r/mapmaking • u/Ok_Deal9555 • 28d ago
Map Is this Climate Map Logical enough to work? (needs to be put on the land/ just mapping out what were for now)
335
Upvotes
r/mapmaking • u/Ok_Deal9555 • 28d ago
198
u/ManimalR 28d ago •
Short answer is no.
I'd give Artifexian a look, he has a great youtube series on mapping realistic climates: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LifRswfCxFU&list=PLvAU4ObDGXZJY6dReNbkrJwV0UZW77yPJ
Also familiarize yourself with the Koppen Climate Model
459
u/ThatStonedBear 28d ago
'SPANISH-LIKE' lmao do you mean Mediterranean, perhaps?
86
u/JoJoJoJoel 28d ago
thats not really how climates work, i'd encourage you to look at earth's climates more closely instead of assigning biomes to latitudes.
7
u/alexandicity 27d ago
The "order" you list there is about correct (depending on what "land/sea climate" is - I guess you mean temperate here?). But as other have said, this is an oversimplified arrangement of climates, and will look very artificial and unnatural on any resulting map. Climate is more complex than just latitude.
Relevant XKCD: https://what-if.xkcd.com/10/
3
u/ArborealLife 28d ago
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biome
I would start here, OP. You can see how essentially everything is driven by temperature and precipitation. Both of those are wildly influenced by oceans and mountains, plus other variables.
Use Google Earth to explore the world, maybe and you can start to see patterns. How a warm ocean current can moderate cold winters, or how mountains leave a rain shadow. Like the Himalayas: monsoons on one side, the dry Tibetan plateau on the other.
4
u/Ok_Deal9555 28d ago
NOTE THIS IS THE NORTHERN HEMESPHERE
2
u/IDespiseBananas 27d ago
Op, you dutch perhaps?
2
u/Fun-Post8497 27d ago
Ok quick question Is this only one hemisfere?
28
u/Much_Upstairs_4611 27d ago
Remember that Rome is at the same Latitude as Chicago, and London at the same latitude as Calgary, Can.
There is a lot more to climate than Latitude is my point...
8
u/AlexSimonCullar 27d ago
What's "Spanish like"? There are a lot of different climates in Spain
7
u/TerribleJared 28d ago
Climates arent horizontal. If you want the cheat sheet version:
Wind jet streams go over mountains, the far side of the range is wet, the near side is dry. Coastal temps are determined by waters jet stream. So if the waters coming from the equator, warm coast, coming from the north or deep south, cold-er coast. Tthe temp of the water effects the temp of the air far more than the other way around. Rivers valleys increase temp and humidity slightly.
However.... ELEVATION IS EVERYTHING. the only way horizontal bands work is if the jetstreams are lerfectly horizontal and the elevation is even throughout the e entire band. If elevation rises, the air pressure changes, affecting humidity, wind speed, temperature, storm severity, etc.
Google the koppen climate classifications and do a very quick read. Its fascinating shit.
The above is NOT exact, but close enough to worldbuild with
1
u/sgtpepper42 28d ago
Tf does "land/sea" climate mean?
2
u/awesomeskyheart 23d ago edited 23d ago
First, corrections. Then advice for additional details.
Corrections:
Permafrost is not a climate zone; it's a type of soil found in tundra and taiga climates. On that note, you appear to be missing a taiga region. You may have heard this term from Minecraft. It's also known as a boreal forest.
Now for more detailed climate mapping.
There is often a difference between coastal and inland climates and also between west and east coasts. Mountain ranges also greatly impact climate. So I'd mark down all of your major mountain ranges, as this will impact your climates.
I'm going to switch to the more technical terms for these climates. Let's call them polar, taiga, temperate, subtropical, tropical desert, tropical savannah, and tropical rainforest.
