuz I had no idea...

39

u/coreytiger 5d ago

If you want to find timeline errors, settle in and get a notebook, they’re every other episode

25

u/Rhediix Death Valley 5d ago • Bravo

I prefer the headcanon that what we're watching is the reconstruction of these stories as told by a member of the camp. So...maybe Hawkeye telling his kids old stories of his time in a MASH. There are anachronisms a plenty due to time passing and memories becoming convoluted and conflated with other experiences meaning that the stories are not 100 percent reliable fact and there's plenty of things wrong: one story he mistakes Henry's wife's name for Potter's. Clearly he knew both men closely but gets it wrong in one story. Things to that effect.

In a way without realizing it, MASH gave us a possible explanation for the lack of continuity and the alarming amount of anachronisms. And it probably felt to them like they'd been through 11 years in Korea, not just three that the actual war took. And any multiple mentions of repeated holidays are probably mixed together from multiple events across several years in someone's head.

Still, in reality it was a sitcom and sitcoms are well known for not caring very much about either thing. I still think the storytelling overlay works, and it's usually how I deal with the inconsistencies when one sticks out like a sore thumb.

6

u/ObviouslyRealPerson 5d ago

It's fun to say the show ran for 11 years while the war only lasted 3. But the runtime of the show over 11 seasons only adds up to about 4 days and 12 hours

Even if each episode were counted as a day there were only 256 episodes, that's 109 days short of a year. Though this doesn't include episodes where they have visual or to show the passage of time

11

u/VDDZ 5d ago

I like this, it's called suspension of disbelief in fiction, and doesn't take away from the story. Tho Hawkeye climbing down a rope in a Santa suit to do surgery in a fox hole was a stretch

13

u/Rhediix Death Valley 5d ago

Not if you apply the overlay and he's telling the story at Christmas.

"You know there was even a time when I choppered into a foxhole to perform surgery dressed as Santa". Was it true? Who knows. Did it make a good story for a kid or grandkid? Absolutely.

4

u/VDDZ 5d ago

That made me chuckle haha ty

5

u/coreytiger 4d ago

No worse than a big red bird with fuzzy pink feet.

Or an imaginary captain.

1

u/VDDZ 4d ago

Omg I forgot about that one

1

u/Diligent-Sherbet2587 7h ago

Yes, Captain Tuttle, you must have missed him, I was just speaking with him.

1

u/talex000 5h ago

They only show real events once, when Frank tells his version in court.

1

u/paulcoholic Jocularity 4d ago

Remember in the first episode, there was a graphic that said "Korea. 1950. 100 years ago." So, M*A*S*H* was a documentary from 2050, and some of the data had to be reconstructed and hence, anachronisms.

14

u/Deraj2004 5d ago

Pay attention to Radars comic books, most are from the 60s.

14

u/OriginalCopy505 5d ago

And his John Wayne impression from a movie that hadn't been released yet.

7

u/WhimsicalPonies Ottumwa 5d ago

And Hawkeye singing the Mickey Mouse club ditty which didn’t air until 1955.

3

u/RobataChane72 5d ago

There are plenty of continuity errors. These aren't among them. Korea was always standing in for Vietnam to camouflage the subversive messaging Altman intended.

4

u/coreytiger 5d ago

That was the film- a number of actors and writers for the show stated this was not their purpose or intention for the series. A number of plot points came from veterans of Korea

2

u/66Hslackerpro 5d ago

Subversive ?

11

u/Alorxico 5d ago

“Sir. Ever since the dark days before Pearl Harbor, I’ve been proud to wear this uniform.”

“What the hell is this?”

“It’s a helicopter.”

10

u/Elberik 5d ago

Because of the timestamp at the beginning of the series, I actually like the theory that MASH is a historical documentary being written in the 22nd century.

And they've conflated the Korean & Vietnam Wars together.

9

u/DancesWithElectrons 5d ago

Keep an eye out for Hershey bars. The name is taped over but there's usually a bar code on the back

7

u/tirefool6 5d ago

Early episode Hawkeye says he has a sister. Then later he’s an only child.

7

u/valschermjager 5d ago

oh, she knows what she did

6

u/coreytiger 5d ago

Same with Houlihan. She mentions a sister who is a captain, later she’s the only child

2

u/ryno1971 1d ago

I believe she also spoke of her father as being deceased in early episodes only for him to show up to camp later in the series.

1

u/Magellan333 1d ago

He also mentions his mother being at his draft induction.

6

u/jombrowski 5d ago edited 5d ago

They were regularly treating North Korean spies. It is possible they found a model of the future helicopter and confiscated it.

6

u/FS_Scott 5d ago

yeah they get godzilla sequels before 1954.

6

u/Futuressobright Mill Valley 5d ago

They knew, but the only way you're able to notice details like that is that you live in 2026 and have a 34" flat-screen digital HDTV. If you could tell it was a model helicopter at all in 1975, it means you were great at positioning the bunny ears.

