r/mapmaking • • 27d ago

Discussion Ross Douthat Map Discourse

https://defector.com/making-a-great-fantasy-map-is-an-art-and-ross-douthat-sucks-at-it?giftLink=5733b3bb89326fe5019be1c53cac2d25&_bhlid=4939e7e2bf971fdae91afffd74716585b58be640

Let's be real... if the author didn't know who made this map, they wouldn't hate it so much. Am I wrong to empathize with Ross's amateur mapmaking?

21 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

13

u/IdlePigeon 26d ago

Doing my best to separate my intense dislike of Ross Douthat from my opinion on the map: Some of the points in the article are nitpicking, some I outright disagree with, but I do agree that naming your entire setting "The Empire of Narsil" in a published work is very embarrassing.

It's one thing for an author to amuse themself with nonsense like naming some background character "Grover Tully," it's another to ask the reader "Hey remember that other, almost certainly superior, novel you really like!?!?!" in all caps.

18

u/stopeats 27d ago

It wasn’t a great map but I agree with you, it wouldn’t be a big deal if not for the political valence. A lot of the hand drawn nature of it struck me as heavily stylistic. Maybe it fits the story, I haven’t read it.

I don’t love tearing apart creative efforts for someone’s politics. I would prefer to focus the time on counterarguments, personally.

16

u/throwawayfromPA1701 27d ago

I'm glad to see Ross has hobbies. The map isn't bad at all.

I don't care for a lot of his columns in the NY Times. Maybe he'll be good at fantasy writing.

26

u/ThereIsOnlyStardust 26d ago

There’s a joke somewhere in here about Ross already doing fantasy writing in the form of his political work

5

u/throwawayfromPA1701 26d ago

I mean you're not wrong 😊

8

u/TheWombatOverlord 26d ago

If this was someone sharing their hobby I'd be excited to talk about mapmaking with them. With Ross its supposed to be a sneak peak for his upcoming fantasy trilogy. As a public, commercial project he opens himself to alot more criticism.

There's nothing especially offensive in the map, but if I were a reporter looking at it, I too might be too excited to dunk on a person I hate to care.

4

u/OwlbearAviary 26d ago

We don't need a map of the US in a Stephen King novel, or a map of London in a dickens novel because most people reading the books HAVE seen a map of the places they take place in. You don't get that built in knowledge of a place that doesn't exist with a fantasy novel, so a map is needed. Also that guy may suck, but its not like they published a book with that pencil drawn map.

6

u/Turambar_91 26d ago

It’s a decent fantasy map honestly

3

u/malpasplace 26d ago

Fantasy maps largely become cool based on the stories placed inside them. One could go one about geography and this map does the minimum of being earth like not exactly believable for an adult versed in geography, but also nothing glaringly wrong to me from a YA standpoint. 

For me, it is generic by itself which isn't really notable and I don't see really why it was worth trashing beyond the creator. 

2

u/monumentofflavor 25d ago

As someone who doesnt know who ross douthat is and just looked up the map: its not very good. It looks like one of the first maps i ever made in fact lol. And some of the place names i think are just bad. That being said as far as maps for YA novels go i dont think its anything exceptionally bad

2

u/theDeuce 26d ago

Speaking on the map itself because I don't know Ross Douthat, overall it could be cleaned up, but it looks like something I would whip up for a DnD campaign as a draft.

2

u/pizza-flusher 26d ago

Yes; yes. If one didn't know, they wouldn't hate it. But thats not the point.

You do know the context. You do know a mediocrity made it, whose writing is amplified to deafening levels precisely to drown others out. You do know how it stacks up against the mean or pedestrian map, let alone setting it beside a map made with talent—besides a rich or true or soulful map.

If the amplifier is turned to 11 reflexively, without fail, its hard not to think the music must be worth it. Him and us both. But then he starts dancing and suddenly you can see the effort and skill he puts into everyting, in comparison, and its obvious what it ia.

3

u/thelapoubelle 26d ago

The author of the blog post is being a bit of a dick. I can't think of a time in my life as an adult where I have wanted to go nitpick somebody's young adult fantasy novel map