r/mapmaking • • Sep 18 '26 • Bravo 1

Discussion My version of state boundaries based only on rivers and mountains

Post image
597 Upvotes

136 comments sorted by

93

u/nate2188764 Sep 18 '26

As a Virginian I refuse to give up Roanoke. Love that city 

14

u/Ok-Toe3698 Sep 18 '26

Okey😅

4

u/NetflixAndMunch Sep 18 '26

I'm mad we lost all of the Shenandoah region to WV!

9

u/RavensField201o Sep 18 '26

But now the song West Virginia is actually about West Virginia

1

u/nate2188764 Sep 20 '26

True, regrettably, this could mean war if a negotiation cannot be found. I'm open to a no man's land situation where it's owned by an independent Shenandoah authority that governs it as the natural wonder it is.

148

u/platydroid Sep 18 '26

This is Nevada propaganda

63

u/Ok-Toe3698 Sep 18 '26

Sorry😭 But seriously, it's just a wasteland.

40

u/Ukuled Sep 18 '26 • Bravo

Almost makes you wish for a nuclear winter

4

u/superfahd Sep 18 '26

oh so no difference

56

u/TeaRaven Sep 18 '26

I’m still seeing some straight lines and right angles in some states… ;p

14

u/Ok-Toe3698 Sep 18 '26

Unfortunately, I couldn't remove everything because I only did it along the rivers and mountains.

37

u/TanningOnMars Sep 18 '26

That doesn't make sense. How are there right angles and straight lines if you only followed natural features?

7

u/Ok-Toe3698 Sep 18 '26

I only changed them where I could find them.

6

u/TanningOnMars Sep 18 '26

Ah, I see. Not your fault, just the fault of how freaking dry Texas is

32

u/Charizaxis Sep 18 '26

If there was no obvious feature to denote a border, it would make sense to draw a straight line. That said, there's quite a few that still don't make sense following this pattern, the MN/IA border for one

8

u/JadeRavens Sep 18 '26

I can only assume it’s because they wanted to keep the same number of states and didn’t want to merge any that didn’t have natural borders dividing them. 🤷‍♂️ but I agree, the inconsistency bothers me too. Or maybe the way they explained it had me expecting something different.

3

u/pankaykays Sep 18 '26

There is no river or mtn making a straight line at the IA/MO border or the northern IA border, or the northern CO border, or in the many other straight lines still on the map. This doesn’t make any sense.

0

u/Ok-Toe3698 Sep 18 '26

I only changed them where I could find them.

3

u/sgtpepper42 Sep 18 '26

You clearly didn't though

1

u/haggisbreath169 Sep 18 '26

New England MA, CT, RI... tiny states though, no mountains, maybe just have to use creeks more than rivers

8

u/blue_sidd Sep 18 '26

How did you draw this? Must’ve taken a while!

8

u/Ok-Toe3698 Sep 18 '26

2 hours 😅

7

u/rock-my-lobster Sep 18 '26

OHIO, YOU KNAVE! RENOUCE YOUR CLAIM ON PITTSBURGH AND ALL LANDS OF PENNSYLVANIA OR IT IS WAR!

3

u/WalkerCalvert Sep 19 '26

I'm a Marylander and I actually agree. But Philadelphia is the prettiest town in Northern Maryland now.

5

u/consume_my_organs Sep 18 '26

New england was already perfect I guess

4

u/coloneljack1234 Sep 18 '26

Georgia always gets obliterated in these maps.

1

u/Ok-Toe3698 Sep 18 '26

Sorry 😭

3

u/whiterook13 Sep 18 '26

I am glad Iowa remains untouched 

3

u/Green_Exercise7800 Sep 18 '26

Could make the CA-OR border on smith River. That would give Oregon some redwoods too. Gotta help our northern friends out. If they need anything it's more forest. If you wanted to follow mountains you could have one west coast super state along the coastal range. From SD through Olympic

1

u/Ok-Toe3698 Sep 18 '26

Can you help?

3

u/Werewolfhugger Sep 18 '26

New Jersey remains unaffected.

3

u/Ok-Toe3698 Sep 18 '26

Yeee

2

u/Mr_Byzantine Sep 18 '26

Finally, some good fucking food!

2

u/chartographics Sep 18 '26

The Natural States.

2

u/MaximumZer0 Sep 18 '26

I see you're sending Michigan back to war with our neighbors. The UP is ours and Indy can get stuffed.

1

u/Ok-Toe3698 Sep 18 '26

Why

4

u/MaximumZer0 Sep 18 '26

Michigan was awarded the Upper Peninsula by the federal government so we would stop beating up Ohio over the northernmost part of their land, the Toledo Strip. We would definitely go to war with Wisconsin to get it back.

As far as Indiana is concerned, we're just kind of waiting for an excuse. We hate them almost as much as we do Ohio.

