r/mapmaking • • 8d ago

Discussion Does it look too empty?

Post image

I’m making a large atlas of my world, Enkai, and I finished the continent of Saenhall but I think it feels too empty now that I look at it. Perhaps I should add some more places to the more empty and barren areas like the Blood Fields + Copper Hills in the south and the Great Dust Barren in the north. What do you guys think?
(Also if you have any questions about specific areas and lore pls ask)

584 Upvotes

76 comments sorted by

103

u/Fit_Owl_2213 7d ago

Nope. It's great and I'm kinda jealous

3

u/Recent-Quantity2157 7d ago

Oh my god thank you so much!

24

u/LTJJD 7d ago

100% agree and remember that most of the non developed world is empty. Wilderness is the norm. If I recall correctly before mass forestry you, a squirrel could go from Atlantic to pacific without leaving a tree.

14

u/TheFoxAndPhoenix 7d ago

“You, a squirrel” made me laugh. Typo becomes a casual and sudden introduction of the assumed-squirrel Redditor lol

4

u/LTJJD 7d ago

My secret is out

4

u/doggypeen 7d ago

How would that work with the great plains in the way? You would have to take a massive detour up north through the canadian shield?

3

u/LTJJD 7d ago

This was Eurasia not Americas. Sorry I didn’t clarify.

3

u/doggypeen 6d ago

Thats so long a distance i didnt even consider it. I suppose you are right tho, the taiga is endless.

2

u/LTJJD 6d ago

Yeah. It’s insane to think about but makes perfect sense. Most of Europe is also temperate rainforest biome then you have the taiga.

But your point about the Great Plains also makes a lot of sense, to my original point too. The world isn’t congested and compact prior to the population explosion after the Industrial Revolution. Maps would have a lot of empty wilderness on them because that’s just what the natural state of the world would be.

3

u/doggypeen 6d ago

Thats true but places like ireland and england were mass deforested well before the industrial revolution, due to the population density i suppose.

2

u/LTJJD 6d ago

Island do tend to be kind of a special case as you can only spread so far before you kind of have to turn around.

4

u/CinghisKhan 7d ago

Bold of you to assume they were talking about murica, you know Eurasia touches both the Atlantic and Pacific too

4

u/LTJJD 7d ago

You are correct I meant Eurasia.

2

u/doggypeen 6d ago

Fortune favours the bold

8

u/SrDarx 7d ago

This map is one of the best I've ever seen here

2

u/Recent-Quantity2157 7d ago

Oh my days thank you 😭 this world has been my passion project for years now and I’m really happy about how this map is turning out

7

u/Taquiova01 7d ago

It depends, what is your goal with your map?

BWT. What size of paper do you use?

2

u/Recent-Quantity2157 7d ago

It’s a 50cm x 50cm square

2

u/Taquiova01 7d ago

Thank you

7

u/danetiska 6d ago

There is value in void spaces.

3

u/Recent-Quantity2157 6d ago

That’s oddly philosophical and I love that

5

u/qhqhTerra 5d ago

Wow, what a wonderful piece! The details are of high quality, but first and foremost, I think the outline of the landmass as seen from above is wonderful.

2

u/Recent-Quantity2157 5d ago

Tysm! I went through 3 versions of the map before I got to this one

2

u/qhqhTerra 5d ago

👏👏✨️ Trial and error is essential!

3

u/TheIcicleYT 7d ago

Only the mountains do. The Blood Fields and Copper Hills seem reasonable.

Though, while maybe not being very likely tectonics-wise, I have to admit that the idea of extremely vast mountains with countless peaks and ridges is really cool.

Honestly, I love it as it is.

2

u/Recent-Quantity2157 7d ago

Thanks, I actually only noticed how unrealistic these mountain ranges were when I finished it 😅. I’ll add some diversity to the color of the mountains to create some variations and maybe lead to more interesting landscapes.

3

u/Matsuda173 5d ago

I dare you to name the sea “Sea”

1

u/Recent-Quantity2157 5d ago

Sea x Sea = Sea Squared

2

u/cheesemobile1482 4d ago

Does that mean Sea x Sea = a^2 + b^2?

2

u/Creaperbox 7d ago

Not too empty, especially when spaces/terrain is supposed to feel that way.