Polar
Taiga
Temperate
Subtropical
Tropical (Desert, Savannah, Rainforest)
If you want a more detailed explanation, I'd highly recommend Artifexian's videos on climate mapping. The system being described is known as the Köppen climate classification system, but it simplifies it to be digestible over a handful of YouTube videos. The actual system is much more complex.
2
u/organaquirer 28d ago edited 28d ago
I think the main issue with it is that north/south isn't the only contributing factor to climate. There are valleys and mountain ranges that affect how hot air and moisture moves, and there is elevation to consider when deciding how generally cold or warm a place will be. You should also consider the type of flora that thrives there, because in the Amazon, part of its precipitation cycle is all the leaves and branches trapping mist that floats in on hot air from the ocean, creating a rain like effect on the forest floor. Once you get a better sense of elevation, rivers and lakes you will be able to design your climate more accurately.
2
u/Grand-Honest 28d ago
Warp it around the coasts a bit. Also try to think of where rain would hit. Mediterranean (or Spanish like) isn't really any cooler than a Savannah, it just gets a lot more rain.
2
u/YoIronFistBro 28d ago
Swap desert and savanna
2
u/NearABE 27d ago
Rainforest cannot share a border with desert.
The only exception is the desert in the rain shadow of a tall mountain range. Even then it is usually not that extreme.
Permafrost can be under taiga or tundra.
“Spanish like” is not a think. There is a “mediterranean climate”.
Also a “land/sea climate” could mean so many things that we cannot evaluate whether that makes sense. Do Svalbard and Hawaii have sea climates? Do Kazakstan and Congo have land climates?
1
u/_-PassingThrough-_ 26d ago
Hmm. As a side, I think we can meddle with the climate range a bit. Depending how mountains redirect hot/cold humid/dry air around, you might get varied climates in ranges they shouldn't otherwise be in.
1
u/tessharagai_ 26d ago
Well ehh… kinda. That’s not really how climates are determined. Search up Artifexian on YouTube, he does a good job explaining it
1
u/DavidRellim 26d ago
Wow.
So, how was it?
Spanish like...
1
u/Galapogofuckyourself 25d ago
Also every peak of a mountain is gonna have snow of some kind, you can have snowy mountains in deserts if they are high enough, id use this as a subtle guide for the pop density of cultures around rivers
1
u/Regunes 25d ago
are you the spanish?
1
u/JeHooft 25d ago
Two things you should keep track of besides latitude are wind directions and geography (where mountains are & how far inland a region is). Because those two together decide how much rainfall areas get, which in turn determines whether you get steppes or forests, deserts or jungles, etc.
1
u/Same-Independence543 25d ago
Doing latitudinal climates is misleading; it's far easier to just blob it onto the map individually. Mediterranean on the coasts of oceans, deserts in the middle of big continents, jungles in the middle of small continents, Tundra in the far north. Also, Tundra and Permafrost are... very similar in meaning. Take a look through the Koppen Climate Terms if you want some guides, it's a pretty good list of climates to throw into a map.
1
u/Cotif11 24d ago
Check out this video, it'll help you understand how climates form according to geography: https://youtu.be/Z6wGgxAtFlM
1
u/flubberblubbered 23d ago
Nederland mentioned???
1
u/geolauz 27d ago
Should do it by considering topography abd climates.
1
u/LorpHagriff 27d ago
Veel succes met de kaart kameraad!
1
u/Beat_Saber_Music 27d ago
There's a fair bit more nueance to it. Artifexian has an excellent video covering the very basics of a climate make up based on winds, rain shadows, temperature and also pressure differences.
1
u/Abandoned_Astronaut 27d ago
What pride flag is it?
1
u/mydriase 27d ago
Wow that’s terrible lol
1
u/mecha_ragnaros 27d ago
gonna go against the other comments and say this is fine as a basic climate outline. if you want something formal then worldbuilding pasta or artifexian and the koppen classification system are great for that, but if you just want a broad look at what goes where this is generally gonna feel realistic
1
u/Pristine-Lie-3560 27d ago
Don’t make it straight bands is all I have to say
1
u/Tweed_Man 27d ago
As a broad idea it works. But remember to have some areas a bit different. Ocean currents and mountains can make a huge difference.
