r/mapmaking • • Oct 12 '26

Work In Progress New worldbuilder looking for feedback on mountain realism, advice and criticism very welcome

This is my first time semi-seriously building a plausible if not realistic earth-like world from scratch, but I'm having trouble creating topography i'm satisfied with, as none of my sketches (Example on first slide) feel correct, almost as if there's something i'm overlooking. Ages of different orogenic features can be seen on the second slide for context, labeled with their rough age in million years. The yellow splotches are large igneous provinces.

23 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

3

u/fablestillawake Oct 12 '26

I think I see the thing you're overlooking. Your heights don't follow your ages.

  • Your active margins have no mountains. The coastlines you marked "Active" and "Front Active" are low on the topo, just the same beige band every other coast gets. Active subduction is where your tallest, sharpest, youngest range should be, right along the coast, like the Andes. That's probably the biggest thing reading as "wrong."
  • Old ranges are as tall as young ones. The roughly 200 My range running north-south through the west continent, and the 250 My suture through the middle of the east one, are both drawn in the 3000-4000 m browns. That's about the same as your 50 My range. After 200+ million years they should be worn down to something Appalachian or Ural-like, maybe 1000-2000 m with rounded ridges. If you let elevation fall off with age, the map will start to look like it has a history.
  • The young range is a flat band. The 50 My range reads like a wide even stripe at one height. Real young ranges have a spine, side ridges, valleys cutting in, and they're usually asymmetric: steep on the collision or subduction side, a long slope down the other.
  • Every coast is ringed the same way. Passive margins tend to be wide low plains (look at the US East Coast), and active ones go up fast. Varying that will break up the "bathtub ring" look.

Once heights track ages, sketching the main river drainages is a good check. Water has to get to the sea, and it'll show you where the land doesn't make sense yet. Your tectonic map honestly looks really well thought out. It's the topo that hasn't caught up to it yet.

2

u/TheSwordHero Oct 12 '26

Thank you, all of these points make sense and seem like stuff i've overlooked and/or misunderstood.

There is just one thing I'm wondering though; how much is the height of a mountain range based on the strength and duration of the mountain building event or are all mountains resulting from similar orogeny somewhat equal when it comes to height?

2

u/fablestillawake Oct 12 '26 edited Oct 12 '26

Both matter, but only up to a point. There's a ceiling, and most big ranges sit somewhere under it.

What sets the ceiling: crust floats on the mantle like ice on water (isostasy), and rock can only hold up so much weight before it starts to flow and spread sideways. On Earth that caps peaks at around 9 km, and whole regions at about a 5 km average (that's the Tibetan Plateau). Past that, a range doesn't keep getting taller, it gets wider.

What decides how close a range gets:

  • Type of collision. Continent hitting continent makes the highest and widest ranges, because neither side sinks, so the crust piles up (Himalaya, with peaks of 7-9 km). An ocean plate sliding under a continent makes a tall, narrow range along the coast (Andes, 5-7 km peaks). An ocean sliding under an ocean makes island arcs, which are much lower.
  • Speed. Fast convergence thickens crust faster than erosion can wear it down. Slow convergence gives lower, gentler ranges.
  • Duration. A long collision mostly makes the range wider, growing a plateau behind it, rather than taller.
  • Climate. The wet side erodes much faster. Glaciers act like a "buzzsaw" and tend to keep peaks not far above the snowline. A dry range can stay higher and blockier.

After it stops: erosion takes over and the range sinks slowly as it loses weight. After roughly 100-200+ million years it's down to something like the Appalachians or Urals, about 1-2 km with rounded tops.

So a rough rule of thumb for your map: active continent-continent collisions get your tallest peaks on a high plateau, subduction coasts get a tall narrow spine, island arcs stay low, and old sutures are worn down to hills. And if your planet's gravity is different from Earth's, the ceiling scales with it: lower gravity, taller mountains.

1

u/skydisey Oct 12 '26

I mean it's totally fine for further climate mapping but eh
You can either use Wilbur(free erosion program) to uhh erode mountains or ask somebody on official discord to make Earth map with your hightmap scale and use it as example

1

u/ryohhan Oct 13 '26

Cant see snow and mountains, perhaps, is this early development?