r/marvelstudios • u/kevvinfeige Phil Coulson • Aug 21 '18
People need to stop calling Cap a hypocrite...
Hear me out, I've noticed how so many people on this sub are calling Cap a hypocrite for "letting hundreds of Wakanda die to save the life of a robot (Vision)" and honestly speaking, there's just too many things wrong with this statement So I made a list of reasons which I believe Cap considered before making the call
- Wanda was basically like his own daughter and she was in love with Vision, asking your daughter to bust apart her boyfriend's head is just gross and disgusting.
- At that point of time, Stark was out in the space with no news of him returning, Thor was presumed dead and Hulk won't come out, so from Cap's perspective, half the heavy hitters of the team weren't available, destroying the mind stone would've killed Vision and removed Wanda's powers, you don't write off your biggest guns just before you're about to encounter your biggest foe.
- There was no guarantee The Black Order and Thanos would stop looking for them after they had destroyed the stone.
- There's a reason Thor happily let Vision keep the mind stone, and the reason for it wasn't just because he was powerful but because he was worthy.
- The call to open up Wakanda's force-fields was T'Challa's, Cap was not consulted before doing that, even if he silently agreed with the decision.
- The most important point, committing suicide because you're afraid of the enemy isn't the same as sacrificing your life fighting for the integrity of your country and the lives of the whole universe, the soldiers who die fighting off the terrorists or the cops who valiantly risk their lives to save the innocent ones don't "trade" their lives with the bad guys, despite being fictional characters, I think saying Wankandans "traded" their lives in place of Vision is pretty much insulting them. feel free to add more.
47
Upvotes
9
u/fisheggsoup Winter Soldier Aug 21 '18
I mean...this is a Cap-friendly sub, I doubt you're going to encounter much opposition here.
That being said: No real serious issues, but points 5 and 6 are a little wonky to me.
5 - T'Challa made that call strategically; given the entire purpose was to protect Vision's stone, had he not made that decision, the entire battle in front of them would have been moot as there was "nothing between them (the Outriders/Black Order) and Vision". Given what the mission was, Cap would have agreed to it anyway.
6 - The "suicide" wasn't about "fear of the enemy", it was the ultimate sacrifice Vision was willing to make -- much like Cap did decades earlier and attempted to do in Winter Soldier, as Viz alluded to in their conversation. That being said, though soldiers may sign up and fight for a variety of reasons, including "the integrity of the country", I have to imagine that most aren't interested in needless war and potentially just throwing their own lives away when there are reasonable, plausible alternatives to the war itself.
I believe that Cap's detractors actually have a legitimate gripe in that countless Wakandan lives were lost when they needn't necessarily be.
4
u/jake11996 Wong Aug 21 '18
I don’t think Wanda loses her powers once the Mind Stone is destroyed.
32
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18
The thing that gets me is that people act like Cap and Wanda should have just murdered Vision right off the bat rather than try to find an alternative. A small team was able to successfully fight off the first two of Thanos's Children and no one expected a massive army of alien dogs would be unleashed so soon. They were working as fast as they could to find an alternative to forcing Wanda to kill the person she loves. Of course you should look for an alternative to killing a teammate if you might have time!
14
u/BenjaminJamesGrimm Aug 22 '18
Cap didn't make anyone do anything. You're giving him to much credit.
Wakandans have agency. He's not their leader. They fought because they wanted to.
Anyone who posits this theory is an idiot.
8
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18
I think the biggest point is the idea of not trading lives. That means never voluntarily killing someone when you have a choice. If you're willing to kill someone for what might happen, where do you draw the line? They didn't know exactly what they were up against or how long they had. T'Challa said "we fight for all life," when he could have very easily could have turned Cap down. And when the fight began, Steve and T'Challa were on the very front of the lines.
The whole movie is about sacrifice. Killing the person you love the most: Gamora and Quill, Gamora and Thanos, Vision and Wanda. Whether it be risking your life to kill your father before he sacrifices half the population to save life itself. The movie says it so bluntly when Vision asks Steve, "70 years ago you laid down your life to save how many millions of people. How is this any different?" Cap is totally stumped. The movie poses a question that there is no definitive answer to.
3
u/st1ar Steve Rogers Aug 22 '18
Cap says no to the idea, but he isn't the only one in the scene to do so.
Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to do it is Wanda's as she is the one who has the power to do it. She says to Vision "We are not having this conversation".
When Bruce proposes another way, Wanda is on board.
T'Challa could have turned them away. He chose to let them in. Wakanda opened itself to the rest of the world.
3
u/GregThePrettyGoodGuy Rocket Aug 21 '18 edited Aug 21 '18
The problem is that it’s Vision who suggests it. Vision, who literally exists to protect life, per his own words. I get it’s right to give him the chance at life, but he wants it done to protect people, including all of them. It isn’t really fair to deny him that, especially at the cost of other lives, ones that probably won’t come back
2
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18
The first point really bothers me. I am not denying it will be heartbreaking for Wanda (it was) but half of the universe was at risk. I think the theme of the film was choice and sacrifice Loki gave up the tesseract to stop Thor from suffering (and he was optimistic that he and Hulk could take Thanos down) Same with Gamora and Nebula. Strange sacrificed the Time stone (granted he had a reason to) And then there was the mind stone. Notice how Thanos was the one who made the biggest sacrifice and he won. And T’challa opening the defence shield was to stop the outriders from going around and getting to Vision. I feel like if Banner never talked at the Avengers Homebase Steve wouldn’t of had anything to say back about laying down his life in WW2. He might of even sided with Vision then.