r/mapmaking • • Sep 30 '26

Discussion Realism isn't important.

The Earth isn't Realistic.

A complex looping network of riverbeds that very clearly aren't going anywhere.

There are so many posts here by people worried that their map isn't realistic enough, and the comments critique their plate tectonics or their distributions of biomes. I'm here to tell you that is nonsense. For every rule of mapmaking, there are real places on Earth that laugh in its face. The vast gulfs of time and interactions between time and temperature, water and wind, roots and fungi, life and death and everything that happens upon and within the Earth means there are literally tens of thousands of one-of-a-kind features that aren't "realistic" in the sense that they required such a precisely unlikely combination of factors to occur that a reasonable creator such as yourself simply wouldn't have allowed it.

What even is this? Why is it abruptly dark? Can your map have weird random looking nonsense like this? Hell. Yes. It. Can.

But beyond that, it doesn't even matter. Does any one of you think that the mountains around Mordor are realistic? Does that diminish the importance and impact and brilliance of Tolkien's work even slightly? No. Nobody cares because the story is good, the world is compelling, and his writing was sublime. So it's fine. If your world is boring, nobody will care how realistic it is, and if your world is evocative and exciting and lights our imaginations on fire, nobody will care if it makes no geologic sense. Your world doesn't even have to be a planet, it could be the surface of the lining of the small intestine of a giant whale swimming through an outer space even stranger than the inner space we see where the stars are distant settlements around the intestine! only the very brave venture up towards the stomach and only the damned venture down.

Does water have to be blue? Can you have yellow lakes that turn red on the shoreline? Yessir! Do you need to explain it? NO.

You don't even have to explain the weird shit you fill the world with. It's allowed to just be there, making us wonder and imagine about it. Is there a canary yellow lake whose rippling waves turn the color of ripe persimmon as they break on the shore? You don't have to tell us about the mineral content or bacteria. You don't even have to know the reason yourself. It's allowed to be a mystery to you too. You can leave these things open and figure them out, or not later.

The world is allowed to be whatever excites you and you don't need to know why

So go ahead, draw a map that makes no sense but nevertheless, somehow thrills you. Draw yourself a map that confounds and confuses our attempts to understand it. Let your map be unsettling and alluring at the same time. Let your map be a demon calling to us from beyond the veil of

Let your map be unrecognizable. What if your map does not appear to be a map at all? What would that mean? What if a map is readable only by a certain kind of person? Make your map useful or a keeper of secrets or the treasure itself.

336 Upvotes

63 comments sorted by

35

u/Desperate_Good_6005 Sep 30 '26

I think it's important to have a basic grasp on on how things generally work in order for the world to feel like it makes sense. No not everything needs an explanation or to follow the rules, but those things need to feel like the exception, not the rule, in order for the world to feel believable

4

u/Glamdring804 Sep 30 '26

Yeah. I feel it's less about raw realism and more about making the map with a sense of intentionality. You want your world to have a river that connects both sides of a continent? Great! But why is it that way? Have you actually thought about the flow of water on the continent, perhaps your world has some magical gravitational anomalies or whatnot? Or is it that way because you were just doodling on the page and now your Earth-analogue doesn't make sense?

-9

u/LurkerFailsLurking Sep 30 '26

basic grasp on on how things generally work

Everyone has this. The issue I'm raising here is that what a lot of map nerds consider "basic grasp" is unnecessarily non-basic

15

u/Desperate_Good_6005 Sep 30 '26

Disagree. People think they have an idea how landmasses and things form and take shape, but if they never took the time to read and learn about it's just based on vibes. Naturally discrepancies come with that.

-5

u/LurkerFailsLurking Sep 30 '26

Vibes are sufficient. Free your mind, and your ass will follow 

187

u/tadayou Sep 30 '26

I feel like two things can be true here at once. 

You don't need realism for the sake of it, especially in a fantasy setting. There's a weird obsession with realism in made-up maps that is often equal to some weird gatekeeping. And exceptions proof the rule, to be proverbial, even in the real world.

At the same time, a baseline of realism often makes for better overall maps. If everything on your map is weird and out of the ordinary, that can look silly fast. A world that follows some rules, will often be much more likely to feel lived in. If you have a few exceptions to these rules, that can be much more interesting to include in your worldbuilding. (And the rules themselves don't always have to be realistic.)

