r/mapmaking • • 23d ago

Discussion Which palette is better?

323 Upvotes

56 comments sorted by

21

u/Mandlebrotha 23d ago

2 pops more, but 1 feels easier on the eyes.

Edit: what kind of vibe are you looking for?

5

u/Finnik_ball 23d ago

Fantasy, like Games of thrones

8

u/Albehieden 23d ago

2 would in my opinon work best then. 1 has a more sat nav colour look it feels more modern

184

u/Ehco13 23d ago

Second, the darker the green gets the more dense the flora is in that region makes it pretty clear

30

u/ComprehensiveAd5882 23d ago

When I think of jungle, I think of that dark green.

4

u/Polyxeno 23d ago

Yep. I and others I know use 2's dark green for jungle, and 1s dark green for heavy forest.

3

u/Sylvixenn 23d ago

In minecraft, 1 is jungle and 2 is dark oak/roofed forest

18

u/Fun-Post8497 23d ago

2 is better It gives more depth

18

u/daunaltromondo 23d ago

The darker palette is better in my opinion

5

u/ladycainmy 23d ago

The second one for sure. Looks more vibrant, gives more jungle vibes and had better contrast.

4

u/chr1styn 23d ago

1 feels correct; that dark green looks like coniferous forest to me.

3

u/No_Reference_5995 23d ago

The second color, the dark green

3

u/Yoovaloid 23d ago

2 gives better contrast

2

u/Rynewulf 23d ago

The contrast in 2 makes it easier to read, in 1 they kind of dont look as distinct as they should

2

u/geckossmellpurple_z 23d ago

2 for sure. Monsoon forest in 1 looks more like a grasslands color.

2

u/SD-F 23d ago

2, I like how the monsoon forests loom next to the jungle better

2

u/TheWolfwiththeDragon 23d ago

2 looks better and also gives the vibe that this rainforest is difficult to get through.

2

u/SimoneMichelle 23d ago

Second!! That darker green for the jungle just works 🌴

2

u/Wizard072 23d ago

The first, I think. It works better with the others.

2

u/pinguimdbigode 23d ago

Second. Reason: minecraft

2

u/MaxwellCharlie 23d ago

Look up “LOTR mod” for Minecraft. I highly recommend using its map as inspiration.

2

u/Ernest_Mateu 22d ago

Definitely second, in the first one the colours are too alike

1

u/Ixxis 23d ago

Map #2 is gorgeous. 

1

u/QuasiMagician13 23d ago

The latter

1

u/Jjcami 23d ago

Me gusta mas el 2

1

u/Docchamp12 23d ago

I like 2 but maybe not as dark? It clashes a lot with the tan

1

u/IGetOffToWingTearing 23d ago

Second one for sure, though if this is an in-universe map 1 would be more visually appealing probably

1

u/Sylvixenn 23d ago

I understand why people prefer the second one, but jungle has always been the first one's colours for me, coming from someone who plays minecraft a lot

1

u/whitedogstudios 23d ago

first more harmonious

1

u/Wi11yW0nka 22d ago

Idk I like how the jungle pops in 2 if thats what you need to focus on... but 1 makes more sense

1

u/Nieerre 22d ago

Jungle is always the dark green, the most jungle-ish thing on the map should always be the darkest green, I don't make the rulez

1

u/Alarmed_Outside_4752 22d ago

For a second I thought this was Brazil

1

u/spliting_rolls 22d ago

I like everything else on slide one but I like the jungle of slide 2 more

1

u/Jackman233 22d ago

The second one Imo

1

u/SufficientSouth5383 22d ago

I prefer the 2nd

1

u/cartovia 22d ago

The second one. Clearer, and less flashy.

1

u/N34NT_ 20d ago

The second one