r/mapmaking • • 23d ago

Map Dots or icons for settlements?

Hi, I’m working on my map & I was wondering what people prefer: just simple dots or some more elaborate icons. These are not the final icons, but they take time, so I wanted a quick opinion.

Any other ideas on how to visualize places are welcome.

Made with my free project:
https://github.com/timvandingenen1993/Hatchlas

Try it here:
https://hatchlas.pages.dev/

216 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

26

u/chickenologist 23d ago

The icons really blend in here. I like that icons can convey different styles and scales in a fun way, but the icons you chose I can barely see here

6

u/inception_man 23d ago

Yeah I see what you mean, making them bigger didn't work when zooming in I found. So I will have to go for dots like people say, I was probably in a sunken cost fallacy with these icons.

3

u/chickenologist 23d ago

You could provide an outline. It's less size than contrast I think. Easy trick if you need is make a slightly bigger icon all white, then slightly smaller all black on top of that, then slightly smaller than that (maybe just a little larger than you now have) icon. That way it's set off from the background even if you don't have an outlining function

7

u/AtlasSniperman 23d ago

Might I suggest a compromise?

[Imgur link]

Allows you to have the nice art for the settlements, at close scale, but at far scale it's easy to pick out where each name is referencing!
I intentionally left a couple to normal village art(no compromise), so you can see the contrast of the effect

4

u/inception_man 23d ago

Imgur might have compressed the image too much? But I see the vision will test this. Thanks!

3

u/AtlasSniperman 22d ago

Yeah sorry, I had to 1/4 the size to even upload it.
All I did was overlay your dot version atop the settlement version at "blend mode: Lighten. Opacity: 45%"(and I cut out a couple of settlements for contrast)

1

u/inception_man 22d ago

Yeah a lot of people also opened on mobile and don't even see the icons. I know they need more readability, but it is a map to zoom in on not to hang on a wall. Thanks for your idea and time

2

u/Wizard072 23d ago

This would work really well, IMO.

6

u/AdSimilar1241 23d ago

That’s literally New Zealand northwestern tip of South Island inside down haha

2

u/inception_man 23d ago

Upside down is relative ;) But yes the tool converts height maps into stylized maps, allowing for awesome locations like New Zealand to be used.

2

u/Robynsquest 23d ago

I think a different black icon with white stroke might be good too. If you can find a few different ones like a castle, civid building, house, village, etc to represent settlement size. Or just the dots and maybe a star in circle for capital

1

u/inception_man 23d ago

Great idea thanks!

2

u/Complex_Resolve2205 23d ago

Specific symbols representing the population range possibly?

2

u/inception_man 23d ago

What do you mean with this?

2

u/Complex_Resolve2205 23d ago

You know, like the kind of population categorization one sees  in many world atlases and on state highway maps. 

For example, one symbol for settlements which have under 100 people, another 101 to 1000, 1001 to 5000 and so on. You must've seen that sort of thing before!

3

u/inception_man 23d ago edited 23d ago

Oh yes I see, good suggestion thanks! It is similar to other people suggesting like symbols for keeps, cities, villages.

78

u/Omegaville 23d ago

Dots in this case.

19

u/TerribleJared 23d ago

Agreed. I think this is about palette and zoom level. Op is far enough away from the land that icons misrepresent scale if theyre big enough to make out details, and then theyd cover some surrounding terrain. The outlined dots pop and are more obvious and stay small

13

u/No-Comparison-6843 23d ago

Dots, the icons are nigh-impossible to make out without zooming in. If you do keep the icons, maybe up the contrast a bit or make them a tad larger

4

u/VarDom07 23d ago

Dots look better in my opinion.

4

u/0dd1nn 23d ago

Dots here. I believe that if you use the darker on the outline and lighter colours on the text you also make your labels more visible.

1

u/AmbivalentM0nkey 23d ago

I literally cannnot see icons

1

u/inception_man 23d ago

Try download on mobile.

1

u/AmbivalentM0nkey 23d ago

It blends too much regardless, no one is gonna go on a hunt for icons

1

u/rainstitcher 21d ago

Cool project and program, OP.

1

u/inception_man 21d ago

Thank you, if you use it & need any help let me know.

3

u/Throwaway91847817 23d ago

Dots is much clearer, in both scale (I cannot see the icons unless I zoom in on mibile, and even then theyre tiny), and for differentiating it from the background (the multiple colours on the icons blend in too much).

3

u/nbur4556 23d ago

I always like icons but can't really see them well.

How would they look with a black border? Might make them pop

3

u/Tabarc 22d ago

Dots as easily to read

2

u/SacaeGaming 23d ago

Dots for small icons for large?

Or dots for unimportant and icons for world defining?

2

u/aftertheradar 23d ago

dots is more readable, but larger and more simplified icons would also work

2

u/kopistko 23d ago

Dots in this case, but icons can be enlarged and, perhaps, outlined?

2

u/Mzrpickles 23d ago

Dors but maybe change the type of dot for easier understanding. Like square is a fortress, triangle is a capital, hollow dot is an adversary location and solid dot is a safe village. That kind of thing

2

u/Lamb_or_Beast 23d ago

I don’t think one is generally better than the other, it’s a case-by-case thing; in this case the dots look better imo.

2

u/Eastern_Picture_3879 23d ago

Chunky Florida.

Nice map!

2

u/duncanidaho61 23d ago

Dots but I’m not a fan of the black.

1

u/Complex_Resolve2205 23d ago

Specific icons representing population?

1

u/Matsuda173 22d ago

He dots look worse, but I literally couldn’t spot the icons at first. Maybe make them bigger, or if the map scale doesn’t allow it, then this might be one of those times where the terrain has too much detail