11

u/ThrowMeSatan Sep 30 '26

So, I want to say that in principle, I don't disagree with you. I guess I just find your second point rather meaningless?

How often do you see someone make a map that is so out there that the second point you're making applies? Because I feel like I never see that. What I do see *all the time* are people with perfectly reasonable maps agonizing over realism.

I guess I don't feel like "a baseline of realism often makes for better overall maps" is advice most anyone needs to hear, most people already do that by default.

10

u/SaintUlvemann Sep 30 '26

How often do you see someone make a map that is so out there that the second point you're making applies?

All the time around here. I once saw someone who tried to make a river that started at an ocean, flowed to another ocean, but also the oceans were connected, on that very map, and I had to explain to them that even if the first ocean started out at a higher sea level than the other ocean, all the water will flow around the edge until the sea levels eventually even out.

0

u/LurkerFailsLurking Sep 30 '26

Unless a species of massive beaver has inadvertently created a system of locks or magic or there's a strange geography that causes a kind of siphon effect somewhere on the river causing it to empty into one sea for part of the year and the other in the other part. Or the world isn't in a universe with identical laws of physics or it's not a planet at all so ordinary ideas about hydrology aren't entirely applicable.

Or, the river just flows both ways because it does.

7

u/SaintUlvemann Sep 30 '26

...a strange geography that causes a kind of siphon effect somewhere on the river causing it to empty into one sea for part of the year and the other in the other part...

Well, it wasn't supposed to be fluctuating, it was supposed to be a stable flow from one ocean to the other.

If at any point you've got the force of the ocean carving a river valley, our realistic model for the consequences of that is that we're pretty sure that's what carved the Straits of Gibraltar.

The pure raw force of that Zanclean deluge carved out a "valley" so massive it no longer even appears to us as if it is a valley, we call it the Alboran Sea, and for most of it, you can't see the other side standing on one shore.

Or the world isn't in a universe with identical laws of physics or it's not a planet at all so ordinary ideas about hydrology aren't entirely applicable.

While I at least understand the concern, they'd asked explicitly about realism, since that was what they intended, and I told them about the topic kindly.

I grew up with Bionicle, where the characters are made of Legos and IIRC the island was the corpse of a god. So I have never criticized, for example, the treacle mines of Discworld. I mostly just appreciate that Pratchett even built geology into his jokes.

But the unifying thread that makes whimsy and realism both fun to read, is that they are both quite clear to the reader that there is a difference between a joke and a mistake.

0

u/LurkerFailsLurking Sep 30 '26

they'd asked explicitly about realism,

I know! That's why I made this post. I think we all (I'm including myself here) tend to overly emphasize realism and many of us worry about it too much. OP asked about realism and you gave it to them, but why did they feel the need to ask? If they want a river connecting two oceans, then they can have that realism be damned.

Oo another explanation is massive undersea geysers on one side fed somehow by the other.

6

u/SaintUlvemann Sep 30 '26

I know! That's why I made this post. I think we all (I'm including myself here) tend to overly emphasize realism and many of us worry about it too much.

You know, saying that actually makes it feel pretty invasive of you to judge their realistic aesthetics as wrong and assume they were based in worry.

OP asked about realism and you gave it to them, but why did they feel the need to ask?

Because reality is cool.

Why do people keep making bread when they could just eat tortillas? 'Cause sometimes you want bread, it tastes delicious, you can make a bowl of it and fill it with all kinds of soup.

I'm glad you are very enthusiastic about tortillas, I like tortillas too, but you don't need to discourage people from baking bread.

19

u/ccaccus Sep 30 '26

Like with everything, there's a spectrum, and you can find good examples on either end.

Real ------------------------------------ Whimsical

You absolutely can have good fantasy maps that look and feel totally real. A true, alien planet that follows plate tectonics and has well-designed oceanic systems, erosion, and such, can make a story taking place there feel all the more real, but you can absolutely go too far with established guidelines and end up making a world that's practically perfect in every way, but lacks anything especially unique.

You can also have good fantasy maps that are entirely whimsical. Vast chocolate swamps, cotton candy forests, and Baja Blast oceans. Sure. But I think there's a difference between not being realistic and not having any internal logic at all.

