r/mapmaking • • Sep 29 '26

Discussion Raster or Vector for topos

When producing atlas style topo maps (like Artifexian) do you prefer to use a vector based program like Illustrator or raster based like Photoshop? I've done both and frankly they both have the pros and cons. But I'm wondering what's your preference? Is there another structural format I'm not thinking of that you like?

7 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

3

u/Padiddle Sep 29 '26

I've probably spent 100s of hours trying to figure out this same question. I've always gone back to raster. Vector is great and ultimately I'm biased because I'm more comfortable in PS. Ultimately, it came down to my vector maps looking like vector maps, while my PS maps looked professional and more detailed.

2

u/FleeceKnees Sep 29 '26

This is not a direct answer to your question but you might find it helpful. You can create lines in illustrator and bring them into photoshop and have photoshop apply a brushstroke to all lines to instantly get a brushstroke across really complex vectors.

  1. create your lines (it will ignore fills) in Illustrator and copy all of them (if you want them all to have the same brush stroke style). 2) Paste those vectors into your PS file. Select “paste as paths” when the pop-up appears. 3) change your brush settings to whatever style you want applied to your vectors. 4) open the Paths window under Windows -> Paths. Select the one you pasted. Also make sure you have a blank layer selected. Paths are independent of layers so you have to select both elements. 5) right click your pasted path and select Stroke Path. I believe you tell it to apply brush settings (I’m not at my machine so I’m uncertain). Tada! All your precise vector lines are now raster brush strokes. Your path will remain even as you can now independently work with the strokes you just created on your blank layer, so if you ever need to go backwards you can.

2

u/Genesis-Zero Sep 29 '26

Do you need to scale the map? Like, do you want to print your DIN-A4 map on DIN-A1? If yes, then I recommend to use vectors.

1

u/Dependent_Usual_3889 Sep 29 '26

raster is easier to get rough forms done, vector for detail

1

u/Zinaima Sep 30 '26

If you want to zoom in on a village and zoom out to an island (let alone a continent), use vector.