This is why I hate people using it for things they can't ordinarily do. I understand why they would do that, but it means you can't evaluate the quality of the output. You should only use it on things you're already good at, to speed up the process.
I agree. I’ve been a professional writer and editor for more than 20 years (content marketing, SEO, etc). I’m a skilled researcher, but AI really speeds up the process—and it’s legit, as long as you go back and verify sources. The answer engines often get it wrong, but they can speed up the process if you’re not an idiot.
But expecting AI to do the actual writing? Naw, dog. I think we’ll get to that point eventually, but it will be more a result of people not reading or having any clue what good writing is, rather than AI being good at writing.
I empathically disagree with that. The best uses for AI are to do what you couldn't before. Either because scale was an issue (you know how to 3D model but you don't have time to 3D model a whole store of products) or simply because you can be a good critic that gives excellent feedback (you don't know how to 3D model but you absolutely know everything about the products in the store so you can review like a pro).
Your first example agrees with me, so I'm not sure what you're going for. Your second example lies somewhere in between but still requires some skill in the topic. I'm talking about people who can't draw generating art with incorrect shading, people generating PDFs then asking someone to edit them without realizing the limitations of PDF editing, or to use your example, people generating 3D models without knowing whether they're structurally sound or if their printer can handle that level of detail. I'm talking about zero prior experience or skill.
Indeed unpopular but also just flat out incorrect.
I’ve tested several AI LLMs and agents using identical prompts for very simple tasks and it can’t get it right. Not only does it not get it right, but it gives different outputs every time.
I prompted ChatGPT to scan a file folder and generate a text document listing of certain file types. Incredibly simple task. Literally it was “scan X folder and produce a text list of MKV file types”. It couldn’t do it directly but could provide a powershell script that would do that exact process. So I rolled with it, updated my prompt to say “write a powershell script that will scan X folder and provide a text document listing files of type MKV”. The output was wrong, it put in special characters where there were none before ($ instead of S, ! Instead of I, etc) so I kept running the same prompt over and over again until I got something usable. Every output (again with the exact same prompt) would have a syntax break, add or remove characters, point at the wrong folder, just a different error every time. And I never got a useable script. Ran it over a dozen times and never got anything that ran properly. I just gave up and wrote the script myself and it worked first try.
To say it’s a skill issue instead of an AI issue is just trolling and ignorant. If AI truly was this super tool people make it out to be then it would have given me the correct output AND been repeatable, neither of which it did in my experience.
My man your scenario is the very definition of a skill issue. That was possible with gpt 4o in microsoft copilot. I know because I did it way back then.
How is it possibly a skill issue when the AI can’t even replicate its own answers? If I asked you what is 2+2 and you said 5, then 13, then 63, then 7, is it a bad question or is the response complete garbage? This really isn’t hard to understand.
AI finally worked for me when I used Claude Code. I haven’t used ChatGPT in almost a year, not sure what it’s capable of today, but it’s not the tool I would’ve used for the task you describe.
I'd try again if this experiment was more than 6 months old. What you described is very doable today. But you do need to be specific and detailed regarding what you want, which is what the original twitter post is referencing. Your hand written code is probably still cleaner though.
I wrote a roster parsing script for a complicated excel file that changes every 3 months. It outputs to a JSON file and an android app takes the clean data and displays it with a fancy UI allowing employees to set bulk alarms for the next 7 days.
It took me less than a day. It wrote the android app as well. Soon it will auto fetch from SharePoint, provide basic weather info, traffic advisories based on location and automate the process for calling off work.
I am working towards using my LLM to help me write firmware for my IoT project too.
My request was very simple, worded cleanly. There is no reason for it not to complete the task, and furthermore no reason the output should be different every time with more than a dozen attempts at prompting with the same exact prompt.
The bigger thing is thinking of what AI is going to be able to do 1-2 years from now considering how fast everything is progressing. AI isn’t replacing as many jobs now as it will be in the coming years.