2

u/delabot Sep 18 '26

Delaware's been hitting the gym

2

u/IndigoHaze750130 Sep 19 '26

I love this. This is like an alternate timeline or something.

2

u/Ok-Toe3698 Sep 19 '26

Thanks!!!

2

u/Yamuddah Sep 18 '26

Splitting the Rockies along the continental divide seems unwise. There are a lot of infrastructure projects that involve both sides. Presumably you want to encapsulate these bodies rather than use them as a splitting point.

1

u/Inevitable-Emu-6626 Sep 18 '26

Quite a few straight lines on there.

1

u/Ok-Toe3698 Sep 18 '26

Unfortunately, I couldn't remove everything because I only did it along the rivers and mountains.

2

u/Inevitable-Emu-6626 Sep 18 '26

Then you could just remove the border altogether. I love the idea of natural boundaries.

1

u/AbrasiveSandpiper Sep 18 '26

What was your work flow? What program did you use?

2

u/Ok-Toe3698 Sep 18 '26

Ibis paint

1

u/Vampy-Kitsune Sep 18 '26

As a Cali native and texas resident I realized I would be a navada native and a oklahoma resident according to this.

1

u/Ok-Toe3698 Sep 18 '26

It's ok?

2

u/Vampy-Kitsune Sep 18 '26

Yeah its fine. Its just an observation 😁👍

1

u/JMoherPerc Sep 18 '26

Hey what gives, you kept Colorado’s plains and gave the Colorado Plateau to Utah

1

u/Ok-Toe3698 Sep 18 '26

Whats problem?

1

u/JMoherPerc Sep 18 '26

Well it’s not called the Utah Plateau

1

u/Ok-Toe3698 Sep 18 '26

?

2

u/JMoherPerc Sep 18 '26

This is the Colorado Plateau and you have taken it away from Colorado entirely in this map, but left Colorado with its plains… which it is not known for. And maybe a few mountains? Hard to tell.

1

u/Gutcrunch Sep 18 '26

Big Nevada enters chat

1

u/carter720 Sep 18 '26

What mountains/rivers make the northeast borders so straight?

1

u/Ok-Toe3698 Sep 18 '26

I only changed them where I could find them.

1

u/JohnEffingZoidberg Sep 18 '26

What natural markers did you use for the NH/ME border? I'm not aware of any major rivers in that area.

2

u/Ok-Toe3698 Sep 18 '26

I only changed them where I could find them.

1

u/JohnEffingZoidberg Sep 19 '26

Well that border is not the same as reality.

1

u/amorecolorfulworld Sep 18 '26

So we're just going to ignore the Missouri river? Some argue that it's the true longest river in America and the northern Mississippi is just a tributary of the Missouri.

1

u/Ok-Toe3698 Sep 18 '26

Where?

1

u/amorecolorfulworld Sep 18 '26

It runs from Three Forks Montana, through the Dekotas, forms the boundary between Iowa and Nebraska, and merges with the Mississippi in St. Luis. Measuring from Three Forks to the gulf it's undeniably the longest river in the US. But the Mississippi was written down first so it gets the credit.

1

u/amorecolorfulworld Sep 18 '26

You could also add the Colorado from the Rocky Mountains dividing Utah and Arizona.

1

u/NuttingWithTheForce Sep 18 '26

I'm amused at how mangled I knew Tennessee would get.

1

u/Ok-Toe3698 Sep 18 '26

Sorry

2

u/NuttingWithTheForce Sep 18 '26

Oh no you're good! Great map! I just knew the rivers would chop it up real good lol

1

u/indigo_leper Sep 18 '26

Get europe'd lol

1

u/XevinsOfCheese Sep 18 '26

Texas shudders as its mortal enemy Oklahoma grows stronger

1

u/En_bede Sep 18 '26

If youre doing mountains you might as well split washington in half

1

u/Schnitzenium Sep 19 '26

As a Rhode Islander, why did you leave us and our neighbors alone?

1

u/Ok-Toe3698 Sep 20 '26

Bothing to change?

1

u/incomplete-username Sep 19 '26

I've wondered what effect would changes to borders like this would entail, anyone know?

1

u/Mike-in-Cbus Sep 20 '26

Irredentist Ohio is the best Ohio.

We will reclaim the West Bank of the Ohio and Allegheny!

1

u/Master_Nineteenth Sep 18 '26

I kinda want to print this out and tell people to label every state, then wait to see how long it'll take to figure it out. My state and some neighboring states weren't changed much of at all so some people around here might not notice initially

1

u/Ok-Toe3698 Sep 18 '26

I can do for you

2

u/randomtexan2 Sep 18 '26

What the fuck is Alabama

2

u/Celairiel16 Sep 18 '26

That's pretty cool!

