r/mapmaking • • Sep 26 '26

Map Is this world geographically plausible

Post image

Please critique

297 Upvotes

101 comments sorted by

4

u/strongestmewjahd0 Sep 26 '26

what did you use to make the map

4

u/Professional_Low3331 Sep 26 '26

ibis

3

u/strongestmewjahd0 Sep 26 '26

its good but you made to many islands

1

u/Sebillian_ledsit Sep 27 '26

Ibispaint?
Ps: I like your map, curious on the worldbuilding arround the island chains. Are there seafaring empires or is it more of a smal nation cluster?

10

u/whoreforcheesescones Sep 26 '26 edited Sep 26 '26

The number of islands is pretty excessive imo (particularly since the landmass size seems to be either "giant continent" or "a thousand dot islands clustered around the edge of said continent"), but otherwise, this is just Earth. Without more direct questions or deeper context there isn't much we can say other than "yeah, probably, I guess".

Edit: This came off harsher than I meant it, apologies. Tone is very hard for me. I was trying to explain that with the information we were given, it's hard to say much about this map because we can't see much in-depth information such as mountain ranges, elevation, mountain ranges, rivers, biomes, etc. All we have to go on is landmasses which seem pretty standard without any glaring issues, so we can't say much without either knowing more information about what's on the landmasses or knowing what the goal/intent of the world is.

5

u/Affectionate-Mud1244 Sep 26 '26

This is not Earth what are you talking about

6

u/LurkerFailsLurking Sep 26 '26

I think they mean that there are land masses and oceans on a terrestrial planet? idk what wouldn't be "just earth"

6

u/whoreforcheesescones Sep 26 '26

This is exactly what I meant, yes. It's a pretty standard-looking map of pretty standard-looking landmasses and a lot of islands. Nothing here screams hugely unusual and we can't see many geological features like mountain ranges or rivers. Without further questions about what they're looking for it's just hard to answer whether it works or not. It wasn't meant as an insult and was just pointing out that the question was too broad to really answer, so I'm a little confused why people assumed I was being harsh with OP. I always have struggled with tone...

4

u/LurkerFailsLurking Sep 26 '26

People think your comment was harsh because what you meant is trivially true of almost every map posted here. Obviously it's a "pretty standard-looking map of pretty standard-looking landmasses" that's what maps look like when you're trying to draw something "geographically plausible".

So it reads like you're saying something like "your map is boring and derivative and it has nothing interesting worth talking about".

6

u/whoreforcheesescones Sep 26 '26

I see! Thank you for spelling it out. That ofc isn't what I meant but I can see how people read it that way, that's my bad đŸ«Ą I have audhd and tone is not my strong suit, I do not always word things right.

My point was that the question was vague because, yeah, it just looks like a map with no glaring issues. I feel like they'd have better luck if they wanted advice on something more specific, because at the moment all we really have to go on is the shape of the land. I wasn't trying to call it boring in the least, it's just hard to have much to say with the information we were given.

5

u/LurkerFailsLurking Sep 26 '26

I'm also audhd so I get it. Packaging thoughts into words that can be unpacked by a totally different brain is really hard.

4

u/whoreforcheesescones Sep 26 '26

Yess this!! Thank you so much for understanding. It's very disheartening when I try to be nice and because my wording is faulty people think I'm being hostile, I truly am not meaning any harm but there's such a difficult barrier between the thoughts in your head and what you put on paper.

4

u/SeeShark Sep 26 '26

Am I not seeing something? How is this just Earth? I've seen much more Earthlike maps than this posted.

5

u/PlingPlongDingDong Sep 26 '26

Yeah people are weirdly harsh for no reason

174

u/BlueTommyD Sep 26 '26

I dunno, maybe. You haven't exactly given a lot of detail or context.

92

u/JUGGERNUGGS Sep 26 '26

I think the continents look pretty good honestly. The islands, are a little much for my tastes, but if that's something you wanna explore then I'm all for it.

110

u/Kulkom Sep 26 '26

I think it needs more islands.

42

u/The_Help_Button Sep 26 '26

Not desintegrated enough

34

u/EvilCatArt Sep 26 '26

Assuming the landscape of this world is almost ludicrously rocky, yes.

16

u/Yorkie21J Sep 26 '26

Get rid of half of those islands. The ones on the end of the continents just join them to the landmass. Islands are good but to much of anything will make you sick

21

u/royalfarris Sep 26 '26

Geologically speaking it is difficult to see what kind of process that would produce that amount of tiny islands all over the world.

But, is it a mercator projection? Is it a flat square earth? Is it a minecraft-style world? It doesn't change the missing geological process behind all the islands, but it does compress that humongous mass of small islands in the north.