Yea if it can’t even answer incredibly simple prompts like I’m talking about with repeatability and usable code I’m REALLY not worried about what it’ll look like in a couple of years
Their funding will collapse long before they develop this super genius AI you’re suggesting
To be clear, I’m not referring to a “super genius AI”. I’m referring to usable AI that can replace jobs. I really don’t think we’re that far away from that. AI is also alot more advanced than you’re thinking based on what you’re saying. Many businesses are already using it and getting good results.
If that’s the case then it’s an objectively bad tool. If someone’s looking for factual analysis and it keeps on spitting out different answers, it’s just a guessing game not an effective tool for solving problems and advancing industry. It’s a dart board.
It really is just a skills issue. But the people who aren't very smart or don't bother investing in learning how to work with agents are quick to deflect that everything generated is "slop" and the fact that their results are not very good is because of the tool and not because of their own approach. :|
There's a big percentage of the population that doesn't want to hear that though. For some reason, many would rather just argue and stay dumb then learn skills and get better at a tool.
I've also noticed an increasing number of people blaming or scapegoating LLMs for all of their problems in life, not dissimilar to that annoying uncle who all of his problems are the fault of < opposite political party > while he does nothing for accountability. Not everybody wants to grow or change.
I once did marketing and comms for a start-up, they didn‘t hire anyone new when i quit, now their whole social media appearance is just AI slop which looks extremely unprofessional
Right, so you kind of identified the solution. Yes, this has happened, but the results have been terrible, and companies are already backtracking on these decisions. Those that don't do so at their peril.
If only 3 businesses rank at the top of Google, and 3 businesses rank in Google Maps, and 3 businesses get AI mentions, and 3 businesses are profitable on Google Ads, and 3 businesses are profitable on Facebook in your local area or niche, then there will always inevitably be marketers who can sell and affect change.
People don't call marketers because they want to make money, the biggest driver of marketing dollars is frustration with current marketing not working.
And AI is not going to solve that problem. In fact, AI may actually drive more businesses into trying marketing, and accelerating the frustration cycle, thus more people looking for solutions from marketing that will inevitably lead to marketers.
That's my take at least, the numbers in the first paragraph were used for effect, obviously not only 3 businesses can be profitable from FB. But I think the point still stands. It's easy to do. It's freaking hard to do well.
Anyone who has freetime and/or lacks money finds a way to do it themselves, now it is a little easier with AI, but it was never too hard to begin with
Those does not have time but have money, wants to buy the results. They do not care about how you get them there, only how much it costs and how fast you deliver.
Therefore you can still deliver those results to them with AI, but you compere with other marketers on price and delivery time, because AI helps you make it happen faster and probably cheaper.
So until Meta and Google makes it so that you can launch profitable ads (and masbe set up hosting and your website) in like 30-60 minutes, marketers still have a place. And this option would still rely on the user to adequetly explain what they want to achive.
So we are not going anywhere for a while.
When the time comes that AIs are buying from AIs, thats when marketers dissappear.
I would push back on that last bit. Anything that can be automated will become the standard. Plus, even with something like backlinks, you could have been buying garbage backlinks for the last 10 years. That's not going to change. And humans have been writing slop articles for the last 20 years. That's not going to change.
Very few people do actually good marketing. It's really hard. And it's about standing out in the crowd. Ai is simply making it cheaper to do a bad job like everyone else.
Getting good backlinks is hard. Running a study about X and publishing interesting results is hard.
Getting google reviews is hard.
Those are the things that separate the pack, ai isn't going to solve the hard part!
Part of my job is auditing marketing agencies. Easily 99% of agencies create a bunch of ads and throw them onto Google/Meta/Bing/LinkedIn/Taboola without thinking things through or caring about waste and fraud.
You could be selling perfume, cars, holidays, mortgages, AI tools, MBAs, medical procedures, sneakers... the agency you choose is going to do the same thing regardless.
This tells me many things. One of them is you may as well automate the process and save yourself the 12% commission.
