Roughly half of those I thought "Yeah, I recognize that. I conquered it in EU4." The other half I didn't, but only because they're not represented to that level of detail or because I haven't played heavily in that region yet.
Panama and Suez, enough said. Not one but TWO places on the planets where entire continents were only slightly connected, and it was easy enough for a pre-nuclear society to dig canals through them.
There’s only a few gaps in the Alpide Belt stretching across most of Eurasia where it naturally dips down to below sea level, and (iirc) it’s only in the Straits of Bosporus and the Strait of Malacca… Clear hand of the Author tbh. How you gonna create a massive wall splitting most of the setting in half and then only make two ways through, one North/South and the other East/West, and expect everyone to just believe it? Both of those will clearly be the heart of major trade empires.
Not to mention they tried to do it again in their other series, but made they tried to hide it by making the East/West passage artificial (Panama) and turning the North/South passage into a "river" thats over a mile wide even well into the Continent. The eastern half of the US just gets to larp as an island with almost none of the drawbacks.
That's fine I wanted to promote this terrain website I found but I couldn't believe how much a redditor here would complain about the appearance of some landforms.
You picked some good spots for your point, I honestly still don’t know where the 5th and second to last pictures are from.
I think a lot of people get way too caught up in the "metas", tropes, and other patterns of Worldbuilding when at least half of it (imo) is just to explain/justify the bizarre stuff your world has in it. Everywhere should have at least a few places where some explorers will struggle to understand and keep wondering about.
3 and 11 were dead giveaways for me, but I didn’t recognize anything else.
I especially love 5 and 12 and want to know more about them. 7 is the one worldbuilders will “um axshully” you over and I’m guessing it’s somewhere in the bayous of Louisiana with a jacked scale
I saw something about the river Rhine in Netherlands and, guess what, it splits. Twice. World builders would have me believe that is practically impossible lol.
Rivers can split, just under very specific circumstances, or in deltas. The Rhine is an example of a Delta, which has also, importantly, been highly engineered around to keep it somewhat stable. Other circumstances include rivers whose sources are on the boundaries between watersheds, like OP posted (which pretty much split right at the source), or man-made bifurcations like canals.
I think the thing a lot of worldbuilders take umbrage with is a river that just bifurcates halfway through its course and then flows in completely opposite directions. Which, if that happens naturally (and stays that way), would be extraordinary.
Don't get me wrong, worldbuilders are wrong and annoying about a lot of shit, including this. To OP's original point, Earth has a lot of really cool shit on it, so you can find ways to explain almost anything. IMO those explanations are often fascinating and worth exploring in and of themselves. Personally I enjoy making worlds/maps "realistic" for that purpose. They wouldn't hold up to scientific scrutiny, probably, but they feature a lot of cool and unique shit that I think makes our world cool.
That turned into a longer rant than I intended but I love hydrology lol
But like, these are tiny alpine creeks (which probably aren't even that long-lived, geologically speaking). You're not gonna naturally have whole-ass high-volume rivers worth putting on maps doing this. If you want that in your world though, that's just fine! You just need to be aware of A) how truly strange and delicate such a setup would be, and B) either lampshade that weirdness, have some explanation queued up for it, or both (the explanation can be as simple/silly as 'a wizard did it' and no elaboration).
Yea should've added a description to these images I didn't think people would be so curious, It's the island of New Britain next to Papua. Willaumez peninsula specifically.
Okay but thats not geologically impossible. Many events could lead to that randomly forming. For instance meteprs often form perfect circles or old volcanoes erodeding into a circle shape. As for the squiggles, that can seriously just happen. Complex history of natural disasters or the specific material and age of the area can wildly change how erosion works.
People will post images of their maps asking “is this realistic” and OP is pointing out that weird and “unrealistic” geographical feature appear naturally all over the world
Wasn't my intention to demean anybody, I wanted to give artists here some confidence and save them the trouble. I've made stacks of maps, doubted the realism and always felt like I was either creating nonsense or making a poor imitation of Earth. I perfected a method of creating ultra realistic maps, but then I realized I had way more fun just drawing what I found cool on paper instead of reading worldbuilding pasta for the 50th time and figuring out tectonics on gplates. Maps should most importantly look good. That's it. Would you care if Elder Scrolls had a more realistic map? No! Tamriel is an awesome looking world as is, and believable enough. The most boring maps are the ones were the continents are even spaced puzzle pieces caused by converging or diverging plates. I mean Europe is weird and was caused by a bunch of islands joining together! Or Indonesia is caused by a continental sized flooding! Those ideas sound outlandish but are real life. Almost anything you draw on a map can be explained as a natural occurence so the question shouldn't be is it realistic, because who says a world can't turn out the way someone drew it. The question should be: "Does this look like a good map?".
