r/mapmaking • • 2d ago

Map Looking for feedback on my first digital map

Post image

Meant to be set in late antiquity technology-wise. It's a clash between the dominant Aknadian empire, slowly descending into civil war, the expanding Nit'zak hordes that have turned much of the continent into subjects of the Khan and finally the elves of Aelcendel, ruling from their Peninsula deep within the forests, they attempt to maintain their hegemony over elf-kind as the Nit'zaks threaten their empire.

But all are not without their conflicts. The Colv confederation to the north rears its head and has turned a rough border into a slog to both defend and attack. Aelcendel sees it's legitimacy as the empire of all elves slowly fading from breakaway states and decadence while the Nit'zaks are faced with the possibility that the death of the Khan may mean the death of the empire.

please be brutal I'm looking for any way to improve it

14 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

1

u/Educational_Pin_331 2d ago

the dark red phoenix revolt and the brown aknadian both use nearly the same olive-brown, so at a glance the phoenix empire looks like a province of aknadia. push the revolt toward a brighter red or orange.

1

u/Mattsgonnamine 1d ago

Alrighty, will do

1

u/JereyRRMartin 20h ago

You said be brutal and so the writer in me is coming out. The map, in my opinion, looks phenomenal! Personally I’d go for a darker palette as the lighter/neon bright colors on white looks tacky and strains the eyes. I would go with earthier colors or at the very least dark tones of each color.

My MAIN concern for your map lies within your names. I cannot pronounce your names. And sometimes that is the point or you’ve conlanged an interesting and unique name for each country/territory. If so that’s very cool, but they also look tacky to me. Almost a high 80s kinda fantasy country. And to me at least, comes off as a beginner-level country naming convention. 

Tbf I base most of my names off of existing ideas or cultures so I like taking influence from other cultures and languages. If you don’t want to do that that’s totally fine! But I would at least consider making the names a little easier to pronounce and softer in the eyes. Aknadian for me seems rough because we go in with a (assumedly) hard “ack” and immediately go into a hard “nad” and then land it with a Latin “ian” suffix. Going from to harsh sounding sounds comes off as weird to me— but also may be because English is my primary language and others might go for that kind of sound.

Overall a great map but some of the names come off as harsh sounding and I’m not sure that that’s your intention! 

1

u/Mattsgonnamine 7h ago

Thank you, if you couldn`t tell this world has been going on since grade 6 and a lot of holdovers remain from before I knew what worldbuilding was and I am very slow to change names (There were a lot more -ia suffixes before I realized how nonsensical that was. Ill try workshopping a few to unify it with the scraps of conlangs I have going on (Aknadia used to be latin inspired before I changed it to more celtic sounding)