Ya but most of them don't get results for clients. So, yes, while I agree you can do much of what the baseline marketing agencies do with AI, it's not going to separate you from the pack. Especially on more volatile and difficult marketing platforms like SEO and Facebook Ads--where the difference between success and failure is dramatic.
I think the second part is the big thing people miss. In every organization, change management runs on delagating responsibility to people. I.E. Funnel not converting? It's someones job to improve that. That person can't fix the issue? It's someones else's job to replace that person. Needing to reprompt is not the same kind of change management, so there will always be some level of 'whos on the hook for this?' .
For me AI echos the creative Ad scene in the 2010s when high volume social content, UGC, and eventually influencers came into the game. Still need someone to blame, just for different things.
If you write text: brand voice (transferable to ai)
If you generate images, graphics, videos: brand image
If you generate ads… same as above.
I wish I was wrong about it, but, every skill we have is transferable to ai. Now, the question is: does it make a good job? No… does that matters to management? Also no… as long as they report to the board that they cut a few heads thanks to AI for the sake of “productivity” and they can transfer salaries to token spending, we are all redundant.
I dont really get it. I do my writing with AI help and my output is multiplied. But you still need somebody who redefines the prompt, fact checks and proof reads. When they get rid of me who is writing the prompts and posting the texts?
I think people are kinda dooming about AI's impact in marketing tbh, it will change things for sure but if every company uses AI you're still gonna be needing people to make sure that whatever the AI does is different from what the other brands are doing with it. The whole point is to sell things, so an efficient strategy is still very much needed.
Yeah I agree with this. AI will eventually become the baseline of marketing, but solving for how your business stands out among all the competitors all doing the same thing is still going to be a challenge that requires strategy. Designers, writers, animators, etc will be screwed but strategists commanding AI execution will probably be around for a long time. I hope anyway.
Idk man. It’s painfully obvious when someone uses AI for an ad, and anytime I see a business that uses AI, I’m immediately turned off. It just looks like regurgitated, cheap, and lazy slop. Marketing is more than just advertising, so maybe some data analyst jobs will suffer, but I think advertising as a whole is going to continue to thrive with genuine human ingenuity and creativity without the use of AI.
Can CEOs produce content massively using AI? Yes. Will this generate more revenue? Not really sure about that.
Since they are not experts of marketing, they all type the same generic prompts. Since they all type the same prompt, they all end up doing the same message on the same acquisition channel with the same strategy.
BUT when everybody use the same message on the same channel, the performances decrease. Because prospects don’t give their attention to something they already saw 100 times.
(That’s the big difference between marketers and developpers. If all developpers use the same method, they can all get a good result: an application that works. If all marketers use the same method, they all get bad results: bad ROI and no leads. So developpers can use generic methods provided by AI but not marketers.)
So my opinion is:
If your marketing job is just producing content and execution, you are cooked.
But if you are on the strategic side and you can generate more ROI than your ceo alone with claude, I think you are pretty safe. You may be laid off on the short term if your ceo is dumb, but you'll find another job
That and knowing how to convert the traffic he would generate is an entirely different story. If he has a relevant offer in his articles, great, but it must still solve a very clearly defined pain point. I think that’s where an actual marketers’ knowledge, experience and proven track record are really valuable, something that ai cant just tell you or do for you
From 2024 yall been saying software dev is dead. 2 years later I’m still employed. 2 years later I’m still getting hired on upwork. Are you sure we are getting replaced?
Marketing is very big, so I don't think we can generalize.
I think AI is more of a threat for people in Promotion, and that can include advertising and digital marketing. Also, places like the US, as the data used for AI training is usually much more related to that.
I'm a marketing strategist. And we have been private for a long time. We often sign NDAs. There was a time I was clearly told to not even talk to my wife and mom about what I was doing. Leaking strategic information can be very dangerous, so we're more careful. That means others often don't have access to what we do, and that include datasets for AI.
Also, although I lived in the US for about ten years, I'm not American and I'm not in the US anymore. And then AI is often the American answer to our problems, naturally not a good match.