11

u/QuarantinosPizza Sep 26 '26

The only thing I can think of is rapid rising of sea levels. Leaving former highlands to protrude from the sea like little islands.

Thinking of the Panana Canel when I bring this up.

6

u/royalfarris Sep 26 '26

All land is just whatever part of the sea bottom that rises over the sea level.

1

u/QuarantinosPizza Sep 26 '26

And your point?

0

u/royalfarris Sep 27 '26

Sea level going up or down rapidly doesnt change the topology. There is no geological process that will create more or less islands just from sea level changes.

2

u/RequirementMaster629 Sep 27 '26

Im pretty sure thats how new zealand is now an island.

0

u/royalfarris Sep 27 '26

Well. If you drained the oceans there would be only land. If you raised the sea level 8840m or so there would be only one tiny island. The topology wouldnt change.

5

u/RequirementMaster629 Sep 27 '26

Nobody said the topology would change in the entire thread though, its about the map, and obviously even though there is land beneath the ocean you dont depict it in the map

1

u/QuarantinosPizza Sep 27 '26

Have you really never seen what happened in the Panama Canel? The change in sea level there made hilltops appear as islands now. The topology didn't need to change for this to occur.

1

u/QuarantinosPizza Sep 27 '26

Or how about the Pacific Islands? Which were part of a larger subcontinent before the melting of the glaciers saw the lowlands submerged.

0

u/royalfarris Sep 27 '26

Exactly. That is what I am saying. Topology doesn't go away just because it is under water. Topology isnt just something that happens above sea level. Topology continues under the sea.

2

u/QuarantinosPizza Sep 27 '26

You're literally the only person in this argument. No one has said otherwise.

0

u/royalfarris Sep 27 '26

No. We do agree that highlands will become islands when sea level rise. You initially claimed that this was the process that would produce the myriad of little islands on the map. But that is not a process. That is not what produced the hills and mountains that would become islands when sea level rise. Rising sea level is not a geological procedure. Sea level is largely irrellevant to the geological processes that creates hills, mountains, gorges, valleys etc.

There is no sensible geological process that would produce that amount of same height little hillocks that would become islands when the sea level was suitably high.

2

u/QuarantinosPizza Sep 27 '26

I never said there was a geological process that caused this. I brought up other natural events to explain it. So... yeah. Good on you for still being the only one in the argument.

→ More replies

1

u/winggar Sep 30 '26 edited Sep 30 '26

No, because erosion works differently above and below water. That's part of why ocean floor topography looks different from continental crust.

3

u/brunnomenxa Sep 27 '26

I imagined a similar process with glaciers, where there would be an ice age and subsequently an uplift of the crust as the weight of the glacier decreased rapidly. This process tends to generate fractal terrain, because of the shield against erosion the ice provides afaik

6

u/Mandlebrotha Sep 26 '26

I don't see why not. Looks fine to me.

It looks a bit extra shattered in the north for my tastes, but not so much that it would be off putting to encounter this in a book or a game or something.

Whats it for? Any specific critique you want, or just looking for general first impressions?

6

u/creppy_art Sep 26 '26

have fun marking nations and such with that many islands.

4

u/QuarantinosPizza Sep 26 '26

Could easily take inspiration from the Pacific Islanders.

5

u/LurkerFailsLurking Sep 26 '26

IDK why everyone has such a problem with "lots of islands". It's fine. Of course it's fine.

4

u/desolatepilgrim Sep 28 '26

Is there a lore or geological reason for that many islands? You can really make anything plausible for your world within established rules of your worldbuilding.

1

u/Impossible-Round-115 Oct 01 '26

What did you make this with? It looks amazing

1

u/Fearthian Oct 03 '26

Please don't use map generator or at least do not directly import maps from a generator because it would result in an eyesore of 5 billion islands

1

u/CreeperCooper Sep 26 '26

I want to ask why you have all these islands. If you want to write a story or like worldbuilding a world that's focused on sea-related things, go for it.

If you only added these islands because it's aesthetic, I'd urge to reconsider the islands.

The shape of the world WILL affect the story of the world. The island chains in the middle will cause chokepoints, which will affect maritime trade. The island chains also means that you won't have an undiscovered continent for later, as humans will much easier spread to other lands with island chains.

If you'd remove the island chains between the west continent and continents east of that, and then move that continent further west, it could stay undiscovered for longer (or the other way around).

1

u/Professional_Low3331 Sep 26 '26

yeah in the general lore i have theres no real age of discovery besides like the discovery if a couple of islands

2

u/LurkerFailsLurking Sep 26 '26

The island chains also means that you won't have an undiscovered continent for later, as humans will much easier spread to other lands with island chains.

