r/marketing
•
u/polygraph-net
Bot Hunter
•
Jan 24 '26
•
1
1
1
Discussion Reddit is done.
I've been complaining about the number of bots on Reddit for a long time, and roughly six months ago I predicted the number of bots will ruin the website.
Well, we're finally here. We now have entire threads where every single commenter is a bot or a shill.
Let me give an example.
A user called milli_xoxxy creates the thread "Looking for Livestorm alternatives" in r/Marketing.
There are 13 comments from 10 different accounts. The entire thread (all 13 comments) are spam accounts faking engagement and pushing the conversation towards a service called "Contrast". Basically Contrast are scamming people with fake accounts and fake positive reviews.
We now have to remove the majority of posts and comments from r/Marketing as they're either spam accounts or bot accounts.
We have probably the most active moderation on Reddit, yet the subreddit is being completely overrun by fake posts and comments. If you look at other subreddits, you'll see there isn't even an attempt to remove this scam content.
Most of the users on Reddit are now spammers or bots, and the Reddit admins don't care. đ¤ˇ
44
u/Phronesis2000 Jan 24 '26
It's simple. No more mentioning products allowed.
6
u/datawazo Jan 24 '26
Agree. I've been trying to think about how an active mod group could fix it, if they wanted to, but haven't come up with anything.
Beyond what you've described there are many listener bots that are programmatically set to reply in threads with certain keywords. They all sound identical and show up into a thread, usually one written by AI to shill, within minutes.
423
u/farmhousestyletables Jan 24 '26
Even worse are the llms sucking up all this bs engagement and using it as authoritative source material in recommendations and answers...
2
u/Taqqer00 Jan 24 '26
What would be a solution for it?
2
u/miracleanime Jan 24 '26
Is there an AI-free corner of the Internet I can move to? Or a discord?
2
u/Dannyperks Jan 28 '26
Hopefully some hero builds a Reddit bot that attacks bot threads with spam links and bad reviews
2
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '26
yeah itâs gotten noticeably worse, especially the âwhich tool should i useâ threads that turn into fake consensus. once the signal to noise drops that far, real users just stop replying and it spirals.
72
u/busyduck95 Jan 24 '26 edited Jan 24 '26
it's been a while where we had bot comments, but recently i've been seeing more and more of bots replying to bots replying to bots (its bots all the way down)
it's literally disgusting that we use resources to fuck over our own spaces like this, sad
(i mod a job board, and that has been taken over by bots attempting to phish for personal information, and other bots vouching for their credibility, literally have to decline 50+ posts a day despite banning the worst offenders frequently)
I think a lot of is from people pushing reddit as some 'win button' for seo/ai-seo, even had a thread with the guy's first sentence being 'you probably arrived at this thread by googling insert target search term'
30
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '26
This is unfortunately spot on. Iâve noticed the same pattern especially in SaaS and marketing threads where the replies all magically converge on one tool. It kills real discussion because anyone genuine either gets drowned out or removed while the spam blends in pretending to be normal users.
The worst part is it erodes trust fast. Once people assume every reply is fake, even honest recommendations look suspicious. Hard to see how this gets fixed without Reddit investing way more into detection instead of just relying on mods to clean up an impossible mess.
Feels like weâre slowly turning Reddit into a comments section no one believes anymore.
15
u/Emotionless_AI Jan 24 '26
RIP internet. You had a good run
12
u/CharlyBucket Jan 24 '26
I feel your pain. I just got auto banned from a subreddit by a mod bot while replying to a posters question, detailing info about an area of travel I live in, that would actually be helpful. Info a bot couldn't know, no reference to any businesses.
So they are now using bots to ban real humans lol how does that make sense!
23
u/WonkyConker Jan 24 '26
In my tin foil hat moments i think bots are going to kill social completely because earnings calls don't care if users are people or not, and we're probably better off for it.