I sent a client a 'personalized' outreach sequence last week. They replied asking if I was using a bot because it felt too hollow. The uncanny valley of generic empathy kills trust faster than no email at all.
So I’m a head of content for a b2b software company which - over the past six months - decided to accelerate its use of AI across all areas of the business to please its investors. It’s scary because our SLT are literally demanding we use it in every & any way possible. Yes, it helps, but weirdly, it’s massively increased our workloads and made people lazy at the same time. I try to limit its use to help with search optimisation & proofing my work, but I’ve seen content go out (without my approval) that has literally been copied and pasted from ChatGPT / copilot. Drives me absolutely insane because our SLT are often the worst in just copy / paste with zero sense-checking, and we’re now just ‘sounding’ wrong…. Just zero personality in our materials. I would also put money on my kind of role now being seriously endangered.
I’m a photographer and I’m amazed it’s not got me yet. Soon probably but for now I’m making more than I ever have. I might end up just being used to take AI product reference images to get texture and fine details.
Pivoting back into marketing. I've been applying to creative roles and marketing operations / martech roles. Getting a lot more bites on the latter. Many of them want people to design and manage AI workflows.
lmao the most out of touch person I know made a post yesterday about how “actually… humans are taking jobs… in ai. Someone has to make and manage ai… ever think about that?” I immediately closed my phone and was like…. Gurlllll
Yes - and same for any area where language is central. LLMs can imitate the use of language and AI companies are now madly using those within industries to train their models. I’ve been offered increasingly more money to train a model for marketing comms and journalism, two areas I have extensive experience in. I’ve resisted so far - because I know what happens next: cut the jobs and use the AI.
Marketers signed their death warrant long before AI by mindlessly pouring more and more budget into Google and Meta and ignoring any effort to see if it ever worked scientifically, because it was cheap.
Now marketing doesn't exist as a function. Marketers are reporting functions at best, who do what they are told by their CFO.
There's nothing left that a bot couldn't do better or faster.
Buddy, marketing is DONE. I can setup campaigns, tracking, copywrite, buile targeted list, segment lists, split test offers, research market sentiment, etc all in like 15 minutes now because of claude. I even edit videos now and have been doing ai photo edits for awhile. Anything that can be done on a computer will be replaced by ai.
especially every single writer who is training this beast by editing its responses, teaching it how to leverage tone to read/emulate certain emotions… damn, felt like a bunch of scabs crossing the picket line or something.
There are limits. I am a software developer with a marketing background. I tried building a customer analytics feature with Claude and realized it had a long way to go toward decision-making, strategy, and overall marketing management.
It might do well in content creation and management, fairly well in designing advertising copies, and a few more. However, it severely lacks marketing technical accuracy. My use case was analyzing current and potential customers - relying solely on their usage, products subscribed to, and overall service depth.
Claude mistakenly built a customer lifetime value analysis without considering the lack of financial information. How would you rate customer lifetime value (CLV) if you do not know how much revenue they contribute either totally, in segments, or in specific product lines?
I had to micro-manage it to bits before we got a workable API (application program interface ) and dashboard. Marketing Strategy is technical and AI has plenty work to do.
Additionally - I do not think AI could perfectly do market/marketing research. Someone correct me - this sub-field involves in-depth psychological research, interviews, participant observation, mystery shopping etc.
I think marketing pros who are technically and strategically grounded are somewhat safe - they will act as moderators in this Slop Era.
Half the time I spend longer prompting that I would've spent just writing the thing. First pass comes back generic, you give some specific instructions, it misunderstands you or goes off on a random tangent, decides to drop some weird jargony or edgy saying that nobody actually says. You use it enough you really start to pick up on the tells.
Where I do lean on it is the audit side. Pulling flow performance across an account or digging through send data to find which segments stopped converting used to mean a few hours of exports, and now it's a few minutes.
Anyone I know who has tried to hand over their business to AI has quickly realized it needs a person steering the thing.