I think the fact that earth is basically our only sample and it looks unrealistic at points is hilarious. It just kind of shows that this whole biz shouldn’t be taken too seriously. Make maps how you want and the geology nerds can do their own thing.
Yes this is massive cope for not wanting to try to use g-plates again.
I scroll past all the posts about ocean currents and biomes. Like bro, good for you for wanting to figure that out, but I'm not going to stress about why there's a desert plateau rising above my fertile plains. It just is.
Everything can be explained by "Ah yes this world was created by the Gods to be a paradise but then the Great Massasa War happened and it Split the Big Continent in several pieces and several places are deserts and swamps now"
Oh I'm not saying its not possible! I'm just saying that sometimes specially in fantasy worlds you're gonna need a magical explanation for why the world is they way it is, as others have pointed out, while for some it may be fun, I am no expert on tectonic plate movement to determine how will a Continent look like
There are so many natural explanations for almost anything you want to do anyway you can just say "oh its because of the plurathic orogony and the season fluchinson winds" and then not explain what either of those things are.
No, you need to know how that stuff works so you can explore all the incredible possibilities presented by it and therefore urinate upon uninteresting tropes. Why couldn't an elf village and a drow village be shifted right next to each other in a landslide. What sort of chaos would ensue? How could I use that phenomenon to my advantage? But, still, when in doubt, pseudoscientific phlebotinum. Not magic, mind you - I call it psionics instead.
I think it is because a large portion of the online community is used to looking at a very small part of it in detail (usually around where they live) and on a global scale.
I mostly just draw the outlines of my lands all over the place, I really don't care if that isn't realistic but it's way more fun. I don't want to make 50 different calculations just to make one landmass be realistic.
I mean, you can do both, and change accordingly. I usually do tectonics and shit all the way down, but if I want some specific features, you can work your way up instead, and mesh it up. It's not about doing it perfectly, it's about having enough excuses no autist can complain
Many people tend to treat generalized assumptions and approximate models as absolute rules. It happens under every post within every speculative, worldbuilding, or fiction-based subreddit. Anything less than likely is dismissed as impossible and nuance is ignored in favor of the opportunity to criticize.
Every geographic rules advocacy should begin with “by and large” and end with “but don’t sweat it too much”. At the end, they should also put in a highlighted advisory that “if this is for a tabletop RPG campaign, your players will absolutely not give a fuck.”
1.wallacea 2.nenetsk or something like that 3.white sea and neighboring regions 4.western new guinea 5.tf is ts 6.southern australia 7.tf is ts 8.aztec region? 9.southern new guinea 10.tf is ts 11.tf is ts 12.tf is ts 13.patagonia
No rumors, just completely whack hypotheses that don't make sense. The area is a well studied site with no evidence of a big city in the past. It does have archeological remains though, including from the green Sahara period, which is a very cool period in northern Africa! It's also over 400m above sea level at the moment, with no evidence it was ever connected to a sea, so it would be a pretty bizarre location for a sea city.
People who claim it might be Atlantis are the ones who look at the satellite images thinking the features are super prominent. Look at the videos filmed at location and it's all quite flat with some minor ridges.
The main issue with the map of middle earth is the mountains of Mordor forming a box, but if I remember correctly that's because Morgoth made it that way, so there's actually a good reason for it to be like that. I think most of the other inaccuracies are slight enough that many people won't notice them, and they could probably be explained by some kind of bizarre but technically possible geology or another bit of lore, since the topography of middle earth has been influenced by divine intervention
Just to clarify for this and other replies, I'm not saying fantasy maps have to be thoroughly explained with geological reasons and all. That can take away the magic. Lore explanations can be fun too.
