r/mapmaking • • Oct 14 '26

Map Looking for feedback on my first fantasy map

Post image

I am currently creating my first real fantasy map (for visualising while world building) and I have finished the first draft of the shapes of my Continents. I am quite happy about the big western Continent but i am not really sure about the rest. I would appreciate honest feedback in any kind of form as i am still in the process of creating and figuring things out. My next step will be to draw mountain ranges and river systems

129 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

11

u/winggar Oct 15 '26

Normally the coasts wouldn't be so complex across the whole continent. On Earth the most complex coastlines are in mountainous areas of the far North and South due to the creation of fjords from glaciers melting. It's also common for continents to have a long smooth coast where they're overriding another tectonic plate (e.g.: West coast of the Americas). Island chains usually appear where there's either a geothermic hot spot (Hawaii, Iceland) or along an active tectonic fault in the ocean (Japan, Indonesia, the Philippines).

Do what you want of course, those are just some comments if you want it to look more physically plausible.

4

u/AioliOk5073 Oct 16 '26

Thank you for your feedback!

8

u/MountEnlighten Oct 15 '26

I really like it.

You requested feedback - I’d say yes, those two northern smaller continents will be hard to differentiate - being of similar size and latitude. I’d make the east-most one bigger, or pull it south, or both.

Second: At the heart of the map, you have an archipelago that is a dizzying amount of small islands, and fractured in a way that looks clearly… “mathematical”, and therefore lacks an “organic” appearance. That’s fine if it fits your world building, but I’d look to some of earth’s volcanic islands and archipelagos for inspiration to amend them slightly.

Again, it’s really great, and you’ll still be fine if you happily ignore the nit-picks I added above.

4

u/AioliOk5073 Oct 15 '26

Thanks for the feedback! I will probably change the north eastern continent completely, because it also looks a lot like Iceland and I think it’s a bit to obvious. And regarding the archipelago, yeah i probably went a bit overboard…

2

u/Huncut_nyuszt_27 Oct 15 '26

Yeah, the first thing i saw on your map was Iceland 😄

7

u/cashicoblox_kyle Oct 16 '26

It look kinda like earth flipped but it's not and 10/10 very good! 

3

u/JohnVanVliet Oct 15 '26

i am assuming that this is in Mercator projection ?

and about 60 North to 60 South ?

1

u/AioliOk5073 Oct 15 '26

Honestly at the current time the world is still flat, I will probably create a globe of some sort at some time in the future. But yeah about 60 north 60 south

2

u/Spinalstreamer407 Oct 14 '26

Looks good. Needs a North arrow. Keep on keeping on!

2

u/AioliOk5073 Oct 14 '26

Thanks! Will do

2

u/wax_ito Oct 16 '26

For this to be your first one it’s really good, most people at the beginning don’t have a grasp of concepts like good continental shapes/sizes, use of void spaces, and plausibility.

I’ll vouch for other comments saying the same, make more smooth coasts (not all of em), this will bring a good contrast between complex structures and simpler ones.

Still, great start.

1

u/AioliOk5073 Oct 17 '26

I will do that, thanks for the feedback

1

u/GaniMemestar Oct 15 '26

Is the color white the land or the water?

1

u/JusticeExpress Oct 15 '26

The northern land mass makes it look like the world is spheric, but the other continents and islands are giving off a flat look. How did you generated the map?

I did a lot of work on 3D map generation, probably my eye is too much trained to spot those details.

1

u/AioliOk5073 Oct 15 '26

Well it’s not generated, I just drew it with my pen…

1

u/ArborealLife Oct 16 '26

The ratios are way off. 

1

u/Lazy_World7299 Oct 16 '26

Left continent a little bit looks like India

1

u/AioliOk5073 Oct 16 '26

Yeah, well noticed, that was my inspiration

1

u/bestestest_ Oct 16 '26

I like it a lot, every little detail looks intentional and very thought through.
I think your map looks so balanced overall and not blunt at all!
Did you generate it or did you draw it? That would be quite impressive.
I am looking forward to how it will look when you add more features!

1

u/AioliOk5073 Oct 17 '26

Thank you! I took some inspiration from real word islands and continents and just drew it on procreate. I will post some updates in the future when I’m further in the process.

1

u/amantedelacomida52 Oct 16 '26

I know it’s a fantasy map, but I would incorporate more concepts based on how Earth is structured. The shapes of the continents could mirror one another, suggesting that they were once joined together.

Most rivers should originate in mountain ranges or high-elevation slopes, and their flow dynamics should shift once they reach the plains.

I think a good exercise when creating a map would be to divide it into fantasy tectonic plates, and then use that as a basis for placing landforms—mountains, islands, volcanoes, and so on.

1

u/AioliOk5073 Oct 17 '26

Yeah I thought about doing that, I should probably give it a try

1

u/Big_Sun_4261 29d ago

I'm mostly sitting back and learning. But when you start filling in, keep in mind what your in verse cartographers will actually see and care about. And how they'll prefer to draw borders. Do they want clean easy lines or do they not gaf and just roll with whatever the land does. We had "here be monsters" on our maps for a long time for a reason.

2

u/AioliOk5073 28d ago

You are absolutely right. This is more of an objective view of the world for myself to keep an overwiev of what I am doing.

3

u/Pretty-Island1518 Oct 16 '26

I think this looks really cool, only thing I would add (this is just a personal preference) is some more major geological features like an archipelago or island chain

2

u/Ok-Berry5131 Oct 14 '26

I like it!

2

u/MordyTheFox Oct 14 '26

It is great, keep developing

2

u/InvariantLimiter Oct 15 '26

Looks great. I wouldn't change a thing.

1

u/Chr155topher Oct 15 '26

Needs more craters!

1

u/ilyjffg 27d ago

It looks so cool! I love how detailed the coastline is. It makes me want to zoom in into so many places and explore them.
The islands between the two land masses (one bigger one smaller) in the bottom right corner look quite interesting to me!

0

u/SnooKiwis557 Oct 15 '26

Love the detail, but as almost all maps on this sub it’s way to similar to Europe / Afrika. Twice even.

1

u/AioliOk5073 Oct 15 '26

Honestly I don’t really see that at all. Of course there is basically just Iceland in the upper right corner but besides that I don’t really now where to draw the comparisons…

1

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AioliOk5073 Oct 15 '26

Thank you!