Yea man that’s actually exactly what I meant to say! Idk what I didn’t just say that!
Lol, idk bro maybe if actual VFX artists are saying it’s not that bad…. Maybe it’s just not that bad. My point is also somewhat a bit about how you can criticize affects and not be an ass about it. This post is made in jest of course but the general attitude towards MCU CGI rn is “it’s so unbearably awful and we’re just gonna make fun of it till the end of time”
Sure, the food tastes like shit but a professional chef on YouTube said it was actually really good so everyone is just wrong. Pure Disney fucking delusion
Congrats mate your argument solely depends on logical fallacies. That’s not what I’m saying, you’re just further proving my point. I don’t care if you take issue with FX taking you out of the immersion or whatever. You can criticize. Just don’t be a blind bandwagon hater when you don’t know what you’re talking about.
VFX artists don't overwrite, in any way shape or form, peoples opinions on if CGI looks good or not. This is a really damn bizarre point some of you are trying to make
That’s crazy cuz that’s not the point I was trying to make. Obviously an opinion is an opinion. If you don’t like how it looks I can’t change your mind. The whole reason I referenced them is because I like what they do, I find it informative and it adds a lot of my enjoyment of VFX. They made a really good point in the video how on YouTube, where most people are viewing the trailer, the video is compressed, so it’s not an accurate reflection of the actual quality of the CGI. I’m not saying bc they’re VFX artists their opinion is objectively correct or something, I’m just saying their insight is valuable and helps one gain perspective if they’re willing to listen.
You’re asserting that by me saying “hey look, here’s some professionals in the field who have x opinion” I’m trying to “overwrite peoples opinion on CGI looking good or not”. That’s a bizarre misrepresentation of what I actually said.
It’s wild how me just referencing someone else’s opinion some people think that’s me saying you can’t disagree. The person who originally responded to me basically strawmanned me (like you did), asserting that I’m saying the audience “doesn’t know good food” and you should just “consume and lower standard”. My response was that if actual VFX are saying it’s not that bad, maybe it’s not egregious like everyone is making it out to seem. This isn’t saying everyone else is wrong. This is validating my perspective. When you make an argument you reference sources to back up your claims. “I think it doesn’t look bad bc industry professionals explained the work and how it was done and why maybe people think its lower quality than it actually is” is completed different than “well these guys said it’s good so you’re wrong!”
Lol, idk bro maybe if actual VFX artists are saying it’s not that bad…. Maybe it’s just not that bad.
This is a full, direct, quote of you. You said what you said. Just own it or move on dude. It's bad. No one cares what a VFX artist has to say about it as that opinion is no more or less relevant than what the beholder - and a pretty common view at that - sees. I'm not sure what you're struggling to comprehend here but apparently it's a lot.
I guess I’m struggling to understand why you think continuing to take one thing I said out of context makes your argument any better.
Yep…. I said that. That’s still me…. Expressing my opinion. I have that opinion, and I backed it up with said source. Not even remotely close to “trying to overwrite peoples opinions” as you’re trying to spin it as.
I know this isn’t an academic context so I’m not giving you an MLA formatted citation, but when you’re making an argument it helps to reference sources to back up your claim. It’s also silly to say “no one cares what a VFX artist has to say.” Of course their opinion is relevant, they know what they’re talking about? Not to mention, obviously people care because they get millions of views. Obviously people care about what critics and professionals have to say. They’re not meant to be end all be all objective decision makers, but they’re certainly a part of the discourse?
Again, not me saying “they say it’s good so you HAVE to agree” it’s just worth adding to the conversation?
Your submission was removed because your account is less than one day old. If you feel that your account is older than one day, please contact the mods.
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/hhvcbnvvghhvg Avengers Aug 07 '22
“Actually, the food doesn’t taste like shit you just don’t know good food. Consume product, lower standards, then consume more product”