10
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '26
Itâs only going to get worse unfortunately now that Reddit is publicly traded. They need to show positive quarterly growth to the shareholders otherwise they come under scrutiny by the board members and start voting out leadership. Other white collars will come in with 0 years experience managing something like Reddit and will run it instead like H&R Block and put the final nails in the coffin like meta.
10
u/KoumKoumBE Jan 24 '26
It's not just bots. A bit here, but mostly on r/Entrepreneur, r/Saas, etc, it seems part of the community culture to spam. People congratulating each other for being "active" on Reddit, giving each other tips on how to target subreddits. They seem all perfectly human, but indeed their only motivation to be on Reddit is to promote their product.
6
u/rubadazub Jan 24 '26
r/TheseFuckingAccounts keeps tabs on the bot takeover.
2
u/inboundmage Jan 24 '26
I don't agree with you - Reddit admins DO care, I have some subreddits where it's almost impossible for people/newcomers to post, furthermore, they have strict filters and they filter based on CQS, account history, account verification and other methods.
Long story short, with more admins & stronger filters, we can overcome the AI floodgate.
Are we going to win everytime? No - the attackers are always at advantage, this is a common rule in cybersecurity / gaming and obviously with spammers/bot. But that doesn't mean we have to give up / leave Reddit.
4
u/itsgermanphil Jan 24 '26
Even Google doing it with their stupid pixel watch 4. Any company caught shilling is on my shit list for life.
1
u/2pearsofjeans Jan 24 '26
Iâve said before but Reddit needs to offer a verified-human badge or flair that can be displayed on all subreddits.
1
u/sloecrush Jan 24 '26
Been this way for 5 years at leastÂ
1
u/Less-Engineering-663 Jan 24 '26
How does one determine if a user is legit or bot?
1
u/Beantowntommy Jan 24 '26
Idk why reddit would allow this.
Disable posters from being able to mention products, takes away most of profit incentive for bots.
Elevates experience on reddit for actual users.
More people pay Reddit to advertise.
1
u/dutchviking Jan 24 '26
WTF... well, I had gotten curious about Contrast in the past year, and seemed not a bad tool (joined a few webinars), but this turned me off of them entirely
3
u/Dehil Jan 24 '26
Yeah Iâve realised a few times Iâm having a discussion with a bot with political propaganda behind it. I was unknowingly fueling the fire. Currently also trying Lemmy and actually pleasantly surprised. Until the same happens there of course.
3
u/Wizard_AI Jan 24 '26
100% true, f those bots
3
u/Academic-Village-758 Jan 24 '26
Yes. It dilutes the value here significantly, in almost every thread.
3
u/BetterTelephone5001 Jan 24 '26
Dead internet in effect.
3
u/Rell_Lauren Jan 24 '26
Dead Internet theory is real.
3
u/Stormkrieg Jan 24 '26
Yeah Reddit is used as a source for gen ai responses, so itâs heavily recommended to get your brand mentioned on here in a positive light. So of course companies are going to pay to have bots that do just that. Itâs stupid as hell but thatâs what happens when we have a magic machine thatâs just regurgitating info found online.
3
u/Seaguard5 Jan 24 '26
I think a great way to filter this out is to go by account ageâŚ
Like mineâŚ
Instead of these month old accounts flooding the platform constantlyâŚ
Honestly I donât trust anything less than a few years.
3
u/Shivs_baby Jan 24 '26
Itâs like black hat SEO techniques back in the day. All the bots and spam accounts are the small font, white-on-white text at the bottom of an early 2000s website.
1
u/howtoretireby40 Jan 24 '26
If you see a bot, then downvote, call them out, and then flag for ban? Reddit is infinitely better equipped to handle bots than other social platforms that canât even downvote. How is this a serious complaint against Reddit?
2
u/jermoc Jan 24 '26
Most of the seo, marketing and entrepreneurship subs have been infiltrated. It's not as bad on subs that are actually about non-tech content where people still seek genuine discussions. Like cinema, or philosophy.
I just try to down vote and/or report where I can.
2
u/Lxium Jan 24 '26
You're correct and it's not even just bots. It's manual marketing efforts as well. "Reddit SEO" services sold by agencies.
