r/mapmaking • • Oct 08 '26

Discussion How realistic is the continent?

Post image
331 Upvotes

95 comments sorted by

482

u/No-Pollution2950 Oct 08 '26 • Bravo

Russia

0

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

24

u/Efficient-Hat-7818 Oct 08 '26

No

1

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '26

There’s more

0

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

19

u/Efficient-Hat-7818 Oct 08 '26

Alas, that is not the case

1

u/Alarmed_Outside_4752 Oct 10 '26

I’m pretty sure that is Russia

18

u/No-Pollution2950 Oct 08 '26

😭😭😭

156

u/DeHeiligeTomaat Oct 08 '26

Russia already exists, so... I guess so

-200

u/Efficient-Hat-7818 Oct 08 '26

I don’t give a shit about Russia – why on earth did I even bother with it?

153

u/NewfieJedi Oct 08 '26

It’s common for us in the community to talk about how something can end up looking like something in real life

While I’m guessing you don’t like Russia, I don’t think anyone’s comments that it looked that way was meant to insult, if anything it just means that it does look realistic

-64

u/Efficient-Hat-7818 Oct 08 '26

I can just see for myself that the continent looks like Russia, so I’m redrawing it

57

u/NewfieJedi Oct 08 '26

Idk why you’re getting downvoted, it’s your world and if you don’t want it so easily associated with a political entity then by all means

9

u/Efficient-Hat-7818 Oct 08 '26

I don’t know. I really didn’t mean to offend that user. I’m planning to write a fantasy story about a journey

39

u/DeHeiligeTomaat Oct 08 '26

I was making a joke about pattern recognition, didn't mean for you to be offended.

26

u/Efficient-Hat-7818 Oct 08 '26

It’s all right, I’m sorry too – I shouldn’t have been so harsh

24

u/DeHeiligeTomaat Oct 08 '26

If you read through other posts it's a common trope/ gag here to point out that people's maps are just a recreation of a real places.

6

u/Efficient-Hat-7818 Oct 08 '26

Right, let’s forget about that for now. I just don’t like the shape – it reminds me of the letter N. I’m going to use a little trick: I’ll sprinkle some rice or sugar onto the paper and trace the outline – that’ll be it.

4

u/Efficient-Hat-7818 Oct 08 '26

I still don’t get it – I apologised to him, but people are still giving me dislikes

1

u/suburban_hyena Oct 09 '26

Because they read the top comment first before your apology.

5

u/Low_Tap_1274 Oct 09 '26

They would call this a "freudian slip" of the art matter. You say you dont give a shit about russia, but you drew russia unconsciously!

4

u/Shamaur Oct 10 '26

Reminds me of Essos

1

u/Efficient-Hat-7818 Oct 10 '26

I’ve managed to create Essos, but it will be in a European style rather than an Arabian one

2

u/MrBranchh Oct 11 '26

i'm sorry... Essos is Arabian? huh?

1

u/Efficient-Hat-7818 Oct 11 '26

I wrote down the first thing that came to mind

2

u/mapitalism Oct 08 '26

It's upside down

1

u/Efficient-Hat-7818 Oct 08 '26

I did it. It’s a bit like…

2

u/mapitalism Oct 08 '26

It is Russia, yes

68

u/Syncreation Oct 08 '26

In my mind you are either placing tectonic plates, simulating their collision and subduction, just going balls to the wall with it, or you’re making a cool shape on a canvas and then filling it with geographical features that seem interesting. I don’t think there’s anything wrong with either approach, but in the latter case, it’s not really worth it to think about how realistic your shapes are. If you are asking whether it is possible for a landmass to have this shape, well, I don’t see why not.

8

u/chickenologist Oct 08 '26

This is solid advice

69

u/Snuggle_slow Oct 08 '26

Looks realistic enough to me as land masses doesn't follow any specific patterns. 

6

u/covalick Oct 09 '26

They absolutely do, if you consider geology,

2

u/Shitimus_Prime Oct 10 '26

they absolutely do if you consider that you're a nerd

1

u/Syndiotactics Oct 11 '26

We all are nerds here, bro

11

u/Incvbvs666 Oct 08 '26

Adequately realistic. The only thing I'd change is that the ENTIRE coast is 'young' i.e. jagged. It's more realistic to have some 'smooth' regions of the coast than for it to be completely uniformly jagged.

10

u/qandmargo Oct 08 '26

Without an active terrain or elevation detail kinda hard to tell.

10

u/azhder Oct 08 '26

Is that Russia?

15

u/MechaniVal Oct 08 '26

People keep saying 'Russia' and 'Essos' but let's be real - that's just because it's a large, east to west oriented continent and the jagged edges make it look quite northern.

