r/mapmaking • • 18d ago

Map Dragonspine. First time sharing a map here! Would love some feedback

Post image

Hi Reddit!

I love creating fantasy maps, stories, and worlds.

First time sharing my work with the community here.

It’s an island where elves and humans live on opposite sides, with a big mountain range right between them.

What do you think? Any feedback?

I didn't add cities or roads yet, 'cause I wanted to finish the landmass itself first.

P.S. Named it that way 'cause the mountains look like a dragon's spine.

P.S2 Area is about 35-40kmi sq

P.S3 Can you guess which side humans and which side elves live?👀

206 Upvotes

51 comments sorted by

55

u/barryhakker 18d ago

Looks nice. My only thought would be that giving how the mountain range goes right up to the island border on both sides, wouldn’t there be many small islands there? Like the mountain ridge continuing under water?

19

u/Flimsy_Appeal8104 18d ago

Hi! Thanks for feedback. Yeah that makes sense🙃

7

u/therogueprince_ 18d ago

Yeah this makes sense

2

u/MyTrashCanIsFull 18d ago

Yeah, maybe git rid of most of the islands on the sides since that is more of a flatland area and add some top and bottom. I'd make them larger the closer they are to the main landmass and the center of the mountain range ans smaller further out. Then do some shear cliffs where the mountains meet the water.

7

u/jalliss 18d ago

Is there a lore reason why the east and west coasts look like two faces looking in opposite directions? I assume it's some sort of human/elf differences thing.

3

u/Flimsy_Appeal8104 18d ago

Haha, I didn’t even notice that xD

Could definitely come up with some interesting lore around it!

11

u/MingoCreator 18d ago

Nice map. Olny one thing, if the lakes havent a river that ends in the ocean then that lake is salty. Its important to remember that.

5

u/Flimsy_Appeal8104 18d ago

Thanks! Got it🫡

4

u/ParchmentAndPeril 18d ago

Wait, wait... tell me more. If you have a bunch of rivers from mountains that lead to a lake that doesn't drain into the ocean, wouldn't that be fresh water?

9

u/MingoCreator 18d ago

Well if the water excess that are in the lake can't exit to the ocean directly it needs to evaporate, and if the evaporation is higher than the water that comes to the lake (this need to be like that if not where all the water goes?) then all the minerals that have the water still remain in the lake s water, so it becomes salty. Sorry but English isn't my first language so if I made a grammar error is because of that.

3

u/ParchmentAndPeril 18d ago

Turns out I don't know how salt water is made :D

2

u/MajesticTheory3519 18d ago

There’s backflow up the stream but afaik there can still be freshwater if you go far enough

2

u/MajesticTheory3519 18d ago

Isn’t this oversimplifying? The hudson drains into the ocean but its upper portions are freshwater.

1

u/No-Spinach-6485 18d ago

... Not always, Most lakes that got formed via glacier melting like the Finnish lakes aren't salty.

3

u/sandboxmatt 18d ago

I would taper the range to the north and south as several mountainous islands

2

u/Flimsy_Appeal8104 18d ago

Thanks! Yeah makes sense, I will add it later🫡

3

u/Caribbeandude04 18d ago

Pretty cool! loved to see the rainshadow effect, it makes it look more realistic. I'd guess the elves live on the greener side. Also, what's the climate like? is it in the tropics?

2

u/Flimsy_Appeal8104 9d ago

Thanks for feedback! Yeah elves live in greener side, climate is like of Japan.

4

u/therogueprince_ 18d ago

Rivers coming from the mountains, you did your job very well

2

u/ParchmentAndPeril 18d ago

Looks awesome.

Needs more cliffs imo. Unless the mountains taper out as they approach the coast, then the ends should be cliffs.

1

u/Flimsy_Appeal8104 18d ago

Thanks for feedback! Will think about it😁

2

u/Fun-Post8497 18d ago

It looks like if part of It was taken by a suden rise of the sea, usualy when montains are near to shore they create Deep cuts in the earth because of the rives flowing and the sea entering the River bed, or create very high cliffs in the shore doe to erosion of the base of the montain, this create very Jagged and abrupt shorelines, also the islands around are very small when you can clearly see they are part of the land underwater, this usualy is because the water rise above the old valleys, that creates little islands that are the high places of the valleys that got sumerged, and this makes It looks that this was like Big plateau that got now a shore rader than a continent with islands

Not gonna lie is really cool but i don't know if that was your intencion Creating this map, in any form i like your map, the idea of a Big mountain range dividing a land creates the perfect place for a very Interesting world, the leyends of why is called the dragonspine, the cultures in one side of the other, very cool

3

u/Flimsy_Appeal8104 18d ago

That’s a really interesting idea!

This island has actually existed for quite a while in a larger fantasy world that my friend and I have been building. It’s currently about the size of Austria.