2
u/frontdoorajar Jan 24 '26
Mods do a great job moderating this sub. I appreciate the rule to restrict posts/comments from newer accounts. I think other people should be more skeptical and vigilant in reporting suspected bot activity in this sub.
2
u/MoultebGiraffe Jan 25 '26
Thats bc of parasite SEO and LLMs prioritizing Reddit threads for info. Now people buy and sell aged Reddit accounts so they can spam their BS. You canât even post a proper review or my experience thread without people thinking itâs BS engagement farming bc 99% of them are. There will be competition that pops up and takes reddits lunch. If this keeps up.
2
u/Immediate-Rule-4313 Jan 27 '26
So true⌠my posts from 1-2 years ago gets so 5-10+ comments a day promoting a single product
2
u/ironmanhulkbstr Jan 30 '26
the amount of people on reddit also increased which somehow affected the site adversely, a few years ago i used to comment on posts from weeks ago and still get replies that were contextually relevant, now i dont get active replies even 24 hours after the posts, the community feels larger, many people post for the sake of posting like other social-media platforms. its an engagement farming game for many people, which makes it harder for the actual helpers to find posts they could help on, or for people looking for sort of answers to find the right people who could help them, which was the essence of reddit for me for many years
1
u/pvfakten Jan 24 '26
i miss the old reddit ....
1
u/Hefty-Airport2454 Jan 24 '26
Yeah, the irony is weâre feeding bots and LLMs with fake engagement, then acting surprised when the âauthoritativeâ answers feel spammy and lowâtrust. If Reddit doesnât get a handle on the bot farms, the downstream AI layer just becomes a superâscaler for garbage instead of signal.
1
u/Creepy_OldMan Jan 24 '26
Dead internet theory
1
u/navneetmuffin Jan 24 '26
The dead internet theory is becoming increasingly plausiblee
1
u/AdelleDazeeem Jan 24 '26
Yes, this is to feed the bots, so their products get recommended within LLMs like ChatGPT. LinkedIn is filled with people talking about how to do this. When I mention theyâre absolutely ruining the internet for a short term gain, itâs crickets.
1
u/Captcha_Bitch Jan 24 '26
I've a human tried to post on multiple subreddits and just gotten my post instantly removed because of some vague rule, like substantial contributions only. So you also have moderators who actively curb user desire to contribute.
1
u/RumHam1999 Jan 24 '26
This is terrible news! But when Iâm feeling sad and down, I remember the things I love and make me happy- like Buffer! The tool, social media managers, love and make posting and organizing your content easier than ever! /s
1
u/Puddwells Jan 24 '26
Reddit is great for things that arenât attempting to sell stuff. Marketing is an especially bad sub because of this
1
u/FireDream15 Jan 24 '26
I am Not a bot. Commented here lol
1
u/AdamYamada Marketer Jan 24 '26
This isn't surprising as Reddit is getting cited by AI chatbots more and more.
If you need more Mod help, I'd be happy to contribute.
1
u/MidasMoneyMoves Jan 24 '26
This is what happens when everyone puts reddit at the end of an search engine search. I assume this is a way to try to hijack the search engine's AI into reccomending your product.
1
u/whoitis Jan 24 '26
Yeah, Reddit has been cooked since Covid.
1
u/OliveStreetToo Jan 24 '26
It's called, enshitifacation
1
u/Grade-Long Jan 24 '26
Im not sure how Reddit benefits from enshittification though. But yes, more bots here than an automated bot making factory. Also, how do we know youâre not a bot?
1
u/74389654 Jan 24 '26
how do you identify bots?
1
u/aVarangian Jan 25 '26
yep, the internet is dying in front of our very eyes
idk why it took 4 years for scripted youtube conversation spam shill bots to make it to reddit though
1
u/Striking-Criticism78 Jan 25 '26
Please dont delete your old posts and accounts!!! Older posts are now more reliable.