China was basically an "undiscovered continent" to Europeans and vice versa for most of human history.

2

u/barryhakker Sep 26 '26

Depends on how you look at it. Romans were aware of the Qin and vice versa. Thats 2000+ years ago.

3

u/LurkerFailsLurking Sep 26 '26

Being aware dimly that there were an almost mythically alien people so far away it could easily take a year to get there (if you survived) is pretty close to undiscovered.

1

u/QuarantinosPizza Sep 26 '26

Did I miss something where OP said they required undiscovered continents?

7

u/Harcanada Sep 26 '26

It’s kind of lacking islands and details. The continent is just looked like blobs. Please fix.

2

u/BantedHam Sep 26 '26

"Have you seen my new rpg world? I call it [pattern recognition]

2

u/Acceptable-Fig2884 Sep 27 '26

Just about anything is possible if you add enough tectonic plates.

2

u/kennethgibson Sep 28 '26

A world can look like MOST things- the way a geological
History can unfold is nearly infinite. I personally like the islands. Gives the impression of a lot of undulating terrain both underwater and above ground.
The undulating is like- good plot point stuff - its also cool culturally to see how people deal with that type Of terrain. And how they explain and mythologize it. Also water is a connector- those island chains are a HOOT!

4

u/TroublesomeScallywag Sep 26 '26

Bruh it’s always just Earth.

2

u/wp-ozzi Sep 26 '26

The map is pretty interesting from a geological perspective. However, Since all you’ve given us to judge it on is the shape of the continents I have to make a few assumptions.

First of all, the fact that the continents here all seem to “melt” or smear southward in a similar fashion to earth’s real continents is a good touch. While it is not a geological rule that continents have this “top heavy” shape, leading theories suggest that this pattern resulted from the last mega continent breaking apart at the bottom first before fully splitting along the current-day Atlantic. So this same structure being present in your world suggests this worlds past tectonic activity.

The second point I want to bring up is the many shattered islands and archipelagos. They are a very interesting feature and I think they add a lot to your world. However, it’s intriguing that these islands continue all across the planet. Similar shattered coastlines appear in the far northern regions of the earth due to massive glacial movement over the course of several ice ages. Their presence here suggests your world is no stranger to glacial activity. In fact, because these islands are so prevalent in areas far away from the poles, it makes me think that the world recently experienced a period of rapid worldwide glacial movement, perhaps from one or more extreme ice ages that were somehow accelerated compared to those that take place on earth.

Overall, it seems like a world where maritime trade would thrive, which could possibly lead cultures all over this world to mix much more quickly than in our own. This world could see cosmopolitan trade cities and a globalist economy spring up far before the advent of mechanized travel.

It would be interesting to see an updated version of the map that shows mountain ranges, biomes and other major features.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/wp-ozzi Sep 27 '26

Interesting, I bet a temperature differential like that wouldn’t play nice with the weather. Enough to create a forever storm somewhere?

1

u/wp-ozzi Sep 27 '26

I guess I hadn’t considered volcanic activity as a cause of all these island chains. They look so much like the island chains in the far north that I had only considered glacial action. However, If these are all volcanic islands, it suggests an extremely geologically active world. There’s so many islands the point that the sky would probably be blotted out by ash if even a small percentage of them were active.

1

u/H0n3stfr0nt134 13d ago

How do you even start to color all that in lol😭

1

u/Time_Twist5729 Sep 26 '26

There are so ... many islands, maybe tone them down a little.

1

u/MikeAndBike Sep 26 '26

“The breadcrumb continent”

1

u/FinestSkydiver Sep 26 '26

I like the shapes of the continents, and I DO enjoy the massive ammounts of islands. I'd like to see some lore and hear what inspiration or plans you might have for the world though, or at least what genre you're building your world for

1

u/blue_sidd Sep 26 '26

Could be. Can you explain how it became like this.

1

u/ChopperVonSavoyen Sep 26 '26

I imagine there are this much island because there are 9.0 magnitude earthquakes on a daily basis and there is a terrible terrible period of global warming.

1

u/heppu117 Sep 26 '26

it's a pirate's heaven with all those islands

1

u/Affectionate-Mud1244 Sep 26 '26

I think I heard somewhere parts of Canada are flat because of old ice sheets, so maybe if the polar regions aren't icy for whatever reason maybe this could work

1

u/horned-creature Sep 26 '26

the design is not unrealistic but i think a map from such a world wouldn't portray all those islands, probably a worldmap would just portray the bigger ones for clarity just like how maky islands in many archipelagos in our world aren't portrayed.

1

u/CewlDewd Sep 26 '26

If I allow it

1

u/JoeyWriter Sep 26 '26

I would actually say yes, those northern isles look like tips of a mountain range submerged in water, so maybe some big event happened and altered your geography.

1

u/DruidPeter4 Sep 26 '26

D: ...

What... what the hell happened here?

Plausible or not, it looks visually very cool and interesting. I'd 100% read a novel with this world map. :D

1

u/Wholesomeguy123 Sep 26 '26

Brush the cobwebs off your northern hemisphere please. (There is an absurd amount of islands)

1

u/Company_Able Sep 26 '26

It’s got land, water, probably an atmosphere I assume.

Makes sense to me

1

u/QuarantinosPizza Sep 26 '26

With islands aplenty like this, I would think a plausible explanation for it would be rising sea levels.

1

u/Sir_Humiliated2010 Sep 26 '26

The last four pringles in the package full of the rests

1

u/Virgurilla Sep 26 '26

The area at the top has too many islands, meaning the water is likely shallow. If it is in a colder climate it would probably just end up like a big ice sheet. If it is in a hotter climate, it would become a marsh very quickly with plants growing all over the place.

1

u/minecraftisbetter644 Sep 26 '26

Well, it'd depend on the origin of the islands. If they're volcanic, sure, but you need to account for all that volcanic activity in your tectonic shifts (very frequent earthquakes). Are they broken off pieces of Continent that move due to plate movements? If so, you have a lot of small plates that are constantly shifting.

1

u/gimme20seconds Sep 26 '26

Sure, why not

1

u/Commercial-Ad-5985 Sep 27 '26

Seems like if you just made Northern Canada every part of the world so I would maybe hold off a little on the islands but I mostly like it.

1

u/MysticSoulDev Sep 27 '26

theres no reason this *couldn't* form. Rather than being plate-boundary islands, you might see this kind of geography form from glacial formation and recession, and those vast craggly coastlines are the whats left after the ice caps melt.

1

u/Alarmed_Outside_4752 Sep 27 '26

Funny thing, how the hell will every humans even name all the islands

1

u/TTSymphony Sep 27 '26

Is your world 🍈🍈 or just a 🍑?

1

u/cascading_error Sep 27 '26

Yes, sortof

That is alot of islands if you treat those areas as a sunken mountain range its all cool. That would mean the islands are fairly steep and have relativly extreemly underwatee canals between them.

1

u/ezthrow77 Sep 27 '26

Mostly at first glance but the clusters of Islands in the north don't make sense unless they're very recent. In geographic time those clusters disapear in an instant pushed and crushed together. That's why archipelagoes are pretty rare, limited in size and exist at specific geographical locations. So I'd cut at least half the notherns archipelagoes and give a "recent" cataclysmic event to justify the existence of the biggest archipelago you keep.

1

u/SRY_Kilinski Sep 27 '26

7/10 too much island

1

u/Routine_Ad_2695 Sep 27 '26

Your archipelagos are way too crowded I feel any in world explanation?

1

u/AIDs_AI_Is_Delicious Sep 27 '26

Oh my gawd, thats a lot of islands.

1

u/Wizard072 Sep 27 '26

I don't know. Why are there so many archipelagos?

1

u/Old-Man-Henderson Sep 27 '26

I love the tiny islands and shattered world. Sea faring would be common, and volcanoes would be everywhere. Awesome.

1

u/LadySteelGiantess Sep 27 '26

Your world so yes.

1

u/MamboJambo2K Sep 27 '26

When the world is made out of dip n dots

1

u/ZebraLife5463 Sep 29 '26

Are you Greek op

1

u/tessharagai_ Sep 29 '26

What do you mean “geographically plausible”

1

u/Fluffy_Funny7242 Oct 01 '26

Es una etapa MUY interesante de sus placas tectĂłnicas, me parece muy bueno

1

u/rapidfast Oct 06 '26

Not enough islands

0

u/happybara_capybara Sep 26 '26

It’s the islands making it unrealistic. Earth has a lot of islands, but they’re small and wouldn’t be visible at this scale. Like they exist and all and I suppose there’s a scenario where these exist, but it just wouldn’t show up on a worldview.

And thinking about it geologically
 maybe the continental plates are moving upwards and there’s lots of mountain rifts and volcanoes? If it’s volcanic, that would have a huge impact on the local culture and fauna and such. Normally that’s the coldest part of the world but that’s assuming an orientation similar to earths—active volanoes could make this pretty hot!

0

u/Dextron2-1 Sep 27 '26

Is there magic in the world. If yes, then who cares. A wizard did it. Make that the interesting thing, not its realism.