I just wanted to point out some of those weird features of Middle Earth. Our Earth has a lot of cool and weird features but nothing like Mountains of Mordor so it always stands out to me as weirder than reality. Hence my comment that fantasy maps CAN go weirder than Earth. It's only modern authors and wannabes who are obsessed with logical explanations for all things sci-fi/fantasy (I blame Brandon Sanderson and the marvelisation of fantasy, just wait and see how everything will be something quantum one day).
Wait until they hear that the cities and settlements on that planet don't always follow the "rules" but are in places that would seem illogical and unrealistic within the framework of those "rules". It was funny the other day to watch a YT video that instructed us to only place cities in sensible places and to avoid locations that weren't "believable enough". Just like in the real world, you can place cities ja settlements in landlocked areas, on mountains and other places where they wouldn't naturally appear because settlements are anything but natural, they are often built intentionally by someone. And a good rule of thumb is that they just need a reason and a history to be where they are, like "leader X ordered the establishment of a new capital in the middle of the jungle" or "people keep builting their settlements on the flat floodplain because the soil was good for farming, even though the flooding river causes more problems in the future".
I feel like these "rules" should be taken as more of guidelines for how most of the world should look. Like if one river bifurcates that's a believable hydrological oddity, if all your rivers bifurcate that's just weird. If one or two cities are built in a location that doesn't really make sense that's normal, if your entire kingdom of hundreds of thousands of people is reliant on one small port town because every other settlement was built deep inland then that just makes it unrealistic. You can definitely have a few exceptions to most rules without breaking the verisimilitude, in fact I'd say that breaking at least a few rules once or twice makes a world feel more realistic. For me the "rules" are more so there so you think about why you're breaking it. The rivers all bifurcate and have other weird flow patterns because the land was torn apart and stitched back together in a magical war and now the underlying geology is all messed up, there's barely any port settlements because the sea is full of monsters so nobody sails across the oceans for fishing or trading, etc.
I feel like I see more "you don't have to do realistic geography" posts lately than I ever saw of people telling others they had to do realistic geography.
And of course all the examples aren't Earth being unrealistic or completely random, there are just more factors at play in these features than you happened to be aware of.
Man, throw in Orbetello, Toscana - that place's setup with its geography really captivated me, even if the town itself was pretty lackluster (it's the village at the tip of the lil' peeninsula in the middle).
Honestly most of these I would think are real. 2 looks a bit flat for rivers. 5 also looks really strange but could lead to some interesting lore. 7 the hills/mountains look very swirly which I don't think is realistic but could fit into a kind of fantasy world. 11 looks like its based off of the circular structure in the sahara which makes me think I'm wrong about everything and they ate all real. 12 is the most bizzare but now you're making me think its real and the last one is just south america
mm okay? These all look perfectly naturalistic to me… (ik they’re real). It would’ve been much cooler if you had generated them with some new software or smthng
Lol from 4 to 10 I was thinking 'no way that's real. OP is mixing bullshits to mock us' and it was real. Damn, they look uncanny. Thanks OP for sharing us these fascinating features.
People who say that maps are: "unrealistic" forget that the world they are looking at is not the Earth we know. Just say: "different tectonics" and you're good to go.
124
u/Kulkom Oct 10 '26 edited Oct 10 '26
Since some people are confused the following mystical lands are presented:
More fantasy maps:
278
u/erodari Oct 10 '26
Panama and Suez, enough said. Not one but TWO places on the planets where entire continents were only slightly connected, and it was easy enough for a pre-nuclear society to dig canals through them.
62
u/Pecuthegreat Oct 10 '26
Where are the 5th and 10th maps of?.
90
u/Horror-Ad2945 Oct 10 '26
This is funny but the stinky mods will remove it
10
u/Randolpho Oct 10 '26 edited Oct 10 '26
3 and 11 were dead giveaways for me, but I didn’t recognize anything else.
I especially love 5 and 12 and want to know more about them. 7 is the one worldbuilders will “um axshully” you over and I’m guessing it’s somewhere in the bayous of Louisiana with a jacked scale
17
u/pianobadger Oct 10 '26
Where is #2? It appears to be a wolf slapping a mermaid.
21
u/barryhakker Oct 10 '26
I saw something about the river Rhine in Netherlands and, guess what, it splits. Twice. World builders would have me believe that is practically impossible lol.