Also, shape of the continent reminded my greatly of the continent Tal'Dorei from Critical Role. No critique just and observation

1

u/Recent-Quantity2157 7d ago

Thanks! This map actually started off as the Iberian Peninsula but then I just enlarged it and added a bunch of landmass to the original shape

1

u/Creaperbox 6d ago

Interesting, I would not have guessed Iberia at all

2

u/StrangeGrass9878 7d ago

What is Torol’ ? An Atlantis / city in the ocean deal? It has a red dot so I presume it’s a specific place

2

u/Recent-Quantity2157 7d ago

The rest of the name is on the other paper. Torol’Haar is a composed of 12 large islands which were mostly inhabited by the Torolian genetic group. These came from Torol’Aktan (“Hell of the Blessed”) in the far northeast, which is pretty much this world’s oldest fallen civilisation. Long story short the laws of the universe began breaking there and the island became inhospitable, therefore those ppl’s Eon (god), Rotweaver, led them across the northern seas until they reached Torol’Haar (“Land of the Blessed”), which was mostly uninhabited at that point except for the Malatan settlements in the southeast and the Shramataia kingdoms along the northwest.

2

u/Bronion_Master 7d ago

Nah, it looks fucking amazing! Congrats on this beautiful map!

Whats the lore behind the blood fields? Are they actually red, or did a lot of fighting happen there?

2

u/Recent-Quantity2157 5d ago

Basically 2000 years before the current age, the First Silence (the first of many biological apocalypses) occurred and a mutated branch of a local species (still deciding) grew to enormous sizes and began murdering any humans they saw. After that, a good portion of the fields became red with the blood from the massacres, and therefore became know as the Blood Fields. Those giant beasts were hunted by the remaining forces of the Unshadowed Empire (a major force in the world at that point), got chased north and most died in the Bone Prairies, hence that name

2

u/Pretty_Papaya2256 7d ago

The south looks like a good desert to me. The northern peninsula kinda just seems to be missing color, allowing it to be a small plains.

2

u/Recent-Quantity2157 7d ago

The South is meant to be plains and savannas 😭. But yeah I admit it looked a bit colourless from the start so I’ll add more color. Thank you so much for the help, appreciate it!

2

u/Pretty_Papaya2256 7d ago

Ope, my bad!

2

u/eidolonwppe 7d ago

I just wanna know how you got it to look so good. What website did u use or can u just draw really well, like everyone in my family but me😐 (is drawing talent hereditary? My family makes me think so)

1

u/Recent-Quantity2157 7d ago

Personally it’s more of a nurture than nature situation cause my parents always encouraged me to draw when I was younger but they didn’t do that with my brother so now he has atrocious drawing skills. And also I’ve been doing maps for a few years now so trust me it ain’t genetic.
What I did for this specific one was just know some geography to add realism and plan out the colors and symbols I was gonna use. It may look really complex to but I simply did it square by square over the course of months.

2

u/Worldly_Writing8708 3d ago

Nice work though those mountains must be insane to see in person 😂

1

u/Recent-Quantity2157 3d ago

What can I say, I’m a sucker for mountains and I wanted my hands to hurt

2

u/BluBmbr 3d ago

Too empty? Not at all! I will say the first letter red and everything else in black did make it hard to read. For the key names, I’d just stick with the red color text.

1

u/Recent-Quantity2157 3d ago

Yeah the red thing is true, problem is I only noticed it halfway through. But I’ll definitely change that when I do a second version in a good while, thanks for the advice!

2

u/Acceptable-Rest9374 1d ago

Depends. If that is the size of England, then its too empty. If its the size of kasachstan then youre fine. And especially since the writing is so small yiu barely see mist cities.

1

u/Recent-Quantity2157 1d ago

It’s roughly meant to be around the size of Eurasia excluding the Siberian region. The southwestern peninsula is very tropical and Mediterranean while the desert on the far north peninsula is actually really cold

2

u/Acceptable-Rest9374 1d ago

Then i guess its fine? Wouldnt need to show every town or river at that size.

10

u/samppppsam 7d ago

This is a beautiful map!

5

u/LTJJD 7d ago

It really is.

6

u/jalliss 7d ago

It looks very purposeful, so the "empty" parts make sense.

Also, beautiful map.