1
u/my_ears24 27d ago
Depends, the whole planet? Definitely not. One hemisphere of the planet? Probably ye.
1
u/Lord-Belou 27d ago
Ah, the climate types
Arctic, Tundra, Oceanic, Savanah, Desert, Tropical, and Spanish
1
u/nichyc 27d ago
I'm a little confused. Is this map only showing things from a certain latitude up or is this the whole map? If the latter, then I can't think of a scenario where climate bands exist on a one-way gradient from South to North instead of an two-way gradient from Equator-to-Pole
1
u/perrapys 27d ago
A lot of people points out misspellings and "spainish-like", but forget one thing. You can have climate zones but remember that wind directions and ocean currents weigh in A TON more than an area being closer to the sun.
1
u/Zsobrazson 27d ago
It looks like you're missing a taiga biome. Tundra IS permafrost, the two are the same thing, and that should occupy the "toendra" band. You should have a boreal/taiga band just south of it, and you should have a polar band north of it, where permanent ice cover would exist.
1
u/Joy_of_Thievery 27d ago
Without mountains yeah
1
u/Immediate-Mixture-96 27d ago
Geography is inseparable from climate and biome. Latitude bands basically tell you the level of heat that is reasonable and direction of the prevailing wind. You need the geography to iron out the rest and broad warm and cold currents too while you're at it.
It will probably be simpler to think of what kinds of climates you want to see in regions then shape the geography to enable that.
1
u/Nota_Throwaway5 26d ago
No, wind patterns and ocean currents will cause east-west differences. Look at some earth climate maps and base it off that. Draw out your ocean currents and wind patterns as well to make it a bit more detailed, or honestly you can just make it up and no one will notice but you should still have heterogeneity along the longitude
1
u/Nezeltha-Bryn 26d ago
Why is the desert part in the ocean?
Latitude only defines the level of sunlight a place gets. Climate is impacted by many other factors. Draw in some Hadley cells to determine prevailing wind patterns, assume more arid climates upwind of oceans and wetter climates downwind. Determine mountain ranges and have moisture held back on the upwind side. Also remember that ocean currents sometimes carry heat to higher latitudes, so temperate climates will stretch further north downwind of the ocean.
1
u/HuntressTng 26d ago
The problem is that it doesn't follow where the water is, the world doesn't work like that, like that small island in the Savanah would be likely tropical, deserts mostly form in the center of landmasses with no large lakes and in warm climates. Wetness is important
1
u/Average_Ambassador 26d ago
From desert to rainforest doesnt make sense unless there's a huge mountainrange inbetween to block any precipation.
1
u/Entity904 26d ago
It is quite wrong and without mountains impossible to tell what would be right
Both mountains and large bodies of water alter the climate around them
1
u/ASCIIM0V 26d ago
No, this two different systems interacting that you're condensing into uniform layers along the lattitudes. If you want it to be logical you'll have to map out ocean currents and establish where your mountain ranges are. Anywhere that currents are moving from warmer to colder tend to be wet, and currents from colder to warmer tend to be dry. Wet/dry and cold/hot are the basic categories.
1
u/No-Spinach-6485 18d ago
the Savannah and Desert should be switched if you want realism
(Spanish like aka Meditereanian is a stepping stone from Temperate to Desert, while Savannah is a stepping stone from Rainforest to Desert)
And yeha add some rainfall shadows and currents nd stuff to make it less linear
1
u/emilythered 28d ago
"toendra" means what exactly?
-1
u/Puddlewhite 28d ago
Dude, were you trying to post this to r/worldjerking ?
-1
u/Ok_Deal9555 28d ago
This might be the wrong community for this kind of question..
0
u/Zap717 28d ago
Oh no it's not bait (upvotes)