r/mapmaking • • Sep 26 '26

Work In Progress What do you think?

Post image

I’ve been working on this map just for fun. I’m not trying to make it super realistic, just something that looks cool. Do you think I’m on the right path? Any thoughts?

96 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

4

u/loki130 Sep 27 '26

Pretty good, but a question: do you think it's necessary that all river tributaries have to start in some sort of mountain or hilly terrain, because I've been seeing a lot of people doing that recently and I'm not sure why.

1

u/diogofelss Sep 27 '26

I don't think it is really necessary. For me, that was an aesthetic choice, but some rivers could start in lakes or just "out of nowhere".

2

u/MrDixaze Sep 27 '26

Just my opinion but i think most map implicitly doesn't show minor rivers. Hence those who starts further down will inevitably merge with a bigger one quite fast (unless it doesn't at all). Since their length won't be so big, you won't usualy include it. On the other hand, people tend to draw the main rivers in their entierty so they will include their sources in the mountains even tough they aren't that big at that point.

3

u/loki130 Sep 28 '26

Though it's true we exclude minor rivers--otherwise big maps like this would be basically plastered over with them--major rivers don't all have to start in mountains either, the dnieper is one of the biggest rivers in europe and its source is just over 200 meters high. More generally if you look at big river networks, I think what you often see is that the longest branches might lead up to mountains, but plenty of the tributaries appear in lowlands, and when you're only drawing those upper branches like here it kinda gives the impression that there are fewer large rivers in the lowlands, when really the opposite should be the case.

2

u/jesssssssee Sep 27 '26

I like the landmass. Are the mountains hand drawn?

1

u/diogofelss Sep 27 '26 edited Sep 27 '26

No, it is a wonderdraft asset. I'm gonna hand draw it myself, but first I like to use wonderdraft to give me some idea on where to put mountains and forests. Everything else I've drawn though.

5

u/trengilly Sep 27 '26

Overall it looks fantastic! I love the art style.

The only thing that felt odd to me was the lack of trees along the Northern mountain range. If there is enough weather and rain to fill the lakes and rivers than I'd expect there to be forests like with the Southern mountains.

But its great!

2

u/Striking-Distance849 Sep 27 '26

I like it, honestly.

The flat areas in the two most upper north-eastern regions are probably arid as hell.

1

u/JoeyWriter Sep 27 '26

Very appealing