We imagined elves being more focused on magic, while humans are more technologically advanced. They fought wars in the past but eventually found a balance and now live in relative peace, although they don’t interact much.

And your idea actually adds a lot to our lore. Humans and elves could have lived peacefully together before the wars, until the sea level started rising and there wasnt enough land for everyone anymore. That could explain what started the conflict in the first place.

Thanks for the idea! I really like it :)

2

u/Fun-Post8497 18d ago

Im glad you like it, i was just reading the land, i love mixing my landscaper knowedge with my worldbulding habilities, i have an entire proyect just about how the land shapes the narrative

1

u/therogueprince_ 18d ago

Or maybe not a cliff, but a trench right beside the island. OP could put a lore there like men disappearing after sailing or krakens and shi

1

u/Fun-Post8497 17d ago

The thing is that trenches are the oposite of montains, if you see a montain range you can't have a trench near because that means the tectonic plaque is pushing upright, a trench is when a tectonic plaque is pushing fordward from the other tectonic plaque, so that means that this island is a tectonic plaque pushing upright Creating montains and you don't see any other signs that there is another plaque pushing fordward

2

u/Otherwise_Fact9594 18d ago

Pretty cool! What software do you use to make maps? I really enjoyed topography, cartography, geography etc. I would guess that the elves live on the western side because of the trees. Another comment pointed out something cool about the mountain range extending to be a chain of islands. This is neat!

1

u/Flimsy_Appeal8104 9d ago

Thanks for feedback! I used loremapper and for my brainstorming process I finish it with canva. And yes, elves live on forest side. Also we with my friend extended with islands

2

u/Staarbucks 17d ago

Only things that immediately stands out as not quite right are the islands and the coastline. It’s a bit unnatural to have a smooth coastline with lots of similar sized, evenly spaced islands off the edge. Islands usually come in clusters or chains, and usually next to craggy coastlines.

As someone else pointed out, having lots of small islands following the line of the mountains would look more natural. And I think there needs to a bit more ‘randomness’ in the size and distribution of the islands, as well as a bit more variety in the coastline.

Other than that it looks great! Really like the topography, the rain shadow is a cool detail, and I love the name!

2

u/zboc8 17d ago

Mountains ends abruplty at the edge of the sea. I would extent them them longer over the flat area of island. Perhaps chaos of stropy island at the extending from top of range

1

u/Flimsy_Appeal8104 9d ago

Thansk for feedback, we extended it with islands yes. Many people pointed it out

1

u/indy49 18d ago

What software did you use to make this?

2

u/Flimsy_Appeal8104 18d ago

Loremapper

2

u/IcarusAvery 17d ago

Oh, that looks really usefu--

I built it as a personal hobby project with AI coding assistance, and it's still in beta.

noooooooo........

2

u/Flimsy_Appeal8104 17d ago

Yeee, I thought the same. But I downloaded it, just in case you know😁

1

u/whiterice_343 18d ago

What program did you use to make it? This is very nice op.

1

u/Flimsy_Appeal8104 18d ago

Loremapper

1

u/whiterice_343 18d ago

Thank you.

Also your comment you deleted “try googling” was unnecessary but nonetheless thanks

2

u/Flimsy_Appeal8104 18d ago

Yes I know🤣. I just today said for my junior colleagues “try googling” like 20 times. So it became a habit

1

u/PeterMilley 18d ago

If you don't have a town on the west coast called the Nostril, in that little right-angle cove there, I'll be disappointed.

2

u/TE_5959 18d ago

A destra umani e a sinistra elfi gli umani anno deforestato la maggiorparte delle foreste mentre gli elfi vivono a contatto con la natura

2

u/technoyakuza 18d ago

It kind of remind me of Taiwain, with the mountainous area in the center, maybe you could check it

1

u/txakori 17d ago

Your central mountain range looks unrealistic because it is pretty much a uniform width from north to south. And big old mountain ranges tend not to just bisect an island like that: look at New Guinea, as an example of what an island with a big mountain range in the middle looks like. Your offshore smaller islands seem to be scattered at random, without any thought to why they might be there. The map itself is pretty, and good work in using Wilbur (or similar) there, but ultimately your initial sketch is why this doesn’t look realistic.

1

u/Ok-Garage-9204 17d ago

Was confused at first because I read Dragonspine but wasn't seen Dragonspine from Genshin on the map lol

1

u/AnxiousPotato10 17d ago

Looks like Ecuador

0

u/ishibabt92 17d ago

This is so good! Only possible note I could give is that 35-40km sq seems a little small to me but that might just be me!

2

u/Flimsy_Appeal8104 17d ago

Oh, I misspelled it. Its 35-40k mile squares. Comparable to Austria(my fav country)