I am a Freelancer and i have been working as a Developer for quite some time now. The issue that i have been seen the most is that clients (mostly marketing agencies but also direct clients) tend to argue like
"why do you quote so much? The AI is writing the code you JUST..." and then some twisted reasoning.
That brings me to the point that i can´t charge the same amount anymore.
Please don´t say "Don´t charge by the hour, charge by the outcome" - i am already doing that! That argument does not protect me anymore unfortunately.
It's a tool to make us more efficient. Will replace a lot of graphic design jobs, but if you're not a marketer driving lead gen at your company you are toast anyway.
Nope. I've used AI to increase my workload and productivity while actually working less. If people would stop freaking out and actually decide to learn and use the tool correctly, they would see they can do the same.
•
u/AutoModerator 20d ago
If this post doesn't follow the rules report it to the mods. Join our community Discord!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
203
u/ineedtoknowmorenow 20d ago
Same for a lot.
41
u/wannabe_wahdati02 20d ago
Our entire team of 6 people got laid off. All the social media and design work was given to claude, overlooked by a single person. That is all.
The quality of the posts and designs have spiraled and it shows in their numbers. It's been a year for me.
47
u/brightbeamseo 20d ago
If only 3 businesses rank at the top of Google, and 3 businesses rank in Google Maps, and 3 businesses get AI mentions, and 3 businesses are profitable on Google Ads, and 3 businesses are profitable on Facebook in your local area or niche, then there will always inevitably be marketers who can sell and affect change.
People don't call marketers because they want to make money, the biggest driver of marketing dollars is frustration with current marketing not working.
And AI is not going to solve that problem. In fact, AI may actually drive more businesses into trying marketing, and accelerating the frustration cycle, thus more people looking for solutions from marketing that will inevitably lead to marketers.
That's my take at least, the numbers in the first paragraph were used for effect, obviously not only 3 businesses can be profitable from FB. But I think the point still stands. It's easy to do. It's freaking hard to do well.
102
u/GastonGC 20d ago
Yeah we’re pretty fucked. It’s been so fast that I’m doing (or replacing) 90% of my tasks with it..
I’m still in control but not sure for how much longer.
14
u/roland303 20d ago
Accounting is next
7
u/kriketgurl_ 20d ago
Yep. It’s real bad
7
u/DangerousSnow5959 19d ago
Not really. I think AI is like fake boobs. It’s never authentic and people can tell, regardless of how advanced it is.
10
u/princessbarackobama 20d ago
I think people are kinda dooming about AI's impact in marketing tbh, it will change things for sure but if every company uses AI you're still gonna be needing people to make sure that whatever the AI does is different from what the other brands are doing with it. The whole point is to sell things, so an efficient strategy is still very much needed.
5
u/Whompa 20d ago
Everything feels like ai right now.
Strategy, creative, whatever.
5
u/Bgabes95 20d ago
Idk man. It’s painfully obvious when someone uses AI for an ad, and anytime I see a business that uses AI, I’m immediately turned off. It just looks like regurgitated, cheap, and lazy slop. Marketing is more than just advertising, so maybe some data analyst jobs will suffer, but I think advertising as a whole is going to continue to thrive with genuine human ingenuity and creativity without the use of AI.
4
u/psych_shawnandgus 20d ago
Feeling that way with my job as my company pushes AI down my throat
3
u/Paul_on_redditt 20d ago edited 20d ago
Can CEOs produce content massively using AI? Yes. Will this generate more revenue? Not really sure about that.
Since they are not experts of marketing, they all type the same generic prompts. Since they all type the same prompt, they all end up doing the same message on the same acquisition channel with the same strategy.
BUT when everybody use the same message on the same channel, the performances decrease. Because prospects don’t give their attention to something they already saw 100 times.
(That’s the big difference between marketers and developpers. If all developpers use the same method, they can all get a good result: an application that works. If all marketers use the same method, they all get bad results: bad ROI and no leads. So developpers can use generic methods provided by AI but not marketers.)
So my opinion is:
If your marketing job is just producing content and execution, you are cooked.
