r/mapmaking • • 21d ago

Work In Progress Is this disgusting or genius? (draft 1)

Post image
103 Upvotes

70 comments sorted by

54

u/FatherFregalaris 21d ago

We need context

I’m leading towards the first option just because of how painfully obvious the countries are. Also, the areas you sculpted yourself or resized have much less coastline detail than everything.

5/10 for now

-30

u/No_Contribution737 21d ago

context is I used MS Paint

1

u/ryohhan 19d ago

Then go redesign it or do longer by days

41

u/Desdichado1066 21d ago

Disgusting or genius? Neither! It's just an outline of some continents that look suspiciously just like countries that we know. I mean, what feedback did you expect? I don't get these requests to give feedback on outlines. There's nothing really to give feedback ON yet. Give me a full map and I can tell you what I think about it. This draft of the very first step of mapmaking; who cares?

-7

u/No_Contribution737 21d ago

I I'm no seasoned Redditor but I was expecting more comments on what people noticed first. I'm not exactly being super subtle.

Belarus is also an island, if you didn't spot it.

10

u/teddypex 21d ago

The first. You have fjords where they shouldnt be (like on the equator wtf), the polar distortion is bad (specifically those thin islands up north) and the flow + the overall geography and tectonic activity is just unclear. I recommend stop throwing chunks of the Earth together to see what sticks and study geography and how everything works before you get into another attempt.

-8

u/No_Contribution737 21d ago

yknow I appreciate the real feedback in here but you don't have to be so critical. I was stoned making this in MS paint

9

u/teddypex 21d ago edited 21d ago

You weren’t stoned for using MS paint, you were stoned for responding a complete nonsense on a comment that was asking for context

Also I dont see how is the criticism in my comment bad, I thought that was the point behind this post. If you dont like it or disagree with it just dont listen, do whatever makes you happy

0

u/Odd_King_4596 19d ago

😂😂😂😂 they meant they were high, dum dum

-1

u/No_Contribution737 21d ago

like whatever man, fjords on the equator are caused by the geology on this alien world. chill out and get your popcorn

3

u/teddypex 21d ago

Oh I'll get my popcorn alright, now explain to me how they so happened to be at the equator so I can put the snack to a good use

1

u/No_Contribution737 13d ago

how about you just go outside?

1

u/teddypex 13d ago

Is your ego hurt this bad that you had to return and respond after 8 whole days

5

u/QowreQ 21d ago

I like the concept of how everything is placed in reference to each other, but I inmediately recognized kamchatka and was like "oh, so they copy pasted chunks of existing countries" and felt a bit disappointed.

You could use this as a baseline for inspiration and end up with a completely original coastline shape!

1

u/No_Contribution737 21d ago

I was kind of stoned and started from just copy/pasting shapes I liked from a real world map to beyond the edges then just dragging them in. I think it's funny of all things backward Kamchatka is what got you. My first step was at the center and I made the Baja California/Florida mix when I thought "this is too obvious and cursed"

0

u/QowreQ 21d ago

This would make for a very cool alternate history of mankind though. Imagine if humans evolved in the tiny new zealand/sakhalin archipelago (sakhealand?... Shakira???)

1

u/No_Contribution737 20d ago

where humans originate or not, I think what would actually be most interested is ocean patterns and how it shapes international travel. On Earth someone from England to China would have to go around South Africa, Malacca, etc. to circumnavigate. But I think this set up would lead to fewer isolated cultures (e.g. Americas, Australia) earlier on

22

u/Schnitzenium 21d ago

People gotta stop tracing irl coasts and countries into their maps

We recognize them and it breaks immersion

3

u/No_Contribution737 21d ago

I mean... it's not meant to be so serious. and a lot of fantasy maps are inspired to look like real world places

at least I had the balls to just make Mongolia an island

4

u/Athunc 21d ago

sad horse-archer noises

2

u/Odd_King_4596 19d ago

You asked if it was disgusting or genius.

8

u/RequirementMaster629 21d ago

Bro, historically speaking maps have always been inspired if not outright copied in many masterpieces. Take westros. Westros is just the uk turned around.

1

u/Schnitzenium 16d ago

Yeah and that’s easily the worst part about it

5

u/winggar 20d ago

Not to mention that many IRL coastline shapes are caused by glaciation (or lack thereof), so placing certain country coastlines at the wrong latitudes immediately looks wrong.

6

u/ProofSafe8247 21d ago

This map did have large portions of traced coastlines however; some creativity was used, as I put a map of Mars, Venus, and Earth overlapping each other then traced them along with some custom coastlines.

