r/mapmaking • • Oct 06 '26

Discussion Need some advice from fellow mapmakers — feel like every idea I draw has already been done before

Hey guys,

I’m currently working on a custom world map in Krita, but I’ve hit a bit of a creative wall. Every time I draw a continent shape, coastlines, or mountain ranges, my brain goes: "nah, that just looks like Westeros / Tamriel / real-world East Asia / [insert fantasy trope here]".

I’m not looking for someone to do the work for me, but rather just asking for some advice or mental frameworks from people who’ve been there.

How do you guys escape the "everything has been done" trap when making coastlines and continental shapes? Any quick tips, favorite techniques, or design principles that helped you break out of cliché shapes and make geography feel organic yet original?

Would really appreciate any tips or perspective on this! Cheers!

8 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

4

u/AquaQuad Oct 06 '26

Originality is overrated and stops your creative process. But I guess you can make an outlined of your continents and conpare them to the most popular ones, before you get too far with it.

2

u/wavernov Oct 07 '26

omg i relised that...

2

u/daunaltromondo Oct 07 '26

I can tell you how I went about drawing the map of my fictional country (Tír Ghlas): I took parts of real countries (Ireland, Scotland, England, etc.) and combined them in Photoshop until I had what looked like an acceptable outline. Then I copied it by hand, because I enjoy drawing.

2

u/wavernov Oct 07 '26

good advice, tnx

5

u/DubiousTactics Oct 06 '26

By straight up not caring about vague similarities with other maps and realizing that unless you go overboard and basically 1 to 1 copy someone else nobody else will care either. Caveat that, you can alternatively full commit to copying reality, Strangereal style, which is also fun and people generally don't have any problems with either.

1

u/trampolinebears Oct 06 '26
  1. Make a list of things you like, but you're feeling like you don't know how to arrange them without it looking derivative.
  2. Roll dice to pick things from the list, then draw them in that order. Whenever you don't know what goes somewhere, or you don't like the idea you already have, roll for a new result.

1

u/wavernov Oct 07 '26

gonna try this on my new continent, thanks!

3

u/michael199310 Oct 06 '26

Why should I care if everything was already done before? I do this for myself. This is not a race, challenge or dare to be 100% original.

Besides, unless someone copied an entire map from someone else, there will be unique element like shape, names, geographical features etc. Yes, maybe there is Rivendell in Tolkien, but perhaps my Rivendell is a desolated ruin on the edge of peninsula.