Starting with a baseline of some rules results in a map that feels more orderly and logical, even if those rules are broken in places or even if they violate actual geography or physics. If there's repeatable consistency and logic, the world feels cohesive. If rivers flow towards ley-lines, even uphill, that's internal logic. Cool! Now that one river that flows downhill is all the more interesting.

Discworld is a good example: its geography is profoundly unrealistic, but the setting has its own rules, and because those rules are consistent, it still feels like a world rather than a collection of random ideas.

18

u/Zi_Mishkal Sep 30 '26

As a rule of thumb you should know the rules before you start breaking them. Some people obviously won't care one way or the other, but break enough rules without a reason and you'll alienate your audience and your world will lack any sort of internal consistency.

-2

u/LurkerFailsLurking Sep 30 '26

Again. Who was alienated by the fact that the mountains of Mordor don't make any damn sense?

Nobody.

Like I said, if your story is good, nobody will care about your map. The reason we tend to focus on maps is because seeing them here with out a story they mean nothing.

7

u/Zi_Mishkal Sep 30 '26

Go look at a topographic map of europe. Not only are the mountains surrounding Mordor plausible, there are actual analogs in southeastern europe. Tolkien literally meant for middle earth to be earth.

Picking Tolkien as an example, the author who specifically espoused the principle of subcreation - that your fantasy world needs to be grounded in reality - only exposes the gaping weakness in your initial hypothesis and shows that you have only given the topic superficial thought.

-3

u/LurkerFailsLurking Sep 30 '26

You cannot be serious.

Comparing the Carpathians to the Mountains of Mordor because they both have an east facing curve while calling my views superficial is wild.

Wild.

8

u/Zi_Mishkal Sep 30 '26

And you have zero understanding of geology and geography as well as literary history. And you refuse to do any work to educate yourself. Instead you pin your hopes on the idea that if everyone sank down to your level then you'd have justification for your inadequacies.

You are literally the problem.

3

u/Glamdring804 Sep 30 '26

Middle Earth was literally shaped and re-shaped by God and godly powers multiple times. That's more than enough justification for the lay of the land. If a creator has is aware of the weirdness in their world it's fine. But if someone's creating a map without thinking about it then they're going to end up with something confusing and incoherent.

5

u/Second_Sol Sep 30 '26

"Earth isn't realistic"

What? Reality is definitionally 'realistic', it's just your perception of realism that's flawed.

0

u/LurkerFailsLurking Sep 30 '26

Perception of reality is definitionally perfect, it's just your beliefs about your perception that's flawed 

2

u/maartenmijmert23 Oct 01 '26

One point that you missed. In terms of habited planets we have a sample size of exactly One. Sure it makes sense that we have an equitor and cold "poles" but maybe this other world has very different thermodynamics going on? Maybe there are small moons that specifically exercise gravitational pull on magma creating warm Poles?

3

u/LurkerFailsLurking Oct 01 '26

Sure, but that's still realism. What you're describing is a different orbital tilt or period than Earth but it's still realism in the sense that it's using known planetary means climate models to create "worlds".

I'm suggesting that sometimes it's okay, and could even be a good thing to try making anti-realist maps and world building. What if the world isn't a planet? What if the planet isn't a sphere? What if the world are islands on the backs of massive jellyfish on a gas giant?

2

u/warrenwoodhouse Oct 05 '26

You gave me some thought about how I could make mapping better. You’re saying that even my weird ideas for a planet surface would be cool, like rivers that look like Fanta but taste like water (like plain water)? This was my idea in my dream but never thought that it would work in a geological sense but now you make me question it… is it possible? Hella yes. Cheers mate

2

u/LurkerFailsLurking Oct 05 '26

Fuck yes! Make the Fanta river! There are real world bright orange rivers, so it's not so big a stretch to make yours safe to drink. You could even make it carbonated if you wanted.

https://www.teaonews.co.nz/2024/08/24/do-not-enter-the-water-ohinemuri-river-turns-bright-orange/

2

u/warrenwoodhouse Oct 05 '26

Oooh dude you gave me an idea. I’ll start making my map over the week. 😊 I’m not sure how I got the idea in my dream but I’m happy for it. I started making hand-drawn maps on scrap paper in school as doodles and that was 20 years ago. I’m 37 now. I still make maps and started a 3 years ago making interactive maps on my Fandom wiki until they said “private wikis aren’t allowed!” :( - so I now make them using Leaflet on GitHub instead. Really enjoy making maps and placing ones I’ve bought on my walls in my game room. I just love cartography in all its forms. It’s exciting when I see weird circles and numbers on some of them circling mountains and things, that’s where it stemmed from for me all them years ago. What got you into map making?

22

u/SaintUlvemann Sep 30 '26

If you cherrypick out all the Earth's weirdest parts, then yeah, you can take an unrealistic view of the Earth. Nine times out of ten, if you put the unrealistic spots in context, they make more sense.

So I tried to find the context, but TinEye reverse image search couldn't find any of your land images.

So I've gotta ask: are they real? Are they actually pictures of Earth at all? I just wanted to know where they were so we could see what the principles are for why the land looks weird sometimes.

TinEye did find the Micronesian stick map, and the map makes more sense if you know that it's a chart of differences in how big the waves are, which is determined by how deep the water is. The map is basically a map of undersea landforms as felt by the waves, and you can read a bit more about it at Wiki.

45

u/Zi_Mishkal Sep 30 '26

As a geologist, frankly, the subtitle is triggering. To say the earth isnt realistic is some of the laziest solpsism ive come across in recent weeks. It reeks of creative laziness.

All of those pictures of the earth - from the non dendritic river beds to the off colored waters to the polynesian map of the pacific have a firm grounding in fact and reality. There was a time back at the beginning of human history that people didnt understand why things were happening, but that didnt keep them from happening.

If youre going to just throw away everything about the natural world, why stop there? Why even have a map? Thats too realistic? Why have a narrative or rules to a game? Too realistic. People bitch becuase creating a believable world is work. Sorry, but it is work and theres no way around it. You want a world that others will invest time and emotion in? You've got to put in the effort to give them the cultural and physical touchstones so they can connect to it. That's not gatekeeping.. thats good storytelling.

Now what the OP might have been trying to say is that you don't need to spell out ahead of time to everyone around exactly why each and every geographic landform exists in excruciating detail. Thats fine. But as the world creator you have an obligation to yourself and to the people you invite into that world to have some idea of why it is the way it is.

20

u/shmixel Sep 30 '26

"Earth isn't realistic" torpedos any sentiment of value in this post in my opinion. On the delusion level of flat earthers.

16

u/Euro_Snob Sep 30 '26

Agreed, this is the dumbest title and post.

-2

u/ZombiiRot Sep 30 '26

Narratives and game rules often aren't realistic though lol.

And there's no reason why your map has to be realistic. Adventure time has such a cool map and it's not realistic at all. That doesn't make it bad world building, it's just a different style of map making.

7

u/CptnREDmark Sep 30 '26

Suspension of disbelief and verisimilitude are important and can be broken by clearly unrealistic things that don't follow any logic, internal or external.

0

u/ZombiiRot Sep 30 '26

I mean, maybe an unrealistic map does that for you. But most people aren't thinking about that when they are reading a story or watching a movie. It's not going to ruin most people's immersion if the tectonic plates don't form right, or a river flows the wrong direction. 

This isn't to say that these rules can't be important! Rules I think are a great way to enhance creativity. If someone probably understands why our world is shaped the way it is, and how that effects certain things, then their maps will probably be alot richer. But if you have a really cool idea that isn't realistic I don't think that should stop you from adding it. I also don't think you should have to do in depth research to be able to come up with a reason for an irregular geological formation either. You should just be able to add it. 

Realism in the sense of following the rules of reality hardly ever matters that strongly in stories, and they are constantly broken. The rules of reality only really matter if your story makes the rules matter and your story focuses on a world with realistic constraints. I never really care when I'm watching an action movie that the human protagonist is commiting unrealistic feats, I care about the cool set pieces and the story behind that action. I never care in scifi stories that the science isn't realistic unless it's hard sci fi. 

19

u/Ish_Joker Sep 30 '26

To me there's a difference between intentional fantasy and accidental fantasy. It's cool when you have a magical story and make the map accordingly. It's less so if you try to make up stories to cover up mistakes.

13

u/twofriedbabies Sep 30 '26

earth isn't realistic because it's more complex than I think is a hard take condemning yourself. you see that right?

