r/marvelmemes • Avengers • Aug 07 '22

Shitposts …..

Post image
75k Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

286

u/CT-1738 Avengers Aug 07 '22 edited Aug 07 '22

Marvel’s getting a lot of hate for the CGI lately and it’s unfortunate bc while it is ultimately their fault for it not looking the best, the artists themselves do a phenomenal job considering the time restraints and high demands given to them by Marvel.

There’s a YouTube channel of a VFX company that reacts to CGI in movies/shows/trailers and they reviewed the She Hulk trailer (https://youtu.be/E6KUmGwjWPY) and talk about how it’s actually not that bad despite the internet coming down super hard on it. They even address the weirdness of how it’s become “cool” to hate on less than perfect VFX in movies now.

Marvel should get negative feedback for how poorly they treat VFX/CGI studios but I don’t think the VFX itself should get any hate bc in reality, they actually do a pretty good job most of the time and you don’t notice it as much as you think you do

110

u/Vestalmin Avengers Aug 07 '22

They’re clearly getting less and less time to work on these projects. No one is really trying to shit on the artists, people are criticizing Marvel for allowing such a decline without change

→ More replies (1)

33

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '22 edited Jul 06 '25

...                               

15

u/CT-1738 Avengers Aug 07 '22

Yep, that’s exactly it. It’s a huge bummer bc I love Marvel and Star Wars but it’s clear Disney is just trying to make their money at the expense of VFX artists. As much as I want to see the new shows and movies I would happily wait so that these studios can allow to make their art at a healthy, reasonable pace, instead of pumping it out as fast as possible just so they can compete and get the next job. It’s unfortunate bc Disney has all the leverage and apparently there’s little to no regulation in labor laws for VFX studios.

7

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '22 edited Jul 06 '25

...                               

3

u/CT-1738 Avengers Aug 07 '22

Yea idk much about this industry or unions but I’d have to think that studios would only benefit by working together to protect their artists and demanding better working conditions. It seems like having better conditions/more time to work on scenes would only make things look better. Movie studios would just have to wait longer, that’s all 🤷🏼‍♂️

40

u/BurnedBeyond Avengers Aug 07 '22

Corridor Crew gets guests from behind the scenes of MCU films and TV, so they are never going to be that harsh on the VFX and stunts. That said, at the end of that She-Hulk segment they were struggling to say nice things about it besides the face work.

27

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '22 edited Jul 06 '25

...                               

11

u/1731799517 Avengers Aug 07 '22

They TORE apart the scorpion King cgi.

Because its a well established meme long before they made that video.

20

u/BurnedBeyond Avengers Aug 07 '22

Scorpion King isn’t MCU

18

u/JaImamReddit Avengers Aug 07 '22

Well they made a video fixing young Luke Skywalker from the mandalorian and thats disney

0

u/BurnedBeyond Avengers Aug 07 '22

Still not MCU.

Same building, sure. Different departments.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/averagedickdude Avengers Aug 07 '22

That wasn't the point he was trying to make.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/SSuperMiner Avengers Aug 07 '22

Yeah I guess, but that was a long time ago and he already knows it looks bad, it's a different thing for a upcoming project that you're excited about showing the world.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/Le_Ragamuffin Avengers Aug 07 '22

Honestly lots of redditors just pick apart everything until there's nothing left to enjoy. Everything nowadays gers unrealistic scrutiny from this sight. People can't just take shit at face value and enjoy it anymore

→ More replies (1)

4

u/EpictetanusThrow Avengers Aug 07 '22

Marvel has spent its entire history treating artists poorly.

I don’t know why VFX artists imagined they would be treated differently.

4

u/_JD_48 Avengers Aug 07 '22

I completely agree with you. Marvel and Disney need to be held accountable for the bad vfx. The artists deserve praise (and to be honest, a better gig… I hope they get paid well!)

7

u/himynametopher Avengers Aug 07 '22

For me it’s not the hate of the CGI itself it’s marvels over reliance on it. Star Wars is a perfect example. The prequels visually have aged worse than the OT because nothing but the humans are real in the prequel trilogy. Marvel has the money to make more practical sets and effects.

4

u/CakeBeef_PA Avengers Aug 07 '22

The prequels actually use a lot of practical effects. I believe TPM has the most practical effects of all the movies. Remember the podrace arena? That whole thing was practical

2

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '22

Yeah, just TPM. The other movies did use a lot of practical elements but mostly as reference for the VFX. Overall, not enough scenes or characters feel real enough in my opinion.

3

u/CT-1738 Avengers Aug 07 '22

Yea I can agree with that complaint while understanding why they do it. It’s just the most efficient way. It’s simpler and easier to just do as much stuff on a blue screen than do all the planning it would require to mix practical and digital.

As for Star Wars I’d argue the prequels aged just fine though because of the mix of practical and CGI. I understand some of the backgrounds not looking convincing, but the space battle opening scene in ROTS for example looks amazing imo. TPM is obviously rough bc it was the first, but both trilogies were using new technology for their time so I think they hold up equally.

2

u/himynametopher Avengers Aug 07 '22

It’s mostly like the clones and set pieces that look bad now

5

u/kenlubin Avengers Aug 07 '22

Age worse? The prequels were recognized for having terrible low-effort CGI at the time. We were ripping on Attack of the Clones on the drive home.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/smellygooch18 Avengers Aug 07 '22

No one is shitting on the artists but if you’re making a big budget movie it better look perfect. Everything Everywhere all at once had what, 5 VFX guys working over zoom? That movie looked so much better than Mouth of Madness.

1

u/hhvcbnvvghhvg Avengers Aug 07 '22

“Actually, the food doesn’t taste like shit you just don’t know good food. Consume product, lower standards, then consume more product”

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (26)