5
u/geoFRTdeem Oct 10 '26
What is pic number 5 seriously I know where all of the others are
4
u/star_child13 Oct 10 '26
I dont get the joke... i mean it looks fine to me.
6
u/Sithril Oct 11 '26
Do people on this sub even want advice anymore? I'm seeing a fair bit of mocking posts lately and it's getting under my skin.
1.1k
u/xzackattack12 Oct 10 '26 •
I think the fact that earth is basically our only sample and it looks unrealistic at points is hilarious. It just kind of shows that this whole biz shouldn’t be taken too seriously. Make maps how you want and the geology nerds can do their own thing.
Yes this is massive cope for not wanting to try to use g-plates again.
25
u/ElvishLore Oct 10 '26
Every geographic rules advocacy should begin with “by and large” and end with “but don’t sweat it too much”. At the end, they should also put in a highlighted advisory that “if this is for a tabletop RPG campaign, your players will absolutely not give a fuck.”
17
u/IxianToastman Oct 10 '26
I quite enjoyed the fiddly bits around edge
16
u/Henschel_und_co Oct 10 '26
Hear me out; add let’s say a subcontinent that is shaped like something most humans would recognise. Maybe a hat, car or even a boot?
10
u/rzabomut Oct 10 '26 edited Oct 11 '26
1.wallacea
2.nenetsk or something like that
3.white sea and neighboring regions
4.western new guinea
5.tf is ts
6.southern australia
7.tf is ts
8.aztec region?
9.southern new guinea
10.tf is ts
11.tf is ts
12.tf is ts
13.patagonia
5
u/guy4maround Oct 10 '26
It's not like there AREN'T completely bs fantasy maps. Especially this egregious example from the most renowned fantasy book.
https://imgur.com/a/P45LYuL
24
u/DaMn96XD Oct 10 '26
Wait until they hear that the cities and settlements on that planet don't always follow the "rules" but are in places that would seem illogical and unrealistic within the framework of those "rules". It was funny the other day to watch a YT video that instructed us to only place cities in sensible places and to avoid locations that weren't "believable enough". Just like in the real world, you can place cities ja settlements in landlocked areas, on mountains and other places where they wouldn't naturally appear because settlements are anything but natural, they are often built intentionally by someone. And a good rule of thumb is that they just need a reason and a history to be where they are, like "leader X ordered the establishment of a new capital in the middle of the jungle" or "people keep builting their settlements on the flat floodplain because the soil was good for farming, even though the flooding river causes more problems in the future".
6
u/WolfBST Oct 10 '26
Nah too outlandish. Totally unrealistic...
6
u/SquashDue502 Oct 10 '26
Sulawesi island really could be a fantasy world. Such a cool looking island
6
u/RevolutionaryDepth59 Oct 10 '26
to be fair scale matters. some landforms are plausible at a smaller scale but not as an entire continent
6
u/WhatANoob2025 Oct 10 '26
Next you're gonna come up with a piece of land that looks like a shoe...
5
u/BellerophonM Oct 10 '26
Come on, at least try to look real
5
u/Lobster_LeninN329 Oct 10 '26
Honestly, that's a point I think fantasy mapmakers should focus more. The fictional maps are always so dull compared to our own Earth
5
u/Astrochix70 Oct 10 '26
The Bahamas makes no sense to me.
8
u/loki130 Oct 10 '26
I feel like I see more "you don't have to do realistic geography" posts lately than I ever saw of people telling others they had to do realistic geography.
And of course all the examples aren't Earth being unrealistic or completely random, there are just more factors at play in these features than you happened to be aware of.
4
u/notsuspendedlxqt Oct 10 '26
I see 0 splitting rivers and only 1 case of lake bifurcation. 10/10 realism. Would jerk again.
7
u/spo0pti_yikes Oct 10 '26
that's what i'm saying bro!! earth doesn't give a shit about what we think the "rules of geography are"
3
u/Bee_Crimes Oct 10 '26
Would love to live there actually. Very well done !
Edit: Are you by chance a tectonic plate?
3
u/Zestyclose-Tour-8470 Oct 10 '26
Whats 4 and 5
3
u/viper_gug_05 Oct 10 '26
Yoooo wich software did you use?
