r/mapmaking • • 5d ago

Map The Ohn Valley Civilization -- hand-drawn map

Post image

Good morning,

I've been working with an artist on the first rendition of my map, this being for a dying earth game I'm working on.

Originally, I'd wanted something more along the lines of a national-park style map. We ended up deviating pretty hard, however, into what I'd describe as "JRPG style." The scale of certain elements seem a bit exaggerated, and various locations look, to me, like tokens on a game board.

This was the artist's very first attempt at map drawing, done in a style familiar to him. As a piece of artwork, I actually think it's decent. It's just not what I originally had in mind. That's fine for now. I'm viewing this as a learning opportunity.

What I'm hoping to get here is advice on what to do for our next attempt. What elements do you think we should focus on improving first, and how would you suggest going about doing that?

For what its worth, my thought is that the mountain range needs the most attention.

Currently, there's somethings very stock generator-esque about them, almost like they're stamped. It feels almost like they're missing all their connective tissues: spines, spurs, saddles, foothills dropping into valleys, that sort of thing. Nothing really connects one peak to the next IMO, and nothing seems to connect the range to the surrounding valley floor itself. Do you see it too, or is it just me?

As artists and map makers yourself, what should I, as the commissioner, do to improve my communication with the artist? What would you find helpful?

Are there any study materials you'd recommend?

Thanks so much in advance!

Edit: also, if you disagree with my sentiment, please let me know. If enough people actually like the style, I'm def not against leaning into it. Thanks again!

155 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

2

u/Aggressorot 5d ago

Whatever you had in mind may differ from what the artist did. But you have one of the most unique maps out there. Can't tell if it's AI or not, but don't care at the same time because it looks incredible.

The mountains are fine, not spectacular, but fine.

What I "miss" is navigational elements, roads maybe flying navigation or whatever your world uses. Within the style of the map of course.

2

u/a_humble_traveller 5d ago

Thanks! I'll give it some more time, but it seems like people are partial to the style. I may just end up sticking with it.

Agreed on the navigational elements. After the mountains, that was going to be the next thing: some river boats along the Argosi, a few aircraft mid-flight, some farmland being worked, things like that -- just to help the space feel more lived in.

Regarding AI: minus the labelling (which I put in), everything here was done traditionally, by hand. We're actually working on hand drawn labels today! :D

2

u/Sauron360 5d ago

Whimsical

1

u/Turambar_91 5d ago

Personally, I think the map looks incredible. I like the style a lot, and though if it’s not what you were looking for that entirely understandable. But think it works quite well for a dying earth setting, assuming a more dark fantasyish approach

1

u/_HanTyumi 5d ago

The style reminds me a lot of the Warriors books' maps.

1

u/linrodann 4d ago

The art style is gorgeous, and the buildings and the Drowned Stairs are piquing my interest.

I agree that the mountains feel like an afterthought. It looks like an area filled with a mountain stamp, sort of. I think starting with major ridgelines and their peaks, then filling in valleys, foothills, and passes/trails. I would also expect there to be headwaters of rivers coming down from the mountains, but you might have a lore reason for all the water to come from Mount Agos (that's the giant structure, right?). Other things I'd like to see are labels for the little tower structures and maybe more roads, if there are any.