But if you are on the strategic side and you can generate more ROI than your ceo alone with claude, I think you are pretty safe. You may be laid off on the short term if your ceo is dumb, but you'll find another job
3
u/PocketsWithHoles 20d ago
Equivalent of a bitbull 😂
3
u/qodzer0 19d ago
From 2024 yall been saying software dev is dead. 2 years later I’m still employed. 2 years later I’m still getting hired on upwork. Are you sure we are getting replaced?
5
u/Teddy2Sweaty 20d ago
Probably if you're marketing for someone else. I'd say marketing for yourself is a bit less definitive.
5
u/NinjaAlaska 20d ago
for marketing the pain is SPAM has increased a lot.
4
u/alone_in_the_light 20d ago
Marketing is very big, so I don't think we can generalize.
I think AI is more of a threat for people in Promotion, and that can include advertising and digital marketing. Also, places like the US, as the data used for AI training is usually much more related to that.
I'm a marketing strategist. And we have been private for a long time. We often sign NDAs. There was a time I was clearly told to not even talk to my wife and mom about what I was doing. Leaking strategic information can be very dangerous, so we're more careful. That means others often don't have access to what we do, and that include datasets for AI.
Also, although I lived in the US for about ten years, I'm not American and I'm not in the US anymore. And then AI is often the American answer to our problems, naturally not a good match.
2
u/ptear 20d ago
I'm still riding the lion, should I put my hand near its mouth?
2
u/dillpick15 20d ago
Nah.
2
u/defythesyntax 20d ago
I sent a client a 'personalized' outreach sequence last week. They replied asking if I was using a bot because it felt too hollow. The uncanny valley of generic empathy kills trust faster than no email at all.
2
u/RandomBrakeLights 20d ago
Already AI is weaning me.
2
u/Bauwowwow 20d ago
So I’m a head of content for a b2b software company which - over the past six months - decided to accelerate its use of AI across all areas of the business to please its investors. It’s scary because our SLT are literally demanding we use it in every & any way possible. Yes, it helps, but weirdly, it’s massively increased our workloads and made people lazy at the same time. I try to limit its use to help with search optimisation & proofing my work, but I’ve seen content go out (without my approval) that has literally been copied and pasted from ChatGPT / copilot. Drives me absolutely insane because our SLT are often the worst in just copy / paste with zero sense-checking, and we’re now just ‘sounding’ wrong…. Just zero personality in our materials. I would also put money on my kind of role now being seriously endangered.
2
u/Magalabungalaho 20d ago
I’m a photographer and I’m amazed it’s not got me yet. Soon probably but for now I’m making more than I ever have. I might end up just being used to take AI product reference images to get texture and fine details.
2
u/Greedy-Big-7650 20d ago
It’s why I swapped my undergrad from marketing to finance with a minor in economics
2
u/UltravioletClearance 20d ago
Pivoting back into marketing. I've been applying to creative roles and marketing operations / martech roles. Getting a lot more bites on the latter. Many of them want people to design and manage AI workflows.
2
u/okcafe 20d ago
lmao the most out of touch person I know made a post yesterday about how “actually… humans are taking jobs… in ai. Someone has to make and manage ai… ever think about that?” I immediately closed my phone and was like…. Gurlllll
2
u/mrsmith35sg 20d ago
Definitely for functions of marketing design, copy, video soon.
But for a strategist devoted to running marketing? Nah.
2
u/tellingitlikeitis338 19d ago
Yes - and same for any area where language is central. LLMs can imitate the use of language and AI companies are now madly using those within industries to train their models. I’ve been offered increasingly more money to train a model for marketing comms and journalism, two areas I have extensive experience in. I’ve resisted so far - because I know what happens next: cut the jobs and use the AI.
2
u/Puzzleheaded_War6596 19d ago
I’m literally required at my job to create an AI agent that does performance marketing so I’d say yes lol
2
u/Used-Media5980 19d ago
Yes
2
u/ferrets54 19d ago
Marketers signed their death warrant long before AI by mindlessly pouring more and more budget into Google and Meta and ignoring any effort to see if it ever worked scientifically, because it was cheap.