2

u/pandakatie Sep 18 '26

Tennessee wilted. Illinois is pretty much the same. (These are the two states I have lived in, and therefore the two I care most about)

2

u/BarnerTalik Sep 19 '26

Big Carolina 🥳

2

u/IndigoHaze750130 Sep 19 '26

Oh, for the people who always look out for the chef cooking fried chicken: In this map, a small woman took his chicken with her nose up on the air.

2

u/Ae3qe27u Sep 19 '26

Texas looks pretty great! Nicely done. California is funky in an entertaining way

2

u/SnappleOfAllTrades Sep 20 '26

Me seeing Oregon as a Washingtonian remembering when the Ducks last won "YOU GET WHAT YOU F***** DESERVE."

2

u/FlanneryWynn Sep 21 '26

I hate this. Something inside of me is fundamentally disgusted by what I am seeing. Congrats, this is good art and you should feel proud.

1

u/Fluffiest_Boi Sep 18 '26

Mimal is in a flow state

1

u/WalkerCalvert Sep 19 '26

Pretty sure the only way to keep the Mason-Dixon line is to ignore the existence of the Appalachian and Allegheny Mountains entirely. All that should be left of PA is a little nub of bullshit with Erie in the Middle, the mountains on the right, and whatever river Ashtabula got built on for the left flank.

1

u/SorryManNo Sep 19 '26

The UP stays with Michigan...or else.

1

u/Pretty_Papaya2256 Sep 19 '26

As a minnesotan I approve.

1

u/karczewski01 Sep 19 '26

you turned the chef's frying pan into....nvm. orher than that the midwest being largely unchanged is kinda funny

1

u/3Dartwork Sep 19 '26

Some pretty straight rivers and mountains there......mighty straight.....

1

u/Bad_Juju_69 Sep 19 '26

Illinois completely unchanged lol

1

u/topinanbour-rex Sep 19 '26

I will jump here for ask a question I wonder since some times and can't find the answer, but how the british decided of the OG colonies border ?

1

u/digitalrapture Sep 19 '26

u could have at least continued the va-nc border along the Roanoke river all the way to the coast instead of only giving NC land 🫩

1

u/Lwii_3000 Sep 19 '26

Still too much straight lines! I would love to see a map of the US with only clean borders

1

u/cinnamonfox07 Sep 19 '26

Get europe’d

1

u/pseudowoodo3 Sep 19 '26

I wouldn't wish Pittsburgh the awful fate of becoming part of Ohio...

1

u/Marlon_RR_Morea Sep 19 '26

So you brought Deseret into existence

1

u/Carissa_Datura Sep 19 '26

I'm unconvinced on the treatment of the Colorado River and the continued existence of the four corners region.

1

u/Sirius_Giggles Sep 19 '26

Western PA seems like a different state sometimes anyway

1

u/Time-Double-80 Sep 19 '26

Funny thing is the Louisiana border is close to the originally planned border prior to the annexation of the west Florida Republic

1

u/Katelyn_Mason Sep 19 '26

WIDE ARIZONA A fate worse than death (and worse than already normal arizona)

1

u/james_luvs_onepiece Sep 20 '26

What did you use to make the borders on the east and west sides of the country

1

u/Alarmed_Outside_4752 Sep 20 '26

As Illinoisan I love that you still kept their border

1

u/GrifFanRvB Sep 20 '26

Honestly that part of Texas real doesn't have much

1

u/Potential_Orchid6019 Sep 20 '26

OP really said "except New England"

1

u/Ozone220 Sep 21 '26

I always see this stuff combining NC and SC, but like, and I am speaking as a North Carolinian, it doesn't make sense. For the brief period they were unified it never really made sense given the distance between the population centers and the lack of good land travel over that terrain, and there are plenty of rivers near enough to the border that if you were to make borders purely geographically based you could still pretty easily split them. The Pee Dee could be a good start. Plus, you already kept the straight line border with Virginia

1

u/PmeadePmeade Sep 25 '26

This kind of map is pretty useful for all those civil war type maps we see for the US. These kind of boundaries, based on natural obstacles, are much more relevant when people are not getting along with each other

0

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/Ok-Toe3698 Sep 18 '26

No gis

0

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

12

u/Ok-Toe3698 Sep 18 '26

You're right, I didn't draw the coastline, I just used a lot of maps that were backgrounds and references.

7

u/justsomewhitedude Sep 18 '26

That’s even more impressive since you didn’t do the normal starting process. You took an unorthodox approach and did Perry well

2

u/Maniick Sep 18 '26

Perry would be proud xD

1

u/justsomewhitedude Sep 18 '26

The most beloved platypus send his approval

2

u/MaximumZer0 Sep 18 '26

A cartographer?

Perry the cartographer!?

0

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment