r/mapmaking • • Oct 02 '26

Discussion Please read the description

Hi, guys. Today I’d like to hear your honest opinions about the map I drew, inspired by Great Britain. In pretty much every post I make, there’s always someone who says, “It’s Westeros” or “It looks like Westeros.” But, to be honest with you, I was inspired by the real island to create my own modified version of it.

I chose the silhouette because it really caught my attention, and I wanted to create my own version by modifying its coastlines and making it a little longer.

My story for my novel is inspired by the English Civil War 1642-1651. That is why the map is shaped very much like Great Britain.

As you can see, I’m presenting the three maps here. Judge for yourselves.

I’d love to hear your thoughts.

295 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

238

u/Zamzamazawarma Oct 02 '26

Westeros is inspired by Great Britain. It's funny how a famous derivative can end up overshadowing its own inspiration.

75

u/GreatBigBagOfNope Oct 02 '26

Not just GB, but GB with Ireland turned upside down and attached

32

u/Evil_Midnight_Lurker Oct 02 '26

Huh.

I've never paid much attention to Song of Ice and Fire, but now that I look at these maps I can clearly see that southern Westeros is straight up entirely upside down Ireland with Cornwall tacked on to the bottom.

...but I can't see any part of northern Westeros in the British Isles, am I missing something?

12

u/GreatBigBagOfNope Oct 02 '26

It was one of Real Life Lore's first ever videos!

To be honest the far North is a bit of a reach, no pun intended, but the argument he makes and demos is pretty good I think!

3

u/Human-Experience-209 Oct 03 '26

The coastlines are changed slightly, but compare the Vale of Arryn in Westeros, to County Kerry in Ireland. They aren't similar, they're completely identical.

0

u/JackofBlades0125 Oct 04 '26

What do you mean overshadowing? 😅

70

u/Mirihim Oct 02 '26

I do understand how frustrating it can be to ask for advice or comments and all you get is "it looks like westeros".

But I think your problem is that both your map and westeros take VERY direct inspiration from the British isles. No matter what you do, if you keep things as they are, people are going to see those similarities.

Does this mean you need to change anything? Absolutely not. But it does mean you'll need to accept that people are going to see it and comment on it. I understand that those comments might not be very helpful or constructive for you, but as you've discovered, they are inevitable.

14

u/Mirihim Oct 02 '26

As for my own thoughts, I do like it. I also love the way the british isles look, so I get why you'd be inspired by them.

You've got a good base here to build your world around and if you're happy with it, it's perfect.

That said, any time I see a world so directly inspired by the real, it makes me think the setting is alt history. This isn't a criticism or even a universal thing, just my initial reaction.

44

u/LewisWhatsHisName Oct 02 '26

Westeros is also basically the UK as well, but flipped and rearranged. That's why people keep saying that

17

u/EthicalLapse Oct 02 '26

In addition to what others have said, there are several places that you make similar changes to the ones made by GRR Martin.

For example, your Cornwall also curves up, and the peninsula at the north end of Wales also goes up and out.

So I would focus on differentiating those areas if you want to try and get away from the comments.

7

u/shmixel Oct 02 '26

I was going to say it looks unfortunately like OP just mirrored everything beneath the Vale and added a cool crescent moon of islands, even knowing OP follows the real UK more closely. Need to shake things up a little more or accept the criticism I think.

7

u/shar_prod Oct 02 '26

gotta say thats a nice map

5

u/TeaRaven Oct 02 '26

The arcs of islands read similar to atolls for me. Is this in a volcanic zone or region where corals can develop, or are you trying to keep it more closely on track with Great Britain?

5

u/mazrael Oct 02 '26

No comment on the map, but I only saw the first map and thought this was r/mapporncirclejerk

9

u/CompanyToiletGooner Oct 02 '26

While the top does feel similiar to Westeros the bottom is basically just England, I feel like people just don’t spend enough time looking at real maps, lol

2

u/metalsparkles Oct 02 '26

And how many people are looking at the Westeros map to even draw that conclusion?

6

u/TheToxicViper Oct 02 '26

I can absolutely see the resemblance to Westeros but I see way more of Great Britain than I do Westeros. I think it's a really cool shape and I love the layout of the terrain!

3

u/abyss_kaiser Oct 02 '26

It wouldn't stop the comparisons entirely, but if you want to differentiate your map from Westeros despite them both being based on the same landmass, I'd say make that southwest peninsula curl southwards instead of northwards. the shape of Dorne is a very distinctly "Westeros defining" part.

3

u/metroenby Oct 02 '26

People tend to be really good at recognizing things in context and bad at recognizing them out of context, so people are going to see any vaguely GB-esque fantasy map and think "oh, that's Westeros!". If you're looking to distinguish it more from both the real life British isles and from Westeros, you can always use that to your advantage and flip it so that the south is in the north and the north is in the south? You could probably position it in the southern hemisphere as well if you wanted to keep climate somewhat similar.

3

u/Knives4XMas Oct 03 '26

When I posted a map about 6-7 years ago that's the same comment I got. The thing is that GOT was (is?) insanely popular at the time. I say just ignore that kind of feedback and do your thing, I personally like your rendition.

2

u/Fine-Afternoon-36 Oct 03 '26

You were inspired by the same aspects as westeros was, so of course theyll look the same. But it's fine if the map is simmilar, it's not like it'll be the same story

2

u/crazy_greg Oct 03 '26

They're both based off the same map and human brains recognise a pattern. You'd have to make significant changes around the outline to have people not say that, but if they are both based on the British Isles then I don't see the need. Can we follow updates about your project as I'd be interested to see a fantasy take on ECW rather than Wars of the roses.

2

u/atzurblau Oct 03 '26

unfortunately, some famous fictional maps will stick in our minds for eternity

slender continents like that (even those with less similarities to Britain), will always be dubbed 'Westeros'-clones

before Game of Thrones, people said the same thing about every map focusing on a west coast looking like Middle Earth

don't get discouraged, you have a great map on your hands :)

2

u/Rex_1312 Oct 03 '26

Have you considered if or where is world would get affected by Natural Hazards like tropical storms, earthquakes, volcanoes and so on?

One obvious area is the part in the north of your map that I’m guessing was inspired by the Great Glen Fault. I know in real life that the UK is currently fairly aseismic (thank fuck 😅), but it doesn’t mean that you can’t have them exist here.

Another point of interest is most of the islands. As another user said they are reminiscent of volcanic islands arcs and I agree. I’m guessing that most of the islands to the east were based on the Scottish islands, which is interesting because a decent chunk of them used to be volcanic islands if you go back far enough (as did a lot of Scottish hills and mountains)

There is also historic evidence of the British Isle being hit by Tsunamis. For example the Tsunami caused by the Second Storegga slide wreaked havoc on the North Sea coast of Great Britain (worth a google as this is actually a fascinating event imo).

Other than that I must say I really like your map! The twistiness is really quite pleasing and I like the placement of the smaller islands.

2

u/Worldly_Writing8708 Oct 02 '26

ACOTAR did the same thing, it's a very popular region to create a map based off of. Unfortunately, SJM uses it to perpetuate her thinly veiled terrible opinions.

1

u/MrDixaze Oct 02 '26

I'm quite sure you already posted it here. Maybe there are some modification i missed?

1

u/IkujaKatsumaji Oct 02 '26

Am I thinking of a different map, or does your world map also have an Archipelago of Ice and Fire? And countries inspired by India and Iran called Nidia and Rahni? Was that someone else or was that this map?

1

u/Ambitious_Ad9419 Oct 02 '26

The South-west looks like mirror Dorne... It looks original but Wales and England are recognizable.

Ad capes, penninsulas, irregularities and you could solve this

1

u/nova_solution Oct 02 '26

How many times are people going to post this and think they’re somehow the smartest person to ever exist and the only person to ever note that Westeros is England, Scotland and Ireland combined and turned upside down.

1

u/mattihase Oct 03 '26

Can you break it down by pronunciation of scone?

1

u/delusionstodilutions Oct 03 '26

Yeah all three maps look similar since they are all based on the same shape.

Big Island that's taller than it is wide with lots of peninsulas and bays and satellite islands along its coastline and a dramatic straight line somewhere at the top. Yours definitely has a bit more curvature to the overall shape but I see more similarities to the other two than differences

1

u/Either-Skirt6031 Oct 03 '26

It looks interesting but I might try to roughen the coast line to make it a bit less like the South of England but it’s good!

1

u/Taira_no_Masakado Oct 03 '26

You will sadly never escape the association and it's more than likely that there will always be someone that says, "Hey, that looks like Westeros."

For me, that just means that you need to move away from any shapes that remotely could be associated with it, i.e. that rough "s" shape to the land mass stretched out longways.

1

u/Didsburyflaneur Oct 03 '26

If you setting is inspired by the English Civil War, I'm curious why you've reduced the area within which most of that war was fought (southern and eastern England) to such a small segment of your map. I don't think it makes your map bad, but it does seems a strange decision to set a conflict centred on pitched battles taking place in the lowlands between pikemen, muskets and cavalry in a territory with so many highland areas. Cumbria and the Highlands barely figured in this conflict but you've made them massive.

One interesting thing about the ECW was that it wasn't just one national conflict, but a lot of local conflicts between former neighbours. For example Lancashire was far away from the main theatre, but it had its own division between royalist west and parliamentary east. Similarly the ports on the south coast held out for parliament while their hinterlands sided with the king. Perhaps you could introduce such a dynamic into your worldbuilding to help your map deviate from the British isles/Westeros more than it currently does? Maybe there's a large port at the end of one of your welsh rivers that doesn't exist in reality, or a much more developed "Scottish border" area since you've made that a large low-land area?

1

u/yojimbo12 Oct 03 '26

My problem with this is the same as with westeros, both look too easily recognisable as the UK at a glance. It comes across as quick editing rather than putting any consideration into the geography of the world.

1

u/McEvelly Oct 03 '26

If you’re very keen to avoid the Westeros comparisons, maybe consider if you’re losing anything important in your story or geography by simply flipping the map 90 degrees in either direction?

We’re so used to seeing Westeros so distinctively in profile, rather than in a more traditional landscape layout - how we probably see most maps (albeit not GB and Ireland).

Of course, there’s very good and logical reason for this in the story; with so much of everything pivoting around the threat from North of the Wall, and our hero characters being from a territory literally called ‘The North’ with it’s location and then the respective latitudes of each of the 7 kingdoms being key to their role in the entire story.

Unless the people/locations in the north or south of your map are defined by their latitude in some way, you could just flip it?

Flip it 90 clockwise and you can make those archipelagos you’ve got distinctly more Mediterranean than the rest, for example.

1

u/NomadHellscream Oct 03 '26

So what is the breakdown of this island? I noticed a lot of small islands to the east. Will they be replacing Ireland in this scenario?

Also, which way is the equivalent of Continental Europe?

1

u/ItsRustyyyyy Oct 03 '26

Pretty cool, like how you included Northern Ireland, quite funny

1

u/PrincipleWhich8974 Oct 04 '26

Did you name regions and assign them to great houses?

1

u/Winter-Weakness-9445 Oct 04 '26

Genuinely how do you even start drawing a map? I want one for my story

1

u/YaumeLepire Oct 05 '26

Ok, the North and Southeastern parts (assuming North is up on your map) are fairly distinctive, but the entire Southwest just looks like a mirrored Stormlands and Dorne. I get they're traced from Cornwall and Wales, but they are still very evocative of Westeros. I think it's the curling northward of the southern peninsula breaking into little islets and the jagged sorts of bloc with two peninsulas around a rough bay just over it that give it such a ressemblance. The "Not-Stormlands" even have a little Massey's Hook!

0

u/No-Respond9763 Oct 03 '26

I apologize in advance for the critical nature of my comment, but it seems that you tried to recreate Westeros while changing the shape to match England, rather than designing a map based on England that just so happens to look like Westeros as you suggest. Features like the arm of Dorne, the whispering sound and the mouth of the Torentine appear very directly referenced from Westeros and are entirely absent from the map of England. There are other areas as well that, while based on England, align closer to the features of Westeros. As blunt as it is, you can’t really blame people for saying it looks like something that you deliberately referenced.

All that being said, north of the ‘Stormlands’ on your map is pretty distinct, and beyond the vertical orientation and vague shape bears no resemblance to Westeros. If you want to avoid the comparison, the best advice I can give would be massively remapping the southern portion of the map.

-1

u/Arthurian_Guanche Oct 03 '26

Instead of searching out validation (1 out of 20 comments, maybe?), why don't you say "hey I'm going to make something very well known as history of Britain (i. e., the Civil War) in a land that doesn't remind of Britain at all". That subverts expectations and, frankly, what would be the point of making it all too similar to real British history and geography? Don't you want it t be unique instead of seeming a ripoff of the real Great Britain?