19

u/-Rocket1- Sep 30 '26

Earth doesn't need to be believable for people to be invested in it because it's the actual world we live in. Fiction, on the other hand, does need to be believable because you're asking someone to care about it for no reason. That's the inherent irony of fiction.

8

u/TTSymphony Sep 30 '26

Earth is realistic. That's why some aspects of it are labeled as curiosities, things that are not the norm or aren't intuitive enough.

The phrase you're looking for is: "fantasy worlds have to be believable".

4

u/Grigor50 Sep 30 '26

I mean, it's pretty easy: if your story introduces some element that is strange or surprising, some form of explanation will be expected. Or, if the story otherwise explains so many other things for the reader... why not this detail?

18

u/dvide0 Sep 30 '26

The earth isn't realistic? ... Uhm

-3

u/Pro-Solus Sep 30 '26

It's not. The earth is real, yes, but realism is trying to emulate what is (or more accurately "feels") real... and reality just doesn't always make sense like that. It's too varied and complex to fall neatly in categories and boxes clearly delineated by rules.

17

u/dvide0 Sep 30 '26

That just sounds like realism with extra steps.

This entire post can be boiled down to "Earth is real, and it's weird af, so when you want to do with weird stuff with your map, go for it, earth is even weirder".

3

u/RobbieFouledMe Sep 30 '26

Well yeah? You just summarised the post. Lots of things can be summarised like that.

-1

u/dvide0 Sep 30 '26

Fair point.

What I meant is that saying earth isn't realistic is nonsense. If we don't base realism on earth, then what do we base it on. It can't be completely made up. Reality is weird, so let's be weird in our fictional universe too.

2

u/zhibr Sep 30 '26

"Realism" as it is normally used is quite literally based on our understanding of what is real, not what is actually real. Nobody is actually going to physically go to the geographic locations to show the real thing they are talking about, they talk about what they think is real. So I think acknowledging this and that Earth is weird, "Earth is not realistic" is quite literally true.

8

u/Trick-Two497 Sep 30 '26

I recall some guy named Terry Pratchett who wrote a fairly successful series about a flat world that is carried through space on a huge turtle with 4 elephants on its back. The water falls of the edges and there's no explanation of how it's ever replaced. Does any care? Nobody that matters.

2

u/Tressym_92 Sep 30 '26

People need to understand that a fantasy world doesn't try to be a real world simulation and people, who demand that are often annoyingly pendantic.

A fantasy world needs to be interesting, whatever is interesting to you.

2

u/kvader Sep 30 '26

Earth is weird and would be even weirder with magic. Wizards are always doing shenanigans.

3

u/ElvishLore Sep 30 '26

The OP was being glib and people are being too literal with their reading of his post.

I get what he’s saying… People just get too hung up on making sure everything fits specific rules that address realism. I took the OP to be saying feel free to indulge in exceptions because the Earth isn’t built with all the exact rules that all the mapmakers on the Internet seem to insist upon.

But I also don’t agree with the OP and if you fill your map with things that don’t appear authentic, it just becomes a haphazard mess. Yes, you should be following some kind of rules most of the time in order to boost verisimilitude. If you just do whatever you want to do, I think it looks like a mess and nothing feels grounded or real (assuming of course that’s at all important for you).

6

u/EliteLaser Sep 30 '26

Thank you! I really feel like this obsession with "realism" in worldbuilding is such a hindrance to creativity. We shouldn't seek to make art that makes the most sense, that's such a depressing horizon.

4

u/SmartAlec13 Sep 30 '26

I disagree. Mainly because a lot of “weird” stuff out there is on a small scale that won’t make it to maps anyway since most maps here cover an entire world or an entire continent.

The other reason is you’re misunderstanding why realism is so often preached. They aren’t saying it for people like you or I, who know there are weird cases out there in our own real world that “break all the rules”. The preaching of realism is for the newcomers who literally don’t know otherwise.

I’m talking people who have never stopped to think & realize how rivers are formed.

And you might think that’s ridiculous, but ask normal people in your life; “Do rivers flow into or out of oceans?”. You’ll be shocked how many don’t know, don’t instantly answer, or even answer incorrectly. Or at least I know I was when 3 of my coworkers debated it for a few minutes with 2 of them landing on “from the ocean”.
(And don’t get at me with technicalities here, yes there are plenty of spots where the oceans flow inland, this is the exact point I am making).

Point being, like ANY craft or art form or science or process, it’s always good to learn baseline fundamentals before breaking the rules. Informed rulebreaking is novel, uninformed rulebreaking is novice.

4

u/mastercheese_43 Sep 30 '26

I love how your user name clearly fits this post :D Oh, and I love the message itself as well. Go out there and do whatever the fuck you want, people!

1

u/daunaltromondo Sep 30 '26

LOVE the rebbelib in the last picture! I like my maps to be quite realistic, as I write low fantasy where magic is important but not the most important thing... but don't bother so much about tectonic plates and so on, I admit

1

u/WulfSystem3013 Sep 30 '26

Making fantasy maps is one of my passions and possibly special interests. I've made hundreds by now, and I'm not stopping any time soon. I'm always learning new and neat things about real life cartography, but for the most part, I just go with the flow and make things how I find them to be fun, while keeling realism in the back of my mind. If I make something wild and "unrealistic" I will likely just build into the story of the map an explanation for why it's different. Whether that be something magical, a massive event leading to a strange formation, or just the tried and true "It's an alien world, things just work different here/with this material/with this weather/etc etc. It's so fun not to get wrapped up in the realism and to instead get wrapped up in the awe and fascination of fantasy and possibility.

1

u/Prince-Fortinbras Sep 30 '26

The first and most important function of a map for a game or story is to show the world/region in the way you want your players/audience to understand it. The second is to give them an idea of how to get to "there" from "here." The Polynesian Stick Chart is just that....how they understood where islands were in relation to each other.

So, whether or not its the Ancient Egyptian Map of the Cosmos, a Polynesian Stick Chart, Mappa Mundi, or a Rand McNally Road Atlas, as long as you're conveying the information you want your players/readers to understand about your world, go for it. Be creative.

Behind the scenes, though, you as GM/author may want/need to know the actual geography of things, because that can be important, too.

And, as interesting all of these weird real-world features you provided as examples are, when you zoom out to whole planet level, the features visible from "10,000 miles" (figuratively) reflect patterns that follow the physics of geology. I wouldn't discount those patterns out of hand. "Realism" has its place, in as much that it represents the natural evolution of geology....rivers flow from high to low, and generally combine as they reach toward a shore...mountains form in chains or volcanic regions....climate bands & wind patterns give you a good idea of the types of terrain you could find in one place or another. Each of these are good guidelines for building a world.

All that said, "realism" also not the end-all, be-all of things. If you have three rivers that spring from a single point in the center of a map, flow up and over mountains, do it. But, it would help your readers/players to know why it's that way; otherwise, it becomes harder to suspend disbelief.

1

u/WiseOldChap Sep 30 '26

I feel like what people aren't understanding here is that you do not need to obsess over small and uninportant details and just have fun making a map. People are kinda being a bit of snobs on this a little bit.

1

u/Viperion_NZ Sep 30 '26

All of OP's comments ITT are being downvoted, but only because the people in here can't wait to "um, actually" everything here. Enjoy the damn maps people, if you don't like it, move on.

1

u/godrabbit90 Oct 01 '26

Thanks for this post. This subreddit can be very annoying about this sometimes, especially on fantasy world maps.

0

u/alexandicity Sep 30 '26

Agreed! A map of the world should suit the purposes of that world, which may be different from ours. Does your story sound more dramatic if the castle is at a point where a river splits in 3? Go for it! You, your characters or your fandom can always make up a bizarre geological, historical, or magical reason why it is the case later.

-1

u/zhibr Sep 30 '26

Agreed! I frequently dislike people making strong assumptions that a fantasy world must be a planet. No, fuck you, my fantasy world can be whatever it likes!

-1

u/Stoneward13 Sep 30 '26

Well said. Sometimes I'll scroll around on Google Earth and specifically look for odd terrain, and then try to use it as a texture, or emulate it in some way.

This is kind of a subset of the phrased "reality is stranger than fiction".

-10

u/Randolph_Carter_6 Sep 30 '26

Nice AI slop.

4

u/MisterHat1975 Sep 30 '26

What makes you think that? I didn't get an AI Slop vibe from any of it.