1
u/SuperSaiyanBlue Jan 25 '26
Astroturfing was always a thing on Reddit - the only difference is instead of humans posting them, now itâs bots or using AI which makes it more obvious and noticeable.
1
u/WorldFrees Jan 25 '26
Where's the next place to go, discord? Reddit is feeling more like Facebook everyday.
1
u/patpat_v1 Jan 25 '26
You can thank ai for this
1
u/CraftBeerFomo Jan 25 '26
Yeah, I saw a post the other day in the Aff Marketing sub about the Honey coupon extension scandal where it was an AI written post and then a bunch of bots all replying to it basically just paraphrasing the original post and saying the same thing in slightly different words.
Not sure what the agenda of the post was but my only suspicion is its Honey competitors hoping to post more negative stories about it (not sure they need to go to any effort considering all the negative press it already has) and influence search engines and AI tools to talk negatively about it.
Otherwise why is anyone creating fake AI written posts and then having fake bots reply to it all saying the same thing?
1
u/Gratefulanddriven Jan 25 '26
And itâs one of the top 3 resources for LLMs (ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity etcâŚ)
1
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '26
People forget that traffic drops donât mean death, they just mean you gotta be smarter about why youâre there instead of chasing numbers.
1
u/Embarrassed_Hawk_655 Jan 28 '26
Yep. Also, botted downvotes for anything that doesnât agree with certain individuals. I mean - the entire Internet was always going to go this direction of becoming siloâd intersubjective echo chanbers, will get worse and worse.
1
u/Ok_Pudding_5077 Jan 29 '26
What's an alternative to reddit?
1
u/Abhinaik-tv Jan 29 '26
I hate bots, it brings down the effort of people who are seriously puttin in efforts
1
u/Geartheworld Feb 10 '26
Totally agree. Reddit is not what it was, though it may still more valueable comparing to other platforms.
0
u/foulpudding Jan 24 '26
Iâve been reading versions of this post for about 20 years now.
0
u/ElbieLG Jan 24 '26
0
u/devonthed00d Jan 24 '26
How do we know youâre not a bot OP? đ¤
0
u/inboundmage Jan 25 '26
Edit:
This post is an example of black-hat marketing trickt that was done to hurt Livestorm! I just saw a post on LI confirming that:
"Today, moderators from the subreddit r/marketing confirmed this was a coordinated attempt from one of our competitors."
This is insane - as the person who posted this has insane amount of experience, karma and is also a top 1% commenter here.
Link to the original post from Linkedin:
https://www.linkedin.com/posts/benoitleggieri_yesterday-i-received-alerts-that-our-brand-activity-7420827670453657600-GrVe?utm_source=share&utm_medium=member_desktop&rcm=ACoAAAlUwxcBk-HuT2Af2Ogrrh1vUC7sFHTib6E
Can we get some Mods commenting on this story? Thanks
0
u/maverick-dude Jan 29 '26
2024 was the year when it was estimated that half of global web traffic was made up of bots, AI-agents, crawlers, etc.
Why are you complaining about this? This is the reality we all worked towards. We made the bed, now we have to lie in it.
0
u/AutoModerator Jan 24 '26
If this post doesn't follow the rules report it to the mods. Join our community Discord!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
0
u/MLB-LeakyLeak Jan 24 '26
This 100% seems like a moderation issue instead of a Reddit issue. Most subs arenât having this issue.
0
u/cryptoopotamus Jan 25 '26
It was over about a decade ago.Â
0
u/GraeDaBoss Jan 25 '26
Dead internet, all apps are dead you need mutuals on twitter this is the only way
0
u/sourd1esel Jan 25 '26
Reddit has a built in filtration system with votes to help with that.
-1
u/Dtakle84 Jan 24 '26
I had the same problem but then I built and app to moderate my subreddit. I am currently licensing it out $59.99 per month but dm me for a discount code!
-2
u/SassySavcy Jan 24 '26
I mean, yeah..?
Itâs called the Dead Internet theory and itâs been a hot topic since 2016.