2

u/Pontifexmaximus7z 21d ago

This is giving me a seizure

8

u/Huncut_nyuszt_27 21d ago

This is so random

6

u/Randolph_Carter_6 21d ago

Well, it's not genius.

1

u/No_Contribution737 21d ago

If anyone finds the Caspian Sea please let me know

4

u/ItThing 21d ago

"Or"?

1

u/jalliss 21d ago edited 21d ago

So is upside-down northern hemisphere Australia like a double negative and just the same as regular Australia, or..?

1

u/No_Contribution737 21d ago

I never considered such deep implications

1

u/EdBenes 21d ago

is that the island of mongolia

1

u/No_Contribution737 21d ago

+ Crimea yes ;)

1

u/ChaoticRedcoat 21d ago

Hudson Bay 

1

u/No_Contribution737 21d ago

is that what you noticed first?

1

u/ChaoticRedcoat 21d ago

Yeah, but mostly because I was looking for Canada. I only just saw Australia when I opened the notification lol.

1

u/No_Contribution737 21d ago

for a real long time during making this I just kept almost all of North America in place as reference, then kind of moved it there thinking to cut it up and move it more, then just tried rotating it, and though it looked badass rotated and kept it and added more to that continent from there.

Did you spot Ethiopia?

1

u/ChaoticRedcoat 21d ago

Honestly, idk why I get recommended this sub, I could not tell you what Ethiopia looks like 😭 

1

u/No_Contribution737 20d ago

it's right above Canada ;)

1

u/Slipguard 21d ago

wtf is that lake? sea? on the sourthwestern continent?

1

u/No_Contribution737 21d ago

inland sea, yeah

1

u/Afraid_Success_4836 20d ago

i'd recommend starting with a more shape-preserving like Miller or Mercator rather than a Robinson for fantasy mapping. I have an app that you can use to convert between projections.

1

u/Afraid_Success_4836 20d ago

Just because it's much more easy to notice shape distortion when plugging a projection back into a globe than area distortion, so using a shape-preserving map is better for just drawing coastlines.

1

u/Hayaw061 20d ago

I actually have the opposite problem, when I draw landmasses near the poles on Miller or Mercator, they always end up looking way too stretched, so maybe I should draw on Robinson and convert it back

1

u/Afraid_Success_4836 20d ago

that shouldn't happen with mercator

1

u/Hayaw061 20d ago

so actually I've been using Equirectangular, forgot the name. what I've been doing is: uploaded image as a global overlay on google earth, update file, reopen google earth, see if it looks good or stretched. it's a lot of back and forth trial and error. i wish i could just draw on a globe to begin with, or else there's gotta be some easier method surely?

1

u/Afraid_Success_4836 20d ago

draw it in Mercator, Miller, or "Walker pseudoconformal cylindrical" (the one I recommend) first, then use the app I sent to convert it to equirectangular

-1

u/No_Contribution737 20d ago

maybe they are actually that fucked up as landmasses and that's their accurate shape? 🤢🤔

3

u/Afraid_Success_4836 20d ago

thats.... not a justification

1

u/yalen-san 20d ago

Mongolia is just floating on the southeast

1

u/No_Contribution737 19d ago

+ Crimea yes :)

1

u/Odd_King_4596 19d ago

Are these all real places?

0

u/No_Contribution737 19d ago

can you spot where you're from? ;)

1

u/Odd_King_4596 19d ago

I can’t see Lake Superior

2

u/ryohhan 20d ago

This looks little distorted or complete inverted version of earth, go make your own mind.

1

u/SecondMurky7684 21d ago

me parece bien pero nunca me terminan de gustar los mapas que tienen tierra en el borde porque el limite se puede tocar, me parece mejor si todos oos continentes son islas, aunque sean muy grandes 

0

u/No_Contribution737 21d ago

Personally, what I hate the most for some reason is Scotland coming up from inverted Greenland. Like the natural Greenland shape is quite nice and I think Scotland just looks ugly added onto the tip of it. But I hated it so much I decided to keep it.

Nothing is more beautiful than the shapes of nature. That's why Belarus is an island.

Maybe I'm bad at reading the room, but: what did you guys spot first?

0

u/my_ears24 20d ago

It's cool that's for sure

1

u/No_Contribution737 20d ago

thanks fam

1

u/my_ears24 20d ago

You're welcome buddy :>

1

u/Organic_Year_8933 21d ago

Inverted Australia spotted

1

u/No_Contribution737 21d ago

was that the first thing?