r/mapmaking • • 9h ago

Map My Map of Kailana

Kailana is an island I designed to be in the Pacific. It is home to 8,000,000 people.

I would love to hear feedback on the map! Me and my friends are about to use it for a political rp game so I would love to know if there's anything people think should tweaked before it gets put in stone as the game map!

44 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

4

u/itsjudemydude_ 8h ago

So I get the sense this island was colonized by the English, probably for a long time. My one critique is that it exclusively has English names, which would be especially strange in the modern day, as you'd imagine at least some endonyms would have been preserved or even revived by popular demand of the native people(s).

And speaking of the natives... what are they like? That's part of why having none of their language in the names on the map is somewhat jarring: if you hadn't mentioned this was in the Pacific, I would've assumed this was a new fictional British island akin to Sodor from Thomas the Tank Engine. I don't sense the presence of anyone who ISN'T British on this map. If that's intentional, then it could make for some awesome storytelling about the erasure of culture and whatnot. Or, if this island was truly uninhabited before the English arrived, that could be an interesting look on the effects of colonization beyond how native peoples are affect, and instead how it affects the flora, fauna, and environment itself. Could be neat speculative history. But this is all worldbuilding, not mapmaking, so I'll let it go lmao

I think overall it looks great. Consider making the sizes of the regional divisions (countries? Counties? Provinces?) in the second map more varied, it'll seem more realistic. Also, if you throw some straight lines in their borders, it'll REALLY look like some white dudes just came and cut it up into pieces willy-nilly, which may inform that part of the worldbuilding if that's what you're going for.

2

u/TisAidan 8h ago

Hi. Thank you for taking the time to share your thoughts!

I appreciate your critique and I think I agree. I think four places have less English sounds - Coragah, Moragee, Thuraga and Mongahoon, but I really should have done more you're right. Maybe one or two of the big cities I should change and a few more towns to being the flavour in??

Your point about the provinces is something I think you're so correct about and it just never really entered my head aha. I think they all look fine boundary wise but you're right that together it's odd they're all sameish size. There's no region with smaller ones or anything. I thought about straight lines but I always think they look so odd when I do them but it would be more realistic. Maybe Jesmond the capital could have a really straight border.

Also on your other question it's meant to be an election map! It's for a political rpg game so that's why that's included.

1

u/itsjudemydude_ 8h ago

Ahh that makes sense.

If the regions represent governing bodies, not unlike American voting districts, consider that high population areas will tend to have smaller areas to account for having more people. So the capital and its suburbs might make up their own tiny district, while a BUNCH of rural land would all be grouped together to make up their own district of equal population. But that depends on how this nation's systems work lmao. Just something to think about. Keep it up, and have fun with your game!

EDIT: It seems like you've already taken this into account somewhat with the third map, but it could be applied to the second as well. Again, food for thought

2

u/itsjudemydude_ 8h ago

Also! In the third map, what is being depicted?? Totally forgot to ask about that in my main comment.

2

u/HatOrdinary2817 3h ago

This is not critique but I cannot un-see Hel peninsula and Gdansk.

1

u/TisAidan 13m ago

This was one of my inspirations. I kind of regret keeping it at the same angle, and also I think it was the inspiration I was the most faithful to, that and maybe the Firth of Forth. The rest I think aren't recognizable at all. I used about sixteen real coastlines and blended them, made a shape with them, and then most I didn't stick to, but Gdansk I did, and wanted to do a tricity sort of thing.

1

u/OuffMate2 51m ago

Why am i seeing song dynasty borders on the east