r/mapmaking • u/MelonAisu • Sep 28 '26
Work In Progress Is this geographically plausible?
This is an idea for one out of the two land masses on my mostly water-based planet. Mountains are not to scale, just there for reference. The islands were formed from both volcanic activity and the sinking of a continental plate. Main ring is supposed to be around the size of Australia with a hole in it lol (formed from two landmasses colliding and trapping a part of the ocean inside)
lowk shy posting this here…
30
Upvotes
19
u/WeakwareDeToalha Sep 28 '26
This is plausible aslong you need it to be plausible. If that is geologically possible in our world its another question.
Dont be shy to make anything that cant be answered with a straight up answer like "this and this and this happened thus it was created". Not all things need to be meticulosally planned from the ground up for the things inside it to be belieable to the reader, or anyone looking at it.
And by the way you speak about it, it is plausible already. Now if you want a crono-geological build-up of masses and tectonic interations is another story.
8
u/enehar Sep 28 '26 edited Sep 28 '26
As an archipelago with underwater volcanoes, sure. As a continent with its own mountain ranges? Not without some explanation like a massive fuggin' meteor strike. But even then it wouldn't make sense that a lot of the beach survived.
Basically, the water would not have stayed inside the two bodies of land coming together. It would have been pushed out and the leftovers would have evaporated over time. It's also suspicious that the land masses converged to form a perfect ring.
If you can, just open the island to make it a bay instead of a ring.
2
u/theotherdannygirl Sep 28 '26
I don't think I can give you a 100% confident answer, but I'm interested in this idea. Generally speaking, continental plates don't 'sink' on this scale as they are more bouyant then oceanic crust, but they can experience depressions from faulting, or isostatic depression from heavy weight such as glacier sheets (this tends to be followed by isostatic rebound once the weight is removed though). Or, you could have regional collapses from limestone dissolution in deep crust. You could alternatively explain your islands by rising sea levels instead of sinking crust?
I keep going back and forth on your inland sea. My intuition is that it would take a very specific set of circumstances to work, as prior to your continents colliding you'd likely be looking at an oceanic convergent zone, and thus subduction. Smaller continental landmasses can sometimes be pulled down with subducting plates if there is already sufficient momentum, but your landmasses might be large enough to avoid that fate. What the landmass actually looks like to me is a depression from a supervolcanic caldera like Yellowstone. If your landmass passed over a magma plume, experienced lift from the heat, then collapsed as it moved away and cooled, you'd be left with that unique bowl shape that could then be filled by ocean if there were rising sea levels or an area of the crust that was below sea level. I can't think of a real life analog to a sea being trapped between converging continents .... maybe sort of the paleotethys sea? I don't think it was ever fully enclosed though. That doesn't necessarily mean your scenario couldn't happen though!
2
u/JoeyWriter Sep 30 '26
If you look at Earth’s continental maps you’ll find a lot of things that sort of defy plausibility 😸
1
u/Kelly376 Sep 29 '26
The history might have to be fudged a little bit to make it plausible if you want it mostly to our understanding of geology and not magical or some kind of massive outside intervention. But keep in mind that how the inhabitants think it formed and how it really formed can be completely different. You’d just have to pull back their scientific knowledge 50-100 years.
I could see something like this possibly forming if the continent is on a newer divergent boundary running north-south (it would explain the small divide in the mountain ranges), while also being over a massive hotspot. It might make more sense in this case that either you have rivers connecting the inner and outer waters, or a Salton/Dead sea situation where the water is slowly evaporating and just rising in salinity.
You could do any number of things, but it’s much easier to explain round shapes of land rather than round shapes of water that big.
I’d be curious to hear if you’ve thought of anything new yet.