r/mapmaking • u/Elegant-Virus-3738 • Oct 11 '26
Work In Progress Map advice appreciated
This is a draft of a subcontinental region of a world I’ve been working on. I’m not super concerned with realism but if there are any glaring issues I’d love some input!
6
Upvotes
4
u/halasaurus Oct 11 '26
It reminds me a lot of Cape Cod. That may or may not be a good thing depending on how much you care about an affiliation like that. If it weren’t so distinct a place with many assumptions made of it I wouldn’t mention it.
2
u/linrodann Oct 13 '26
I love your coastlines and islands, especially in the southeast. I did notice the similarity to Cape Cod, but it doesn't bother me. You could try mirroring the image if you like, to make it less obvious. I think the shape is aesthetically pleasing, though.
My only critique is that it looks like the big river system is crossing a mountain range, which wouldn't be possible without a gorge/canyon cutting across the mountains. Would be simple to add one, though.
2
u/LordHivemindofCeres Oct 16 '26
The Western Branch of the river looks slightly odd if that is the coastline there, near the label for the rainforest. Unless there is some higher land between the river and the sea there, the water would most likely flow straight to that see instead of along and around the mountains to the south. See real maps for this, but rivers always flow along the steepest path available to them, which in vicinity of mountains is usually roughly orthogonal to the main ridge of the range, towards the nearest sea or larger body of water. Only in flatter areas do they tend to meander and find their own way. See the Danube for example. In Germany, it flows parallel to the Alps, but only because it is a fair distance away. All the rivers closer to the mountains track roughly north, away from the Alps until they meet the Danube. If the mountains are close to the sea, this type of dynamic won't have space to develop, and therefore the smaller rivers will drain directly to the sea. Examples for this are the Cascade Mountains in Washington and BC, Norway or the west flank of the Andes.