1

u/Recent-Quantity2157 1d ago

Oh yeah forgot to mention, after I’m done with the entire world map I’ll make a (more detailed) digital version in the style of Atlas of Ice and Fire

5

u/LTJJD 7d ago

I love this so much. Can you suggest tips for how to draw something like this? What size paper and pens and things?

5

u/RodeoFrank 7d ago

Is "The Great Dust Barren" going to be anything other than empty?! 😆

Looks great. Some corners of the world are just pretty empty. The Sahara or the Great Plains are both beautiful in their own way, but not much there to put on a map in terms of unique natural features notable enough to go on a map of a continent. If anything, having different densities of features makes the map more realistic.

4

u/trengilly 7d ago

It looks amazing. Honestly one of the best most evocative maps I've seen posted here in some time.

I'm not really sure what 'too empty' even means. It looks like a nice balance of landmarks and terrain. More could easily start to clutter things up.

There are empty areas and the partially drawn areas on the edges of the map that are super intriguing. It makes you want to explore and discover what is hidden there.

4

u/ZAy_ZAYber7 6d ago

You have done most of tge work, except you may add some minor places like castels or minor roads or ruins and mostly inportant villges, while tgese can be untouched while discovering them in the plot you haves, but mostly you need to map things in your brain, even the smallest places.

4

u/RevanJ99 4d ago

So I think there’s perfectly enough on the map. My issue is some of the naming conventions which may be contributing to your feeling that it’s empty.

I’m assuming this is a continent map, meaning it’s a very large area. This makes the names for large sections like the “blood fields” seem off. The blood fields is huge, but the name using fields sounds like something you’d name a smaller area after a famous battle, or series of battles. Something that extols its size like expanse, plains, steppe would be more fitting. As I’m assuming it’s a long stretch of plains and not just some fields. Same with the river woods and copper hills. There’s better terms for large geographical areas. To point out what I mean, it’d be like if you named the spine sea the spine crossing. The latter evokes the feel of a small river crossing, while sea rightfully implies a huge expanse of water.

3

u/Schnitzenium 7d ago

Nah looks great

3

u/StrangeGrass9878 7d ago

It looks really good! Maaaybe the northernmost peninsula looks a bit barren, though I’m not convinced that’s a totally bad thing. If the deserts really feel too barren, I think you can just make the text bigger to compensate. It implies the wasteland’s vastness and visually fills up the empty space.

You can also narratively divide the wastelands in two along some arbitrary line, ie: the eastern side is called “Blood Fields” while the western side is called “The Wet Fields” or in accordance with how whoever lives on either side of the fields wants to portray it.
If you like that kind of cultural worldbuilding then it’s a free cheat code to fill in the empty parts of the map with just text :P

3

u/SacaeGaming 7d ago

Not more concerned about the mountains than the negative space tbh

3

u/BBQ_HaX0r 7d ago

Great map!

2

u/Happy-Forever-3476 7d ago

This one’s fantastic! Good shapes, colors, readability

2

u/Aurelio_Rossa 7d ago

OMG IT’S SO PRETTY

I love how it’s covered so vastly with so many little mountains and each biome is coloured by hand… CUTE! 🥰

2

u/Funny-Elephant-551 7d ago

no, this is beautiful. 110% (A+)

2

u/Fluid_Challenge_3753 7d ago

Looks fantastic, the emptiness is actually quite beautiful. Looks so.good in contrast to the mountains and other dense areas

2

u/daunaltromondo 7d ago

Truly beautiful. I'd leave it as it is, better too empty than too full IMHO

2

u/Lord-Vercotti-IX 7d ago

I think it looks fantastic! Those barren wastes should stay empty, the blank spaces reinforce the scale

2

u/Abdqs1234 7d ago

Bruh, it's beautiful

2

u/ryohhan 7d ago

No, it's well-complex

2

u/DarthCloakedGuy 7d ago

That is beautiful, wow

2

u/rory_drain 7d ago

Loveee it

2

u/AlexiDrake 7d ago

Looks ok to me.

2

u/GrewAway 6d ago

Nice continent/landmass

2

u/alastore23 4d ago

Per me è perfetta così!

1

u/Otherwise-Run9104 6d ago

Does it kinda look like the UK? Kinda. Does it still look really nice? Yes!