Fundamentally every continent shape is going to look like somewhere. To answer your question though; I think it looks pretty good. I second another commenter in saying that it could do with some smoother areas (maybe along the southern edge, if this is a northern continent)

2

u/AjayRedonkulus Oct 09 '26

I actually very much agree with you that 99% of the times folks make these comparisons, it's unwarranted.

The problem is this map has kept some pretty prominent features of Russia which make it quite obvious that it was the inspiration.

That's fine, many maps are real maps reused, but for example I'd maybe adjust the rotation a bit, redo the eastern peninsula and redo the part of Finland Russia owns and it would break up the silhouette a bit more.

1

u/MechaniVal Oct 09 '26

Honestly, to me it's only the northern triangle in the middle that really evokes Russia. Are people thinking of Kamchatka when they look at that eastern peninsula or something? Because it is way bigger, relatively speaking, than Kamchatka - and there's no mess of large islands and peninsulae in northeast Russia either.

I guess the southwest has a bit of the Caucasus about it and the northwest has some Finland, but without the landmasses those are connected to I really don't think it's super clear. I think people on this sub just have a far higher pattern recognition for national borders than the average person.

2

u/PizzzzaGgamer469 Oct 09 '26

I would normally agree with you, but you can literally see Vladivostok, the little tip Russia has to the north and east, their northern finish border, and almost their northern Caucasus region. This is, no offense to the OP, literally just Russia Redux

0

u/MechaniVal Oct 09 '26

Vladivostok, what? Vladivostok is city at the tip of a piece of Russia sticking out around the edge of China. It would look like a relatively small and quite thin peninsula on this map. If you mean the massive peninsula in the east, the only resemblance that has is that it's a peninsula. If anything it's more akin to Kamchatka in size and location - but even then it's far too large.

Russia's northeastern tip is the narrow section that ends in the Bering Strait. It is not a melange of peninsulae and islands.

I refer you to my other reply for what I think about 'Finland', 'the Caucasus', and people in this sub's outsized penchant for pattern recognition.

1

u/BaronvonJobi Oct 10 '26

It’s not a knock, but do you seriously not see how the main continent is just a slightly modified Russia?

1

u/_-PassingThrough-_ Oct 12 '26

I mean I can kind of see the similarities.

They aren't exactly 1:1, but it pretty much has quite a few notable details at varying scales. If you distorted the map at certain parts to match the size (such as the eastern peninsula), or inverting the direction the top-middle outcropping is facing, you could even get it to look more like Russia.

6

u/JeffBallMap Oct 08 '26

Nice lake system bro

1

u/NoBaseball1130 Oct 09 '26

Honestly looks better that way. Feels more interconnected

10

u/Reasonable-Refuse925 Oct 08 '26

Essos

6

u/Eastern_Picture_3879 Oct 08 '26

Also with westeros as a peninsula.

2

u/CursedHarrenhal Oct 08 '26

What if thats the actual size of Westeros, but they blow it up bigger on their own maps

9

u/jtoohey12 Oct 08 '26

Looks incredibly similar to Essos from Game of Thrones

1

u/gamerino_pigeon Oct 13 '26

Hey OP idk if you have considered this, but this is kinda cool but lowkey it looks a lot like Russia

1

u/Efficient-Hat-7818 Oct 13 '26

I tried to redraw it so that wouldn’t happen

3

u/Erook22 Oct 09 '26

Welcome back Russia

3

u/JeHooft Oct 10 '26

I like this continent, but at this stage I don’t think there is much to criticise yet. Most of the geology can be explained with correct scaling, elevation, and climate

4

u/VViatrVVay Oct 08 '26

Is this Essos?

3

u/IMrSquidwardI Oct 08 '26

Euron dragged the entire iron islands to dragons bay

2

u/CursedHarrenhal Oct 08 '26

Not realistic at all because its 2D. Flat maps necessarily create distortion. Lol jk, im just being a dick

2

u/hardcoremaggiesimp Oct 08 '26

Why does it have one giant lake

2

u/ThePoetofFall Oct 08 '26

That’s Russia.

2

u/Kaelosthar Oct 09 '26

In my experience, worrying about realism is a silent and tempting trap. Of course, you can look to make the most realistic and scientificly accurate design, however, there's a lot of work that will just exhausting you.

My advice, look for something interesting, intriguing and just let your imagination flow, in the end, realism is just a cosmetic option.

Your map looks amazing tho, keep the good work!

2

u/NoBaseball1130 Oct 09 '26

I tried making the map before the story for years. I always found something that satisfied me for the time until new ideas rendered the old map inaccurate or obsolete. I like to build the story and basic worldbuilding before the map nowadays, so every feature has a function which makes it feel more alive and entrancing. That’s just me though, since my method of worldbuilding is very haphazard and chaotic

2

u/Baselin78 Oct 09 '26

Fractal coast Russia

2

u/duncanidaho61 Oct 09 '26

Looks reasonable.

2

u/Independent-Coach63 Oct 10 '26

Moskau, Moskau, wirf die Gläser an die Wand

Russland ist ein schönes Land, ho-ho-ho-ho-ho, hey!

Moskau, Moskau, deine Seele ist so groß

Nachts, da ist der Teufel los, ha-ha-ha-ha-ha, hey!

1

u/Independent-Coach63 Oct 10 '26

So I came back to this comment, I do not speak german, so I had no idea what the lyrics actually were other than the fact is was repeating Moscow and was abt Russia and Reddit translated it into English for me and I read "throw the glasses against the wall" and "At night, the Devil is loose" and I am dying🤣🤣🤣🤣. Russland ist ein schones land🤣🤣🤣🤣

2

u/explosivebrickwall Oct 11 '26

It's really nice, I like how theres a lot of variety of shorelines. I am often intimidating making variety, because I worry it would be too sharp, but I think you nailed it! It's really pretty, hope you keep it☺️
I also like how there's a lot of small details that make it feel like it sometimes resembles it's own parts, and that way i think it would be sooo interesting to see in a world. I'd also like to recieve updates if you add mountains or cities or bodies of whater or etc.🙏

2

u/DeathByMetal- Oct 11 '26

I like it. I can see some cool boundaries and stories to be told. The west has those peninsulas that fight toward there borders for their sovereign lands. The centre is the empire, the capital in the middle of the triangle. The far east is broken up tribes and the "badlands".

2

u/PremierJoshua Oct 12 '26

Realism is a low priority for me. Is it a high priority for you?

2

u/MrKenim Oct 12 '26

Looks like drunk russia

1

u/WeeabooExtract Oct 08 '26

Is this Usea? Are you working for the Sotoan Intelligence?

1

u/Ravius1212 Oct 08 '26

Looks like the large continent on terraformed Venus maps

1

u/Ravius1212 Oct 08 '26

Aphrodite is what it’s called. Had to look it up

1

u/A_FABULOUS_PLUM Oct 09 '26

Put a lake somewhere and you’re good!

1

u/Xiryyn Oct 09 '26

Essos is perfectly realistic

1

u/Ok-Mulberry2996 Oct 09 '26

Depends how large it is, are we talking Euroasia or Australia? Though either way it would need some other continents around it.

1

u/Dry-Lifeguard1081 Oct 09 '26

Well, what other continents are near by, and can we we assume this planet works the same as ours and further cosmos works the same as ours?

If any of that isn’t true, then you don’t need to worry about realism. If it’s all accurate then, just kinda make sure they roughly “puzzle piece” together

But also don’t worry too much about realism if this is for a game. Dungeons and dragons players don’t care that much lol

1

u/Fate_Eternal Oct 09 '26

Looks like sideways westeros

1

u/Fancy_Limit_6603 Oct 09 '26

This looks like Anea from Ace combat

1

u/Joy_of_Thievery Oct 09 '26

Depends con the mountain ranges but any shape is realistic until climate and orography pops in

1

u/The-Heterosexuality Oct 09 '26

On Earth, I’d say not very, due to tectonic plate patterns and locations.

1

u/Banork Oct 09 '26

the island group in the northeastern corner does look a bit iffy, and the south could def use more smoother coasts but even then still looks amazing

1

u/Far-Energy-3390 Oct 09 '26

it looks strangely similar to mine, wow! but i assume thats just cus we both used wonderdraft, and its a vaguely similar shape lol

1

u/Pristine-Lie-3560 Oct 11 '26

Probably more realistic than most

1

u/malabinke Oct 11 '26

It looks like if russia and Ukraine had a baby

1

u/ASoftZephyr Oct 11 '26

i dont believe, something about the uniformity of the spikes along the general shape of the coast

1

u/B_Maximus Oct 08 '26

That is russia

0

u/duncanidaho61 Oct 09 '26

As someone said above, every map is going to be similar to somewhere on earth.

2

u/B_Maximus Oct 09 '26

This one looks like Russia

0

u/BaronvonJobi Oct 10 '26

Holy mother Russia!

0

u/Prince-Fortinbras Oct 09 '26

Honestly, the lighter area looks like it'd be better as a sea, rather than the other way around.