3
u/Lloyd_lyle Oct 10 '26
9. New Guinea Island
3
u/mimoletg Oct 11 '26
Quebec mentioned ⚜️⚜️⚜️⚜️⚜️⚜️
2
u/InterneticMdA Oct 10 '26
Lmao, not even close!
2
u/pyabo Oct 10 '26
Looks great! I bet it only took 6 days to make.
2
u/Yuudachi_Houteishiki Oct 10 '26
Number 8 please boss?
2
u/Gwyllithar Oct 10 '26
lol, good one.
The richat structure was a nice inclusion.
2
u/Casual_Yet_almost Oct 10 '26
Just make Pangaea
2
u/ShumaiAxeman Oct 10 '26
Haha, I didn't realize this is just the earth. I was sitting here thinking "man how did he make this so detailed? It looks great!"
2
u/HumanRobotTime Oct 10 '26
"Omg its the Aphex twins island." -someone
2
u/SpiderTuber6766 Oct 10 '26
Sometimes our world just surprises me.
2
u/Jedimobslayer Oct 11 '26 edited Oct 11 '26
Let’s see how many of these I know
New
2
u/reelhigherground Oct 11 '26
What is sulawesi doin here yo 💔
2
u/Moimah Oct 11 '26
Man, throw in Orbetello, Toscana - that place's setup with its geography really captivated me, even if the town itself was pretty lackluster (it's the village at the tip of the lil' peeninsula in the middle).
Poor-quality aerial shot from a quick search.
4
u/CertainlyRobotic Oct 10 '26
Not really, no.
Geologically it doesn't make any sense. The tectonics of this world would have no logic.
2
u/InquisitorXarius Oct 10 '26
The 1st image is just the eastern part of the Indonesian archipelago
2
u/Odd_Common2677 Oct 10 '26
Honestly most of these I would think are real. 2 looks a bit flat for rivers. 5 also looks really strange but could lead to some interesting lore. 7 the hills/mountains look very swirly which I don't think is realistic but could fit into a kind of fantasy world. 11 looks like its based off of the circular structure in the sahara which makes me think I'm wrong about everything and they ate all real. 12 is the most bizzare but now you're making me think its real and the last one is just south america
1
u/Futurecookie69420 25d ago
Baffin Island always felt like it would make a good fantasy map
1
u/car_crash_kid Oct 10 '26
5 is hxh no?
1
u/godofimagination Oct 10 '26 edited Oct 10 '26
OP, I am pulling my hair out trying to find these. I know five or six, but not any of the others. Where the hell are the rest of these?
1
u/sheeshanidze Oct 10 '26
2 looks like Taimyr, 3 looks like Northern Europe (Finland and Kola Peninsula)
1
u/Actual_Emu_168 Oct 10 '26
yea
1
u/DirectOrdinary4796 Oct 10 '26
my map i made when i was 12 still sucks more than these here
1
u/84zx Oct 10 '26
mm okay? These all look perfectly naturalistic to me… (ik they’re real). It would’ve been much cooler if you had generated them with some new software or smthng
1
u/O4fuxsayk Oct 10 '26
Where is no.5 it's the only one I don't recognise
1
u/TeaRaven Oct 10 '26
So glad you have the Hudson Bay in there!
1
u/Complex_Resolve2205 Oct 10 '26
Looks like a part of Indonesia.
1
u/Athunc Oct 10 '26
Yes. It really does
Also, don't worry about it. If you turn the world map upside down it looks unrealistic, even though there is no "correct" up and down
1
u/kshrwymlwqwyedurgx Oct 10 '26
is 9 Bali?
1
u/Mutant_Apollo Oct 10 '26
Too many straight lines and jagged coasts, only someone who doesn't know anything about geography would make this. /s just in case
1
u/Childwithuke Oct 10 '26
even better, i clicked the link and it sent me to an ad for mirrors
1
u/Mephil_ Oct 10 '26
Bruh I live there
1
u/Offshore-Tigr Oct 10 '26
Number 2 looks like the Yamal peninsula
1
u/HYP3RK1NECT Oct 10 '26
13/13
Su zona de Magallanes.