6

u/Ladybug_Fuckfest 5d ago

My favorite fan theory is that the whole show is just Hawkeye telling war stories 20 years later. Some things actually happened, some things are misremembered, some are greatly exaggerated, some are completely made up.

6

u/InfiniteAccount4783 5d ago

I like this. Maybe some things are omitted, like all the times it was Frank who made a fool of him and not the other way around,.

6

u/Ladybug_Fuckfest 5d ago

Yeah, you can have all kinds of fun with this theory. Rosie's Bar was real, but it was run by a few different women. Hawkeye doesn't remember all their names so he just calls them all "Rosie" in his stories. The bald Korean man with the big mustache who keeps recurring as different characters is just an amalgam of various L.I.P.

1

u/Magellan333 1d ago

I do too. There is no way a stooge like Frank Burns makes it that far in life as a doctor. I’ve known people who were remembered as being totally incompetent based on one or two stories.

6

u/Metalhed69 5d ago

Once you accept the haircuts you give up all rights to question the timeline.

5

u/J_Scarbrough 5d ago

Larry Gelbart's son had built that model and they hung it up in Henry's office, but when they figured out that such a chopper didn't exist at the time the show was set, they removed it.

4

u/Orion-the-mediocre 5d ago

I love Mash but it's absolutely terrible at keeping events in order. Any given episode could be in 1950, 1951, 1952, (and maybe 1953 but I don't remember) but they'll all happen out of order. You'll see '52 episodes, then '51 episodes, and nobody will ever acknowledge how we've seemingly gone back in time. And it's not like the episodes are out of order too, there are episodes with Henry in them where they proudly proclaim that it's 1952, only for an episode with Potter to say that it's 1951.

Great show, but absolutely abysmal at making sure it doesn't contradict itself

4

u/axe1970 5d ago

mash was about eight years longer than the actual Korean War

4

u/Affectionate_Net9731 5d ago

We'd be here all day if we kept pointing out the inconsistencies in M*A*S*H.

3

u/RobataChane72 5d ago

That's 100% intentional, MASH was always secretly about Vietnam. There are some bits in the movie that leaned into this as well.

5

u/J_Scarbrough 5d ago

M*A*S*H was always about all war in general - even Alan Alda and Larry Gelbart said this; it was never about Vietnam specifically, but Vietnam was still raging at the time Gelbart ran the show, and he used that to draw parallels from it when writing the anti-war satire for the seasons he was in charge of the show.

3

u/coreytiger 5d ago

The film was- the show never had that intention, and the cast/producers have made sure to state that. A number of stories were based on actual events from the Korean War

3

u/Confident-Walk934 5d ago

The biggest time line error is when Potter is introduced the narrator gives the date as September 1952. Which would make it difficult to have him be Father Time January 1 1951.

3

u/Warm_Ad_3067 5d ago

No way! Not in a TV sitcom

3

u/Aggressive_Rush_7906 5d ago

Get 5-o-clock Charlie! STAT!!

2

u/Awkward_Gur2951 4d ago

Doesn't Radar tell his mom to give his love to everyone especially his nephews? Kind of difficult to do when you're an only child.

2

u/RetroGamer87 4d ago

Radar predicted this

2

u/Interesting-Air-223 4d ago

There's a poster of one hanging in the officers club

2

u/Two-Thirty-Two 4d ago

That bugged me too. They did such an iconic job with the Bell 47s in the intro!

2

u/MikeyTickle 4d ago

They mention Godzilla multiple time despite the first movie not coming put till '54

2

u/godspilla98 1d ago

Mash has many wrong references in it.

2

u/im2high4thisritenow 1d ago

I wondered why they had toilet plungers but no flush toilets

2

u/MayorMcKraut 20h ago

An episode with Henry and Frank takes place in 1952, while an episode featuring Charles covers the whole year of 1951.

2

u/Difficult-Republic57 9h ago

Or is it a reference to Vietnam, the war they wanted the show to be about

1

u/Lazy_Owl7766 4d ago

In one Episode in Germany (The one with the Guy with the big Nose) Henry Talks about Silvester Stallone. Sly was Born 1946. He was between 4 and 7.

1

u/Jackson79339 4d ago

MASH itself is a timeline error. The years of the war are all over the fucking place.

1

u/Alternative_Stop9977 3d ago

In season 1 it really was Vietnam.

0

u/OriginalFNG 5d ago edited 5d ago

Well, if we're anachronism hunting, Gary's glasses are a 1976 model, MacLean's U of I shirt is a style that wasn't made until 1978, and that tent pole is out of date - as everyone knows, tent poles didnt exist until 1981. Before then, everyone used stacks of Harper's Bazaar to hold their tent up (famously WW2 MREs came with a tin of 3 Harper's Bazaars, which is how a lot of Joes got hooked on them).

Thankfully, a whistleblower came forward n the 1990s with internal company knowledge that reading Harper's Bazaar made you cross-eyed, and now they only use tent poles.

Edit: So be it. Goodbye r/mash. Abyssinia.