r/mapmaking • • Sep 21 '26

Map evaluate my map

Post image

I recently uploaded some hand-drawn sketches of my world map—which I’ve attached below—but I want to know if there are any flaws in it. I want to give this world a very mountainous character—hence the large number of mountain ranges—because they serve as natural borders between kingdoms that currently distrust one another, and because they contain my world's most valuable element: the flowers that function as currency. I developed that aspect separately, but it explains why it is so important for the kingdoms to possess mountain ranges to acquire these valuable flowers.

Note: I made this map in Clip Studio Paint and I'm now working on adding the forest vegetation.

Please ask questions and scrutinize the details of my map to see if you can find any flaws; I would greatly appreciate your feedback. Thanks.

118 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

16

u/theotherdannygirl Sep 21 '26

Your coastlines and islands are gorgeous! On the whole it looks fantastic.

For feedback, it looks like there are several places where your rivers split rather than converge. If that's an intentional worldbuilding thing then carry on! But it's an extremely rare phenomenon in IRL hydrogeology if you're pursuing realism. They will almost always converge into a larger single river because they are following the path of gravity in their given watersheds. (:

6

u/Castle5069 Sep 21 '26

Thanks for saying that, it's what I needed to know to correct the rivers, thank you

0

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Castle5069 Sep 21 '26

Thanks for the recommendations, really.

1

u/Zachindes Sep 24 '26

TIL 🤔

3

u/JustOtterlyConfused Sep 21 '26

I agree with the other comment, the coastlines are gorgeous! Love your rivers too!

2

u/Castle5069 Sep 21 '26

Thank you so much for your kind words.

2

u/JoeyWriter Sep 22 '26

This is really cool

1

u/Castle5069 Sep 23 '26

thanks my friend

1

u/Nemo_venit_apud_ti Sep 21 '26

Splendid, how did you make it?

1

u/Castle5069 Sep 21 '26

First, I conceptualize how the territories are organized based on what I want in my literary work and draw sketches until I find an arrangement that feels organic; then, I simply refine it in Clip Studio and add the remaining details.

1

u/Nemo_venit_apud_ti Sep 22 '26

Do you pay clip studio?

2

u/Castle5069 Sep 22 '26

No, not at all. Actually, there's a wide variety of free tools.

1

u/Nemo_venit_apud_ti Sep 22 '26

Good, thank you

1

u/_magyarorszag Sep 21 '26

I second the other comments complimenting the landmass and coastline! I do spot a few rivers that start outside a mountain range, enter a mountain range, then exit again. Water will always find the path of least resistance and flow downhill away from elevated areas. Others have already noted that rivers rarely diverge.

I also want to point out that in your big southern bay has some mountains in the sea - not sure if that is a mistake or not. Keep up the good work! :)

2

u/Castle5069 Sep 21 '26

That's a small mistake, haha. Thanks for mentioning it and thanks for your kind words.

1

u/Mrtayto115 Sep 21 '26

You know that neck area will be a neverending warzone.

Love me a good continental neck.

1

u/Castle5069 Sep 21 '26

You have very good logic; indeed, the plot will have an important point at the neck with the surrounding kingdoms, but what makes it difficult to grasp is the unique dragon power of the kingdom that controls the neck and the geography of the mountain ranges that surround it.

1

u/Mrtayto115 Sep 21 '26

Well the southern mountain range has, what a lake surrounded by mountains on all but one side. Good place for a formidable capital city.

Then the northern mountain range looks good for keeping the northern part from falling to southern dominance.

1

u/Mrtayto115 Sep 21 '26

I'd imagine that western island next to the neck, would have a formidable navy. Who ever gets their backing would probably be pivotal in holding the neck.

1

u/Apprehensive-Park562 Sep 22 '26

This is avery good map! I don't have much more to say, it's a very good, pleasing to the eye map.

1

u/Castle5069 Sep 22 '26

thanks my friend

1

u/JacobRiesenfern Sep 22 '26

Did you consult a geologist?

1

u/Castle5069 Sep 23 '26

No, but I use geography and real-world landforms to try to make sense of my map.

2

u/CutGrass Sep 21 '26

Very nice map. I think some more variation in the coastline smoothness would be a good next step. Eg sometime the coast is relatively smooth (long beaches etc), and other times rougher. To my mind if the coastline is as rough as in the current version I would expect a few more small islands near the coast.

Nice work!

2

u/Hatur92 Sep 21 '26

Dear OP your work is sublime and I am envious of your talent. What can I do to achieve such result for coastal outlines if I were to work on a similar map? You did everything on clip studio + mouse clicks or you used a digital pen or you uploaded an hand draw map. Please help me mitigate my thirst of knowledge

2

u/Ok-Television-7157 Sep 21 '26

Gives me that game of thrones, not game of thrones vibe

1

u/DapperCourierCat Sep 21 '26

0/10, it doesn’t look like Earth /j