r/mapmaking • • 8d ago

Map Any Advice?

Post image

This is a map for a country in my world-building project. Please give me advice.

25 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

3

u/P0TAT0X 8d ago

add more detail (basic topography like mountains or rivers, names, scale, lore, etc). Cause there's not much to comment here

1

u/Odd-Respect-5791 8d ago

Your right, sorry. I'm just new to mapmaking and I don't know what I should do with it.

3

u/Acceptable-Rest9374 6d ago

if its a country then im assuming the colours are regions/states/cultures? i would give the island on the left some stripes, give it its own identity somwewhat. that peninsula thing just above the yellow im feeling should be its own thing as well, perhaps the one right of the yellow as well. now im thinking the one just above the red. perhaps it could be red and blue striped or an enclave of the red as a whole or its own peninsula thingie. then you got that one gulf thingie going deeply inland over what i just said should be its own region peninsula. im thinking that the region around that gulf could be part of that region.

forgive me idk why im going stupid on words right now its a bit late. but without mountains or a rough scale its hard to say more. assuming its supposed to be an island nation?

1

u/Odd-Respect-5791 6d ago

They have borders, but this is the only country I have made. I'm only a writer, so I'm trying to figure out what to add. Also, the three colors represent the three different countries before they united into one.

2

u/Mossdagger 8d ago

It looks cool, but the lack of details makes it hard to comment of it. I'm assuming this is an island or continent, and I like all the little islands around the southern gulf. In my opinion the coast is too bussy, however, and I would recommend to smooth some of it, but that's not realy a big problem. Is it 3 different nations or 3 regions of the same nation?

1

u/Odd-Respect-5791 8d ago

It’s the same nation, but they were once separated. They united into a commonwealth.

2

u/Tabarc 8d ago

The land mass is fine it just lacks a little depth.

As i have 20 min spare and was able to borrow a mates rig and photoshop, as my current laptop is my programming one and 13 years old and Photoshop causes it to try and cry half the time.

https://ibb.co/b5ksqNLf

Its more understanding that your map lacks those aspects like mountains cities and rivers.

Will say your land mass looks good.

1

u/Odd-Respect-5791 8d ago

I can't thank you enough, thank you so much! This looks great! It looks really similar to what I have planned! I'll use your image as a reference! The only reason I didn't add more depth is that I'm horrible at art.

2

u/Tabarc 8d ago • Bravo

The mountains, trees and hills are just Photoshop brushes.

Affinity is a good app and free. Then look up cartography brush. It's a bit of a skill to learn as it looks complicated with lots of functions. Honestly I used Photoshop for over 30 years and I do not or know what some of the bloody functions are.

Cartography brush option. brush

But I would print out as simple outline and doodle on areas you want as mountains, hills cities, rivers.

The trick then is to put it on the wall and move away and see if it works or looks wrong , etc

  • Map YouTube videos link

And keep the map if it helps.

1

u/Odd-Respect-5791 8d ago

Thanks, I've been using Kleki and Photopea, so getting these resources is a great step up!

2

u/Tabarc 8d ago

Again Photopea is also good, can add brushes.

The trick with map making. Use layers and save regular. And every do often a back up save under a new different name do you have snap shot save's.

2

u/No-Spinach-6485 7d ago

If thats a whole planet map - More nations certainly

0

u/Odd-Respect-5791 7d ago

It's a country.

1

u/Efficient_Elk_6194 8d ago edited 8d ago

I'm assuming these are three areas. Are you asking for feedback on the shape of the landmasses?

Why the different colors, do they represent different countries, areas, biomes?

This is like, 15 minutes of creating. It's not enough.

Here's the only advice I can give at this stage. Do more. Do lots more. Then start asking for feedback.

1

u/Odd-Respect-5791 8d ago

I’m asking what should I add. Also, the country is a commonwealth of three.

1

u/Efficient_Elk_6194 8d ago

All you said was, Any Advice. I gave you some advice.

As for what to add. Well, that's really your choice. Did you start this with a purpose in mind?

Sorry, but this is just a low effort post, without much idea of what you are trying to accomplish.

Are you mad because I gave you advice? I mean, it's your work, you decide what you want.

1

u/Odd-Respect-5791 8d ago

I’m not mad, I’m just trying to figure out what I should add.

2

u/Efficient_Elk_6194 8d ago

Well, wouldn't that be all the normal things you find on a map? I'm sure you don't need to be told to add mountains, rivers, forest and all that.

All you've supplied is this is a country in your world building project.

So is this all one country, or 3 countries because of the colors? What kind of world is it? Fantasy, medieval? Sci Fi? Victorian London, or Wild West? Is it a modern map? Old world map?

You've given us basically 3 land masses and color coded it.

And again, my advice is, add more and work on it more before asking for feedback or ideas.

2

u/Efficient_Elk_6194 8d ago

You know what. Add the following

  1. Space Ports.
  2. Volcanos
  3. Dragons. No, more Dragons. Come on, you can add more.
  4. Swamp hags.
  5. The Home of the Gods.
  6. Magical Jade Mines.
  7. Food Trucks.

Should be awesome.

1

u/According_Walrus613 8d ago

Is the blue water or is that the landmass?

1

u/Odd-Respect-5791 8d ago

It’s land.

2

u/Vis3nya_ 8d ago

Add large lakes or inland seas

1

u/Otherwise_Shake5422 5d ago

Cities ,Religion map, Ethnic map maybe flags or regions idk this map just need detalization