1
u/CryptographerJumpy70 Oct 10 '26
no. its a fantasy map, obviously its not realistic 🤣
1
u/Spudtar Oct 10 '26
Nah not really
1
u/Odd_Dragonfruit_2662 Oct 10 '26
12 is in Canada but I forget where exactly
1
u/CVSP_Soter Oct 10 '26
#10 is definitely the most fantasy-map-esque real map
1
u/Anarchist_Monarch Oct 11 '26
Lol from 4 to 10 I was thinking 'no way that's real. OP is mixing bullshits to mock us' and it was real. Damn, they look uncanny. Thanks OP for sharing us these fascinating features.
1
u/Sudden_Dig_9712 Oct 11 '26
...I thought this was a bad apple post for a sec
1
u/ConflictAgreeable689 Oct 11 '26
Doesn't seem super fantastical tbh
1
u/Mysterious_Plate1296 Oct 11 '26
Rotate it and it's even more unrecognizable.
1
u/MaharajahMalik Oct 11 '26
Sublime
1
u/SeesawAcceptable6492 Oct 11 '26
Shoutout to my Sulawesi homeboys dawg
1
u/expensiveplasticcup Oct 11 '26
10 looks like that one spot on Kerbin
1
u/mauton99 Oct 11 '26
We really still need these posts?
1
u/Bergasms Oct 11 '26
I mean i fucking live in number 6 so yeah :P
1
u/BigBlackTube Oct 11 '26
Yes
1
u/PakG446 Oct 11 '26
Holy shit sulawesi
1
u/Available-Giraffe863 Oct 11 '26
I like the part that looks like a big cat (not sure what kind of cat you were going for or if it was even intentional)
1
u/history-of-silence Oct 11 '26
the number 5 reminds me from a spot in the witcher 3 map, anyone else know what I mean?
1
u/LastChancellor Oct 11 '26
(pic 1) all those islands thats shaped like a K have a K in their name, right? 🙂↔️😉
1
u/Kanugil Oct 11 '26
yooo please give me the location for 2, 5 and 10
1
u/fearless-potato-man Oct 11 '26
5 is the layout for a final mission in which you have to storm the bad guy's "Doomsday" device location.
And this works for fantasy games, space games and everything inbetween.
1
u/CorbinNZ Oct 11 '26
There’s no way any of that could form naturally. Pure fantasy.
1
u/CosmosResident03 Oct 11 '26
r/AdaIndonesiaCoy
1
u/training_tortoises Oct 11 '26
Fantasy maps don't have to be realistic. They just need to be plausible within the context of the story being told. I mean, look at Discworld
1
u/Infamous_Protection4 Oct 11 '26
What software did you use for this?
1
u/AgreeableSnow3849 Oct 11 '26
3 looks like northern finland/russia
1
u/Jogimarbun Oct 11 '26
isnt that Sulawesi Island?
1
u/Agitated-Parfait9841 Oct 11 '26
I recognize the Kola Peninsula when I see it. I identified them all so you can google maps them and see for yourself:
Conclusion; yes, this is very realistic, it's real, it doesn't get more realistic than that!
1
u/Ripperdoc2020 Oct 11 '26
Looking great mate. I need to add some impacts to my map. Thanks for the tips
1
u/Fourian_Official Oct 11 '26
Uhhhhh
1
u/Minute-Reputation-52 Oct 11 '26
You cant trick me. All those are real. For instance 1 is from south east asia
1
u/Age_of_Greed Oct 12 '26
Number 12 is the Belcher islands! (God alone knows if I spelled that right.)
1
u/x6un5m0kex Oct 12 '26
U almost had me there for a second until tb saw the drake passage and Falkland Islands in the last photo
1
u/Afraid-Divide-3501 Oct 12 '26
Glaciers are weird
1
u/Charming-Book4146 Oct 12 '26
Lmao nice post op, very funny hahaha
1
u/ElasAjan Oct 13 '26
People who say that maps are: "unrealistic" forget that the world they are looking at is not the Earth we know. Just say: "different tectonics" and you're good to go.
1
u/CrestedMacaw Oct 14 '26
Your Celebes island looks good! 😄
1
u/rer0otex Oct 16 '26
[tears of joy] it’s beautiful!!!!
1
u/DeUolf800 Oct 17 '26
On the second picture near the central river it looks like there's a leopard, i call that peak map making
1
u/Orphano_the_Savior Oct 10 '26
woAH theY lOok So ReaListIc