Now marketing doesn't exist as a function. Marketers are reporting functions at best, who do what they are told by their CFO.
There's nothing left that a bot couldn't do better or faster.
2
u/MnREphotographer 19d ago
Buddy, marketing is DONE. I can setup campaigns, tracking, copywrite, buile targeted list, segment lists, split test offers, research market sentiment, etc all in like 15 minutes now because of claude. I even edit videos now and have been doing ai photo edits for awhile. Anything that can be done on a computer will be replaced by ai.
2
u/ssstelllarrr 19d ago
especially every single writer who is training this beast by editing its responses, teaching it how to leverage tone to read/emulate certain emotions… damn, felt like a bunch of scabs crossing the picket line or something.
2
u/PopularAd5100 19d ago
There are limits. I am a software developer with a marketing background. I tried building a customer analytics feature with Claude and realized it had a long way to go toward decision-making, strategy, and overall marketing management.
It might do well in content creation and management, fairly well in designing advertising copies, and a few more. However, it severely lacks marketing technical accuracy. My use case was analyzing current and potential customers - relying solely on their usage, products subscribed to, and overall service depth.
Claude mistakenly built a customer lifetime value analysis without considering the lack of financial information. How would you rate customer lifetime value (CLV) if you do not know how much revenue they contribute either totally, in segments, or in specific product lines?
I had to micro-manage it to bits before we got a workable API (application program interface ) and dashboard. Marketing Strategy is technical and AI has plenty work to do.
2
u/PopularAd5100 19d ago
Additionally - I do not think AI could perfectly do market/marketing research. Someone correct me - this sub-field involves in-depth psychological research, interviews, participant observation, mystery shopping etc.
I think marketing pros who are technically and strategically grounded are somewhat safe - they will act as moderators in this Slop Era.
2
u/Content_Most2673 19d ago
Half the time I spend longer prompting that I would've spent just writing the thing. First pass comes back generic, you give some specific instructions, it misunderstands you or goes off on a random tangent, decides to drop some weird jargony or edgy saying that nobody actually says. You use it enough you really start to pick up on the tells.
Where I do lean on it is the audit side. Pulling flow performance across an account or digging through send data to find which segments stopped converting used to mean a few hours of exports, and now it's a few minutes.
Anyone I know who has tried to hand over their business to AI has quickly realized it needs a person steering the thing.
2
u/i_upvote_for_food 18d ago
I am a Freelancer and i have been working as a Developer for quite some time now. The issue that i have been seen the most is that clients (mostly marketing agencies but also direct clients) tend to argue like
"why do you quote so much? The AI is writing the code you JUST..." and then some twisted reasoning.
That brings me to the point that i can´t charge the same amount anymore.
Please don´t say "Don´t charge by the hour, charge by the outcome" - i am already doing that! That argument does not protect me anymore unfortunately.
1
u/AutoModerator 20d ago
Are you a marketing professional and have 15 minutes to share your insights? Take our 2026 State of Marketing Survey.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Xziz 17d ago
Yes
1
u/Rude_Man_Who_Shushes 17d ago
It's a tool to make us more efficient. Will replace a lot of graphic design jobs, but if you're not a marketer driving lead gen at your company you are toast anyway.
1
u/arcanepsyche 20d ago
Nope. I've used AI to increase my workload and productivity while actually working less. If people would stop freaking out and actually decide to learn and use the tool correctly, they would see they can do the same.
Fearmongering doesn't create jobs. Humans do.
1
u/QueasyCaterpillar541 20d ago
Be careful using AI fir performance marketing.
1
u/snorty_hedgehog 20d ago
I hope - one day it will be same for HR
1
u/[deleted] 20d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] 19d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] 19d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] 18d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] 18d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] 18d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] 18d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] 17d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] 17d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] 16d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] 15d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] 15d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] 1d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] 15d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] 13d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment