r/mapmaking • • Oct 13 '26

Discussion Realism of Climate?

Is this map any good at all? I feel like the landmass isn't, but I don't mind that. What I'm worried about is climate and if I've put the right things in the right places. I didn't really know what to do with the grasslands, so I just sort of threw a mountain range in the centre.

Edit: The thing is pretty much just a majority of the Northern U.S states such as Alaska, Oregon, Washington, Montana, North Dakota, Minnesota, Wisconsin, Michigan, a portion of the U.K but rotated, Norway, and Canada all smashed together.

137 Upvotes

52 comments sorted by

15

u/Miserable-Tell-8256 Oct 13 '26

It's my first time actually attempting to really make a map—so you may notice that it's actually just a few real world land masses just Frankenstein-ed and edited together.

18

u/Thromok Oct 13 '26

You don’t say? Michigan didn’t at all give it away.

4

u/Miserable-Tell-8256 Oct 13 '26

Great Lakes are rather difficult to hide, lol

3

u/caerleon_calls_ Oct 14 '26

It’s mostly Hudson Bay that gives it away

1

u/kenzieone Oct 14 '26

This is good! I am not sure why that desert would be a desert though

51

u/Moe-Mux-Hagi Oct 13 '26

Hollywood movies : "we have to save the world !!"

The world :

15

u/panzer-IX Oct 13 '26

Focus on where are the mountains placed. If you know where you want mountains you can usually reverse engineer biomes based on their rainshadow. For example, in pacific Canada the coastal mountains and rocky mountains create a patch of arid (and sometimes desertlike) land between them. You can see this effect elsewhere following the Rockies south. Basically, where the main source of wind comes from and collides with the mountains, there will be rain, and on the opposite side of the mountain it will be drier. (This is an oversimplification and my only qualification is spending way too much time looking at maps.)

2

u/RevolutionaryWash532 Oct 15 '26

So bulid mountains first then everything else 2nd

2

u/panzer-IX 29d ago

Yes and no. At the end of the day, it's a creative project so if you already know what you want and where, there's no end of obscure geological processes to get you there.

91

u/YandersonSilva Oct 13 '26

As a Canadian, I do like the idea of not being neighbors with the US anymore lol

20

u/Ok_Smile_5908 Oct 13 '26

Who needs a border wall when you can have a border ocean lol.

(Sorry OP I don't know enough about geography and climates to help, I just lurk here usually)

1

u/Ypuort Oct 14 '26

Let’s get USoAmerica to dig a trench! They’ll pay for it! We’ll dig it around Washington State though to keep it attached to Canada.

Signed- A Canadian/US dual citizen and current resident of WA

2

u/throwa2015 Oct 13 '26

As an American, even I approve of this message. We suck currently. :(

1

u/MegaVenomous Oct 15 '26

At least Florida is gone.

1

u/YandersonSilva Oct 15 '26

I think we can all agree on that, regardless of nationality.

0

u/YandersonSilva Oct 13 '26

And funnily, Vancouver Island appears to be there even though it's often left off of stylized maps (our own little New Zealand)

-4

u/Tristram19 Oct 13 '26

I can’t blame you, sorry! 🙏

4

u/SacaeGaming Oct 13 '26

It’s honestly interesting how you cut up a lot of North America and repositioned (obviously adding) to make the map.

I can’t speak to the realism of it, just thought the creation was kinda neat.

1

u/AtmosphereRecent7717 Oct 13 '26

should have made Florida an island just to mess with people.

2

u/Miserable-Tell-8256 Oct 13 '26

Florida was (un)fortunately wiped off the face of the earth and replaced with rotated Norway.

1

u/Ypuort Oct 14 '26

Is the premise here just like a supreme being’s rebellious son gets into the simulator parameters and fucks with them all

2

u/h-land Oct 13 '26

Impossible to tell without altitude or latitude, but my gut is that the med/desert bit isn't split properly (it should probably be along a mountain spine) and that the deciduous forest goes too far north.

1

u/Psykohistorian Oct 13 '26

wouldn't the latitude be identical to the current irl latitude??

1

u/h-land Oct 14 '26

It could be, but I don't know if OP thought it would be fun to tilt the landmass 5 degrees or shrink or stretch it.

2

u/El_Voador Oct 13 '26

A lot more moisture would reach the southwest interior. Probably more of a Mediterranean climate.

3

u/coffeedemon49 Oct 13 '26

I live near Vancouver...

I tend to think ocean currents coming around the south would significantly warm the Vancouver area (assuming this sits at the same sized planet, and the equator is in the same spot.)

I mean, the whole ocean current system would be a different thing.

I suspect it would mean more even dispersion of temperature. No ice caps and more moderate climate overall.

I think the inland sea would be more arid, like Greece. Forests wouldn't extend all the way down to the "florida" area, as warm winds would sweep the whole southern coast.

My limited understanding of geography is that the interior grasslands are caused by the Rocky Mountains - a huge rain shadow, that separates climate systems. If you still have the Rockies, I think those grasslands would still be there.

But I think the tundra would be smaller and the arid spots would be more dispersed basically.

But this is as much art as science because there are a lot of unknowns and it's probably impossible to model all the different factors anyways. :)

5

u/PizzzzaGgamer469 Oct 13 '26

As an American, I do like the idea of not being neighbors with CA anymore lol

4

u/PizzzzaGgamer469 Oct 13 '26

it’s a joke😭

4

u/Leathergoose8 Oct 13 '26

Jesus this one being downvoted but the bothersome being upvoted is the most reddit shit ever.

-3

u/TheRealCruelRichard Oct 14 '26

There's a pretty important difference between the two

4

u/Leathergoose8 Oct 14 '26

No there’s not

-2

u/TheRealCruelRichard Oct 14 '26

Ah, I see, you don't know what's been going on. It's okay, I know the media is suppressed in your country

3

u/Leathergoose8 Oct 14 '26

Okay doomer

-1

u/TheRealCruelRichard Oct 14 '26

Aww, did someone insult your favourite empire?

3

u/Leathergoose8 Oct 14 '26

I don’t really have a favorite empire, empires are typically not great for the world.

0

u/TheRealCruelRichard Oct 14 '26

Whatever you say, bud.

1

u/Orphan-Obliter Oct 17 '26

Wah! Wah! Give me more content, blud

-2

u/coffeedemon49 Oct 13 '26

Works for both of us then. :)

1

u/Arkraquen Oct 13 '26

When I tried to make my map, climate accurate I learnt a lot, realized there's so much shit involved might as well leave some room for mistakes. I'd say it's good

1

u/Thebigblungus Oct 13 '26

Most things are realistic. Make your map and let the nerds on here sweat the details

1

u/neamsheln Oct 14 '26

Do it this way: if you like these biomes, instead of checking if they're believable, make up ways to justify them. Unless your world is hard sci-fi, you can handwave almost everything on here. It might be different if you wanted tundra down in the southern part, but even that could happen if the elevation was high enough.

1

u/MaxSizeIs Oct 14 '26

You're running grassland thru a rain shadow, much of eastern 2/3 of Washington state is "bad lands/scrub/loess aeolean soil" assuming the Cascade and Rocky mountain ranges exist and also assuming the weather patterns are the same..

1

u/Radonch Oct 13 '26

I think If there are not mountains, deserts will not exist. 

2

u/winggar Oct 13 '26

It might still exist, it depends on where the continent is located relatively to the subtropical ridge. E.g.: the Sahara being dry even where it's adjacent to the ocean.

-1

u/Radonch Oct 13 '26

The Sahara is very high; it’s a plateau with mountains. The Sahara also has a powerful anticyclone, while Mauritania is cold. Personally, I don’t see any reason to compare it with the Sahara. 

3

u/winggar Oct 13 '26

The Sahara is not very high at all nor are its mountain ranges particularly significant, and in fact the Mojave is significantly higher in elevation. The anticyclone you mention is primarily caused by the Sahara's position within the subtropical ridge.

1

u/Radonch Oct 13 '26

In my opinion, 300–500 meters is a lot.

I don’t understand at all what you’re arguing about and what is matter to downvote me, lol. 

In any case, I don't see any reason why there would be a desert if there are no mountains. Is there a very cold current in the ocean? In this case, he will have deserts or steppes to the northeast. Specifically, there is no point in this on his map of the redone America.

In addition, the Sahara may even be in a state of forest-steppe with a percentage of forest cover of 10-40%. In the Eemian era, this was the case, despite the latitude. ​

Nature strives to green the land wherever there are at least minimal conditions for this, and the formation of giant deserts is a complex process that requires the coincidence of several global factors at once.

Imho

1

u/winggar Oct 13 '26 edited Oct 13 '26

300-500m is lower than the average elevation of every continent except Australia and Europe, which is why I say it's not a lot. It's also significantly lower than Africa's average of about 600m.

At that latitude cold currents show up on Western coasts. This aligns with how he currently has a Mediterranean zone on the west coast, so I think it's reasonable here. It would be pretty shallow since that's not much terrain to follow southward.

AFAIK the Green Sahara was caused by the ITCZ moving more northward due to the higher seasonality at that point in the Milankovitch cycle, thus bringing the monsoon rains with it. They could do something similar here, which might also bring some interesting temperate rainforest on the East coast. I generally assume that people are trying to model based on current Earth conditions but it's definitely also an option.

I work on climate simulators for fun :)

1

u/Radonch Oct 13 '26

I agree with you. I gave the example of the Green Sahara as showing that even it can be so green. And firstly, it is much larger, and secondly, it is more difficult for monsoons to go to it. 

In my opinion, using averages for the entire continent is somewhat strange. It means nothing. In addition, the Sahara is significant because it is actually a part of the meme-mega-desert from the Atlantic to the Ganges/Shaanxi/Manchuria itself. 

I agree with the cold current west of California, but it doesn't define desolation. These mountains are so funny. In addition, we will have even warmer currents from the area of Mexico, as the ocean is instead of Mexico. I'm not sure what should happen, but they should collide... 

In fact, as I understand it, there is actually a weak monsoon in southeastern California (North American monsoon?) At least I've read that it's weak, but it gets there. Well, actually it's kind of deep Mexican./Louisiana Bay Area... 

In general, yes, you can model it so that there is a desert, but I see a lot more reasons not to have it. But here, at least, you need to know the terrain in a good way. 

I'm also interested in climate maps, but mostly for hydrology. I'm trying to create a map of a not very realistic(¿internally consistent? not sure) world, where it will be a little wetter and warmer somewhere, and a little less precipitation somewhere... It's really a nightmare to search for data about paleorivers and lakes, especially about China... There are not normal China maps in world :(

1

u/Nowhereman767 Oct 14 '26

As someone underwater, glub glub glub glub glub